Responding to the comment itself: the idea behind reduced workweeks is that some jobs become more productive with fewer hours worked. But those are probably all white collar jobs.
I'd say there's something deeply, fundamentally broken in a society if the very thought of people being able to live while working less seems so anathema.
Shoot an email to the mods, I'm sure they'll restore it.
Looking at rebootthesystem's previous comments, a couple are a bit heated but in general it's decent quality. I've made worse comments than that one without getting flagged myself; assuming good faith goes a long way.
We are talking about something that is nonsense.
What are we talking about?
People ought to be able to work no more than six hours a day.
Really?
Why does anyone work eight? Or ten? Or twelve?
Did this 8 to 10 hour per day thing get sprung on people and forced upon them from nowhere?
No. Of course not. It's something that achieved a "natural" balance over decades (centuries?). And the balance has hundreds of variables driving it. From personal happiness to international competitiveness and productivity with even more variables across varied industries and cultures.
Nonsense is picking a number out of thin air, be it six or four hours and proclaiming that, not only will this work but it will result in happiness and a real improvement in employment figures.
It's like going into an ecosystem with some balance and killing off all the rats. There will be consequences. And they will likely not be positive.
You can't force a nation into a six hour work day without leaving behind measurable destruction. And this destruction would range from the personal (individual, family, kids, social groups) to corporate and national. You just can't do that and expect positive results.
This isn't about not liking the idea of working less and devoting more time to "living life". No, this has nothing to do with that. It has to do with the reality that these decisions exist in the reality of a very complex local, regional, national and international competitive marketplace.
A change of the sort being discussed would forcefully move away from a balanced position that allows everyone to earn a reasonable living, companies to remain viable while facing a myriad of competitors operating under different rules and society to function.
And so, proposing that people would be happy while facing a massive change in their standard of living, their ability to save for their future, feed their kids, take trips, have free time (because they will need two jobs), etc. simply isn't in alignment with reality.
To further propose that this would also improve employment is equally misplaced because this metric --the number of people being employed-- isn't a measure of anything other than a head count. A more useful measurement would combine head count with standard of living, savings rate, leisure time, quality of child care, etc.
These conclusions are faulty to such an extent that suggesting this approach would work could only be done from a less than lucid frame of mind.
In other words, it's nonsense and you'd have to be on dope to believe it would actually make society better.
Could we make such a thing work?
Yes, we could.
How?
Through massive global changes that are likely to require centuries to achieve. In other words, Star Trek territory. Not impossible, but, today, highly improbable because it would require dozens of nations to agree on terms and coordinate such changes over extended periods of time while making significant concessions.
People work 8 hour days because left wing labour movements, unions, and politicians argued for it. Much like some people in Sweden are doing now. Some companies / countries tried it and found it to be good, so it spread. Prior to that working days would be between 10 and 16 hours, six days a week. I'm sure many people argued as you are now, 'only the lazy want to work less than 16 hours a day', 'it won't work logically', 'it will be impossible to implement'. Turns out they were wrong and you probably are too.
Did this 8 to 10 hour per day thing get sprung on people
and forced upon them from nowhere?
No. Of course not. It's something that achieved a
"natural" balance over decades (centuries?).
Nonsense.In the United States, the eight-hour day for everyone came from the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1937. Australia got it state by state starting in 1916 (Victoria 8 Hours Act) and nationally in 1948. The Mexican constitution of 1917 also prescribed an 8 hour day. None of these are "centuries" old.
Obviously, individuals and unions demanded shorter working hours before these acts were passed. However, if you look at the spread of these demands, it all happened pretty fast--and at a time when communication and coordination were significantly more difficult than at present.
I don't know the answer to this. It'd be interesting to understand how long the work day was in ancient times. Egypt, Greece, Rome, etc.
Even with slavery, there had to be a forced optimization of labor hours simply due to the fact that people would get sick or even die if subjected to unreasonable schedules.
The world somehow seems to have achieved labor balance at eight hours per day. It's interesting that this seems to be the case in most nations and cultures on the planet. That's what I mean by it being the "natural" work day.
To force something different at a national level (less or more hours) would put that particular nation at odds with other nations. It would also have detrimental effects at all levels, from the individual to the nation itself.
I insist these changes are possible but not through forced legislative approaches. This is where I think, in the long term, robotics and AI will have a positive effect on society. If less people can produce more in less time and we can figure out how to cope with the societal changes this will spur, we could be on a path where people will be able to exist with much less (in financial terms) yet have good lives and achieve balance.
I can almost see an evolutionary path towards what today looks like utopia. I just don't know how to get there. Being in robotics myself I always worry about what it means to make machines that can displace humans. Not sure where the answers on that might lie.
And using terms like "bullshit" and "hippie logic" and calling that "being honest" does not serve the discussion, rather whatever need your ego has to invalidate the expressions of others.
Despite what your grandparents have been through, I bet they'd slap you if you spoke to them as rudely as the way you've addressed everyone here.
Being offended is one of those really weird states of mind.
It is purely one that is created by the person who becomes offended.
