News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:More Evidence that Refined Carbohydrates, not Fats, Threa... by gruseom on Sunday May 09, 2010 @08:00PM (#1333100)
The article contains this astonishing statement: the meta-analysis "found no association between the amount of saturated fat consumed and the risk of heart disease". No association! Yet this has been public-health, government, industry dogma for more than a generation. The history of this catastrophe has barely begun to be written.
Re:More Evidence that Refined Carbohydrates, not Fats, Threa... by eavc on Sunday May 09, 2010 @09:52PM (#1333294)
"In Defense of Food" has an interesting account of how that came to pass.

Basically, scientists told the politician, "We don't know what's causing it. Our advice is to eat less meat and dairy and less food overall."

The politician said, "I can't say that. I live in an agricultural state! I need something more specific to say... What's in meat and diary that MIGHT be to blame?"

And thus, fat and saturated fat were thrust into the mainstream as things to avoid despite there being little to no evidence to that point.

Re:More Evidence that Refined Carbohydrates, not Fats, Threa... by jseifer on Sunday May 09, 2010 @09:56PM (#1333307)
Do you have sources for that info? I would love to read more about how the whole saturated fat recommendation came to be widely accepted.
Re:More Evidence that Refined Carbohydrates, not Fats, Threa... by JunkDNA on Monday May 10, 2010 @07:35AM (#1334104)
About 10 years ago the journal Science had a cover story review article called "The soft science of dietary fat". It's likely still behind a paywall, but that was the single best summary on this topic I have ever seen. I remember it went on at length about how the original research had been simplified by governments and policy groups because it was impractical to tell people which fats were OK.
Re:More Evidence that Refined Carbohydrates, not Fats, Threa... by ig1 on Monday May 10, 2010 @04:51AM (#1333900)
Harvard Medical School Guide to Healthy Eating and Gary Taubes book on Calories both have two different arguments for how the current dietary advice became mainstream (and why it's wrong)
Re:More Evidence that Refined Carbohydrates, not Fats, Threa... by eavc on Sunday May 09, 2010 @10:02PM (#1333320)
I'm sorry, I don't have any sources other than Michael Pollan's book, "In Defense of Food," which I highly recommend anyway.
Re:More Evidence that Refined Carbohydrates, not Fats, Threa... by cdr on Sunday May 09, 2010 @10:31PM (#1333369)
Some of the claims Pollan makes are sketchy. I don't recall that passage, but I'd probably want to see a source before believing it.
Re:More Evidence that Refined Carbohydrates, not Fats, Threa... by jseifer on Sunday May 09, 2010 @10:36PM (#1333377)
Side note: I've seen Food, Inc but I haven't read his books. I thought it was a huge leap for him to go from talking about food and where it comes from to giving nutritional advice in Food Rules.
Re:More Evidence that Refined Carbohydrates, not Fats, Threa... by MikeCapone on Sunday May 09, 2010 @09:51PM (#1333290)
"Science advances one funeral at a time" -- Max Planck
Re:More Evidence that Refined Carbohydrates, not Fats, Threa... by dmm on Sunday May 09, 2010 @10:36PM (#1333378)
Try telling that to the singularity folks...
Re:More Evidence that Refined Carbohydrates, not Fats, Threa... by MikeCapone on Monday May 10, 2010 @12:34AM (#1333579)
It's not a law of nature; in certain fields, there's less of an establishment to fight and replace, so new ideas can move faster.
Re:More Evidence that Refined Carbohydrates, not Fats, Threa... by Alex3917 on Monday May 10, 2010 @03:27AM (#1333802)
I think you're missing the joke. (That is, transhumanists believe that we'll live forever.)
Re:More Evidence that Refined Carbohydrates, not Fats, Threa... by MikeCapone on Monday May 10, 2010 @09:55AM (#1334391)
Oh, I did miss the joke, which is a bit sad considering that I agree with transhumanists that fighting aging is a noble cause.

If people no longer die so much of the diseases of aging, it might cause some problems, but I think they would be small compared to the benefits (few things compared to 100-150k dying each day after getting frail and sick).

Re:More Evidence that Refined Carbohydrates, not Fats, Threa... by Andys on Sunday May 09, 2010 @08:26PM (#1333143)
It usually takes about a generation for bad ideas to pass.
Re:More Evidence that Refined Carbohydrates, not Fats, Threa... by irrelative on Sunday May 09, 2010 @10:51PM (#1333400)
It's too bad that this is the case for facts as well as ideas. Ideally science can turn on a dime when the data is overwhelming, but in practice there's a huge lag.
Re:More Evidence that Refined Carbohydrates, not Fats, Threa... by stretchwithme on Sunday May 09, 2010 @11:58PM (#1333525)
It depends on whether government gets behind a bad idea or not. Bureaucracy doesn't like diversity of thought and tends to reinforce current thinking. Look at how long its taken for alternative medicine to get blessed.
Re:More Evidence that Refined Carbohydrates, not Fats, Threa... by demallien on Monday May 10, 2010 @12:50AM (#1333606)
Huh? Bad example. "Alternative medecine" that actually works just becomes "medecine". The fact that this happens rarely is due to the fact that most products marketed as alternative medecine are a crock and don't hold up when tested. If anything, the fact that government allows these things to be marketed at all is a perfect example of bureaucracy accepting diversity of thought (when it really shouldn't!)
Re:More Evidence that Refined Carbohydrates, not Fats, Threa... by Andys on Monday May 10, 2010 @02:04AM (#1333709)
I'd rather the government accept medicines with centuries of empirical evidence than lab-synthesised chemicals which have been pushed rapidly through official process using cherry-picked clinical trials and promises of lucrative paid positions for soon-to-be-ex-FDA officials.
Re:More Evidence that Refined Carbohydrates, not Fats, Threa... by demallien on Monday May 10, 2010 @09:35AM (#1334347)
Citation needed.

But seriously, as far as I'm aware (and I try to stay current on this topic), there is no 'medicine' out there with "centuries of empirical evidence" that isn't already accepted. There are loads of compounds that claim to be effective, but when tested they are found to be no better than placebo.

Even if a compound is found to be effective, it isn't enough to make a good medicine. The active ingredient needs to be identified, extracted, and stabilised in a product that allows doctors to safely control the dose that a patient receives. Skipping all of that work and just trying to take an uncontrolled substance is dangerous - you can't tell if the active compound has broken down, or just isn't present in a particular sample, or conversely, is present in dangerous amounts. Furthermore, the naturally occurring compound may have other, undesirable compounds included with it.

Modern medicine aims to control for all of this, and yes, the complexity can be off-putting compared to the simplicity of "natural" solutions, but there are good reasons for that complexity existing.

Re:More Evidence that Refined Carbohydrates, not Fats, Threa... by Robin_Message on Monday May 10, 2010 @09:34AM (#1334346)
That is a false dichotomy and you know it.

What you want, and everyone wants, is fair, unbiased testing of any medicine, regardless of origin. Peer reviewed science and FDA approval tests are not perfect, but in the vast majority of cases they are better than "centuries of empirical evidence." The placebo effect is very real; if people are paying money, betting their lives, and putting potentially dangerous compounds into their bodies (whatever the origin), then we'd like better than that.

Also, I would add that alternative medicines tend to fail by not working at all, whereas (what we'll call) lab medicines tend to fail by having unforeseen, unexpected, longer-term side effects.

Re:More Evidence that Refined Carbohydrates, not Fats, Threa... by jseifer on Sunday May 09, 2010 @08:26PM (#1333144)
No kidding. Now we need more research about how bad unsaturated fat is for you.