Re:First China-U.K. Freight Train Departs as Xi Seeks to Lif...
by mikeash on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @06:28PM
(#13323144)
Ships are about 2.5x more efficient than trains according to this: http://business.tenntom.org/why-use-the-waterway/shipping-co...
Drag is indeed huge, but so are the ships.
One interesting thing about ships is that drag depends heavily on speed. If fuel efficiency becomes a greater concern, they can go a bit slower to compensate. Of course, that increases other costs....
Re:First China-U.K. Freight Train Departs as Xi Seeks to Lif...
by Ericson2314 on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @10:13PM
(#13324399)
I'm thinking if we built it train the size of a container ship and rolled it at 15 knots, it would probably be more efficient. But we won't, so I rest my case.
Re:First China-U.K. Freight Train Departs as Xi Seeks to Lif...
by mikeash on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @10:18PM
(#13324419)
Yeah, I bet ship-sized trains would be more efficient. I think there may be some practical difficulties in building such things though.
Re:First China-U.K. Freight Train Departs as Xi Seeks to Lif...
by Ericson2314 on Thursday January 05, 2017 @08:30AM
(#13326935)
Oh yeah definitely. Also cause scaling maybe making decent efficient bearings would be nigh impossible and it still would be less efficient.
I know a recreational motorboat is less efficient than a car by a lot, but...scaling.
Oh engineering with so many trade-offs and sad realities. I'm glad I work in a field of rediculous low-hanging fruit.
I'd think the drag of ships in water vs rail in air would also be far, far greater, but I've never taking fluid mechanics and trains do move a lot faster.
Then again one ship can carry as much as 50 trains or so?