For example, in some cultures crossing your arms while someone is talking to you can be deemed offensive. In other cultures burping is perfectly fine while in others it is not acceptable.
Leaving cultures behind, people, individuals, become offended for a huge variety of things and it varies from person to person.
The difference here (and other fora) is that those who choose to be offended pile on and engage in down-vote wars that are utterly meaningless. Being offended serves exactly zero purpose and does nothing whatsoever to the facts.
The facts in this case are that a national reduction of hours work --for everyone, not just someone's wife-- is a nonsensical and destructive an idea as can be. You can't force something like that without severe consequences.
The "hippie on dope" comment was merely a colorful way to describe the state of mine someone would have to be in to think that this is a good idea at a national level.
And people get offended. Hilarious.
It's not about "getting offended". I told you to tone it down because your comment is unnecessarily hostile. If you, as you say, didn't intend it to be hostile you should take my comment even more seriously: You're coming across as increasingly hostile and rude in each new post you wrote.
Calling somebody a hippie with hippie logic just because you disagree with it? That's not a reasonable thing to do. It's not something I, or I'm sure even the person you were talking to, got offended about - it's just unnecessary and veers the discussion from "friendly chat" to "argument where everyone has their guards up".
That's not ok, nobody wants HN to be that.
If you think this isn't a reasonable think to ask, then what are you doing here?
Please stop. You are reading what you want to read and not what was written.
Where did I call someone a hippie?
I called it "hippie logic". This is what I said:
> What kind of hippie logic is this?
I did not call a person a hippie.
And, besides, since when is hippie a pejorative anyway?
It's like saying "drunken logic". You are not calling someone a drunk.
Geez.
Nah, people are just choosing to be offended because that's a thing today and piling-on with a holier-than-thou attitude is easier and if feels good.
Funny thing about choosing to be offended --and it is a choice: Nothing happens. Your head does not explode. You can still walk and chew gum at the same time. It's one of those empty things people seem to love doing these days. They also believe they have an inherent right to never be offended by anything. Pretty funny considering the times we live in.
It's OK. I get it. Still doesn't change the truth of the argument one bit. It is a great way to not have to argue facts though. Get a dozen people to be offended and very soon we are talking about that and nothing more.
Do you know what would have been a far better response? To completely ignore the utterly insignificant "hippie logic" part and actually go after my argument.
Stop already. I told you it has nothing to do with "being offended", merely keeping the tone friendly on a forum where that's appreciated.
Nobody is getting offended. If anyone is, that would be you.
> To completely ignore the utterly insignificant "hippie logic" part and actually go after my argument
Why do you think I vouched your comment?
Yet you chose to ignore that and instead, keep arguing about how "bullshit" it is that you're getting piled on.
Take the damn hint.
Reflecting upon these various exchanges I had a feeling that there's something odd at play. You see, people such as yourself have consistently misconstrued or misunderstood what I've been saying, both in tone and content. Your last comment is no different. At first I thought it was just people choosing to be offended for a truly silly comment intended more as a joke than anything else. A friendly jab, if you will.
Yet, I did not say or mean what you say I said or meant. Not once. And so I wonder if there's a language barrier of some sort at play here. Either that or a simple case of text-based communications being imperfect enough at times that it can lead to people reading something very different from what the author meant to say.
I have a feeling it's a bit like this scene, where two people almost come to blows due to a misunderstanding in language and intent:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XguKaKMMKaM
I'll leave it at that.
I'm fairly certain there is some form of language barrier at play here which is why myself and many others have been trying to engage with you rather than dismissing your messages.
You have a lot of people reacting negatively to the tone and language you used in your post; insisting on phrasing such as "hippie logic" and just generally taking a negative stance in the replies.
I want to highlight this: nobody here is getting offended at your posts. Likewise, nobody talking to you about tone is calling out the meat of your argument.
You replied to a post further down saying "The validity of an argument is absolutely independent of the messenger". Yet, that post did not question the validity of your argument. It questioned the language you used, which is entirely dependent on the messenger.
MaulingMonkey already tried explaining this to you: this is a super ineffective debate technique. You're getting people to flag your post instead of getting them to read it. HN is not a community that rewards "who speaks the loudest".
I also understand you may genuinely think it's "hippie logic" and in your view, you're just "telling it like it is" by calling it so. Let me put it this way: In my view, believing in an all-knowing all-loving deity is crock. But if I'm engaging a theist especially if I'm going to debate with them, I'm going to respect them and their viewpoint even if I don't believe or disagree with it. And here, you may well be engaging with people who believe in that hippie logic; if you want to convince them otherwise, not using that language will go a long way to get your point across.
You can email me (it's on my profile) if you want to discuss this more in private.
If we were talking face to face and I said "man, that's just a silly argument" or "you must be drunk to think that way" you'd know it was offered in a friendly tone not in a negative aggressive one.
My mistake: I should have added a happy face.
Thanks for your patience. Be well.
PS. I've pretty much given up debating theists. Not enough hours in a day (there's a pun there somewhere).
