Re:What Business is Wall Street In?
by daniel-cussen on Sunday May 09, 2010 @02:57PM
(#1332640)
My understanding is that game theory isn't there yet, so you can't do a first principles market approach. But one should still try to make things work better and more elegantly.
It's also hard to really "design" markets in an overarching way; they tend to be nothing but formalizations of and patchwork fixes to various existing practices. The stock market, for example, is a formalization of the paper-stock-trades market with an attempt at improving transparency and reducing fraud; the commodities exchange market is similar for commodities, with the additional goal of providing a clearance mechanism to get counterparty risk out of the picture; etc.
Is it to enact hard to enforce ambiguous anti hacking laws, while at the same time individually patching each exploit with unrelated fixes?
Or is it to step back and analyze why a system has so much hackable complexity, and seek to fix the overarching issues that create security vulnerabilities?
I would much rather see fundamental suggestions about how to optimize the market for fairness from the ground up rather than patchwork fixes like the dollar a trade tax, or the 5 year tax break.