News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Headphone inline controls – how they differ on Apple iOS ... by coldtea on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @07:54AM (#13317825)
>Patenting something like that is basically the definition of "not wanting to play fair": to make a compatible device, you have to indulge Apple's rent-seeking.

Either you don't believe in patents at all, or this is a fair patent. Apple did find that workaround, others had lots of time until's Apple entry to find it, patent it themselves or open it up.

Re:Headphone inline controls – how they differ on Apple iOS ... by kelnos on Saturday January 07, 2017 @03:03PM (#13346290)
> Either you don't believe in patents at all, or this is a fair patent.

Completely false dichotomy. Patents are there to promote innovation, not to fracture technology choices, make things difficult and confusing for consumers, and disproportionately raise costs for manufacturers. There's a balance to be found between the economic pluses granted to the patent holder and the minuses inflicted on everyone else due to the patent, and in this case I feel the balance is all wrong.

Re:Headphone inline controls – how they differ on Apple iOS ... by upofadown on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @08:52AM (#13318210)
One way to look at this is that Apple used a broken patent system to achieve an unfair result. There is no way an arbitrary assortment of resistances should be patentable.

The fact that someone else could potentially do a bad thing does not absolve you of the responsibility for doing that bad thing.

Re:Headphone inline controls – how they differ on Apple iOS ... by coldtea on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @10:15AM (#13318892)
>There is no way an arbitrary assortment of resistances should be patentable.

Indeed. Which is why they didn't patent an "arbitrary assortment of resistances", but a technique that so happens to include one.