If you can't communicate your ideas to people without muddying the waters with random stuff that distracts from whatever you are trying to communicate, you have failed. And if you don't care whether or not anyone understands you, then there's no point in even attempting to communicate with other people.
It doesn't matter if everyone else on the planet is brainwashed, or if you aren't as wise or articulate as you think you are (only one of those explanations are true, we can let Occam's Razor decide). It doesn't matter. It's your responsibility to read the room and communicate in a way that conveys whatever your meaning is without distracting from it. This applies just as much to Real Life as it does to Internet forums. This is never going to stop being a socially and professionally stunting problem for you; the rest of the world is not going to wake up one day and suddenly find you charming and insightful.
Everything you're saying could be 100% true, but you'd still be the person screwing up whatever it is you're trying to accomplish.
Sometimes I want to call nonsense nonsense and bullshit bullshit. I have those days. We all do. Today was one of them.
I am not going to apologize for something adults ought to be perfectly capable of dealing with. So much time wasted focusing on the style of the message rather than the argument itself. That's a choice made by the reader. Just like someone listening to rap music can choose to conclude it is foul crap and ignore the underlying messages, which may or may not be valid. The reader (or listener) makes the choice.
I have yet to see a solid argument showing that the statement I responded to was nothing more than nonsense. I repeat it here for convenience:
> Then again, the hours that were cut also wouldn't have to be paid to the people not working them. In a perfect situation this would have led to higher employment numbers and happier employees.
Slicing it up and paraphrasing:
"they would have received a 25% cut in pay"
"they would have to hire more people to make up for the deficit in man-hours"
"people would be happier"
"employment would increase"
So:
We pass a law that says "people can only work six hours".
Everyone loses 25% of their pay. Whole households.
Companies still need to make widgets so they run more shifts and hire more people.
Yet now entire households have a severe income deficit.
People are forced to make ends meet and either work double shifts or look for a second job.
This does not lead to happier employees, happy families, good family life, well-cared-for kids, etc.
And so, the statement is nonsense. People get paid less, work more and are miserable. They are not going to be happy and the higher employment numbers are fake and useless. This is as close to nonsense as one can get and yes, it'd take a very unique state of mind to think this a sensible idea.
Offensive? So be it. It happens to be the truth.
Correct, that part's fine.
The part that comes off as hostile is equating everyone who would be fine with a 25% paycut to being a "single hippie who wants to smoke dope all day and have no responsibilities" - certain implications of lawlessness ("dope" being illegal in various parts of the world, and frowned upon by many) and sloth (a vice or sin in various religions.)
Perhaps that wasn't your intent, but that's how you're coming across to me - and perhaps others. And as it doesn't actually help your argument in any way, I must ask you the same: Why waste paragraphs?
> That's part of the problem these days. You can't call bullshit bullshit because people get offended.
Bullshit.
People tend to forget this one as well. Some of the most foul rap music out there is authored and sung by people who have been in prison and have a hard time putting two coherent sentences together. Yet, in some cases, the arguments they put forth are perfectly valid.
People flag because they are offended. I find that interesting. I have never down-voted anyone for tone. I don't get offended (it's kind of a pointless state of mind). My approach is to either up-vote or do nothing. In other words, I am perfectly content with the idea that everyone needs to have the ability to say their piece without being stepped on, whether I like the tone or not.
The other interesting thing is people also fail to read and comprehend before posting a comment. Case in point, your comment:
> The part that comes off as hostile is equating everyone who would be fine with a 25% paycut to being a "single hippie who wants to smoke dope all day and have no responsibilities"
If you read my post this is not what I said. I did not equate "everyone" to this caricature purely intended to drive a point rather than be factually accurate.
In the context of a discussion where the proposal is to limit all workers to six hours a day it is far more likely true that people would be unhappy due to the massive hit in income. You can hate the messenger but the message holds.
But one's interest in attempting to engage the messenger in debate, or otherwise give them one's time, attention, and audience is not.
> The other interesting thing is people also fail to read and comprehend before posting a comment. Case in point,
I read it fully a couple times. Comprehend? I admitted as much: "Perhaps that wasn't your intent, [...]". Glad you find it interesting...?
My goal here in replying is pointing out what part of your post I thought it likely people were actually objecting to - misinterpretation or not - as I thought you were missing the mark.
> I did not equate "everyone" to this caricature purely intended to drive a point rather than be factually accurate.
And the point I'm trying to drive home here is that this use of caricatures and hyperbole is, perhaps, easier to misinterpret over the internet than you realize - and an ineffective debate technique. And polarizing. And what's getting you flagged - not the underlying message.
Communication is a two way street - part of the onus for communicating clearly does fall on you.
> In the context of a discussion where the proposal is to limit all workers to six hours a day it is far more likely true that people would be unhappy due to the massive hit in income.
Some people will be unhappy. Some people will be happy. There might be an interesting discussion as to what that breakdown looks like, both in percentages and in professions. I think we may disagree on where the lines are - to what degree it may or may not be nonsense - but it seems rather pointless to debate without at least trying to be accurate about it, yeah?