News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Polyamorous Christian Socialist Utopia That Made Silv... by beat on Thursday January 05, 2017 @06:19PM (#13332415)
The Amanas (mentioned downthread) are still around.
Re:The Polyamorous Christian Socialist Utopia That Made Silv... by cjensen on Thursday January 05, 2017 @07:17PM (#13332765)
Sure. But according to Wikipedia, they abandoned communal ownership of property in 1932. Seems like the common thread is still that all attempts at fully communal systems fail sooner or later.

Successful group ownership of a business by the workers is pretty common; it just has to stop short of a commune.

Re:The Polyamorous Christian Socialist Utopia That Made Silv... by rmcpherson on Friday January 06, 2017 @07:12AM (#13335706)
I know of one [1], the Bruderhof, that maintains communal ownership of property and has existed for almost 100 years. It's not easy to do, though, so perhaps an exception that proves the rule. They do have some thriving businesses that make surviving in a capitalist world possible [2]. [1] source: I was born and spent my childhood there [2] http://www.communityplaythings.com/ http://www.rifton.com/
Re:The Polyamorous Christian Socialist Utopia That Made Silv... by toasterlovin on Friday January 06, 2017 @10:30AM (#13336991)
The anabaptist religious movements are fascinating. There are Mennonite sects in the US and Canada who live communally and have also lasted a relatively long time.
Re:The Polyamorous Christian Socialist Utopia That Made Silv... by beat on Friday January 06, 2017 @10:39AM (#13337083)
There's a large Mennonite colony just south of the Amana colonies in eastern Iowa. Apparently, they have little interaction (not that they hate each other, they just don't do business together), but we'd see them both. In Iowa City, we'd see Mennonites in town, actually shopping at Wal-Mart and the like. The Amanas were a much rarer sight unless you actually went to the Amana colonies (which we did regularly, because the restaurants there are some of my favorite places to eat ever).
Re:The Polyamorous Christian Socialist Utopia That Made Silv... by zepto on Thursday January 05, 2017 @07:28PM (#13332824)
It's possible that they fail because they have to operate against a capitalist backdrop.
Re:The Polyamorous Christian Socialist Utopia That Made Silv... by omginternets on Thursday January 05, 2017 @07:43PM (#13332898)
It's also possible (and, I would argue, more probable) that they fail because for any sedentary peoples, the accumulation of material wealth is inevitable, and such accumulation is unequal. Thus, some degree of "capitalist individualism" grows organically out of sedentary societies.

The only successful societies with anything resembling fully-shared ownership are those which can't accumulate much of anything.

I say this not to defend ultra-liberal capitalism or anything, but rather to point out that utopias tend to be very artificial (and therefore short-lived) constructs.

Re:The Polyamorous Christian Socialist Utopia That Made Silv... by Symmetry on Friday January 06, 2017 @08:39AM (#13336101)
It's also wrapped up in the move from hunting and gathering to farming. Hunting is relatively random and while skill plays a role you can't rely on it. Also excess meat won't last too long so why not share? Farming is more reliable and when bad luck hits it often hits an entire group at once. And it involved more unpleasant labor to farm a lot of food meaning incentives become more important.
Re:The Polyamorous Christian Socialist Utopia That Made Silv... by zepto on Thursday January 05, 2017 @07:48PM (#13332927)
Ultra-liberal capitalism is also very artificial
Re:The Polyamorous Christian Socialist Utopia That Made Silv... by omginternets on Thursday January 05, 2017 @07:54PM (#13332968)
Respectfully, that's a very loaded statement, as evidenced by the absence of a clearly-stated point. My reaction is twofold:

1. You seem to be implying that ultra-liberal capitalist societies abound. I disagree to the extent that most economies/political-systems incorporate social elements that tend to push the dial back towards resource sharing. I do, however, concede that there has been a trend towards liberalism in recent decades, but this is accompanied by increasing social instability. I don't see how your comment constitutes a counter-point in this respect.

2. It's not really artificial given the two priors discussed above:

    a) accumulation of wealth (and the subsequent inequalities in entrains)

    b) low social trust

Again, this should not be interpreted as a defense of ultra-liberal capitalism, but I think it's so entrenched precisely because it follows naturally from the aforementioned preconditions.
[dead]
Re:The Polyamorous Christian Socialist Utopia That Made Silv... by beat on Friday January 06, 2017 @10:43AM (#13337110)
It's a little loaded to call 19th century religious communes "communist", because it conflates them with Marxism and especially Leninism/Stalinism. These aren't people who build nuclear weapons and invade Poland.

It's kind of like conflating Christians with Baha'i', because they're both monotheistic.

Re:The Polyamorous Christian Socialist Utopia That Made Silv... by firebones on Thursday January 05, 2017 @10:33PM (#13333703)
One interesting thing from the aforementioned (or below-mentioned) wikipedia entry for the Amana Colonies is that they adopted the notion of a basic income (of $25-$50) to be spent at village stores, keeping the money within the community.

This is one take on UBI I haven't seen before--directly channeling collective money back into the local economy.