Re:P vs. NP
by coldtea on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @07:46AM
(#13317773)
>Well, this is semi-popular technical writing directed at people who are not theory-of-computation researchers.
Nothing wrong about directing a technical writing to people other than "theory-of-computation" researchers. Most people are not theory-of-computation researchers, not just laymen, but also also statistics researchers, topology researchers, geometricians, logicians, etc.
>If all scientific writing would be written like this, then all papers would be at least hundreds of pages long and skip important details.
GP obviously means all scientific writing aimed at the same kind of audience.
Theory-of-computation researchers would obviously not need such a volume at all in the first place: they already know this stuff, and they can just directly read pure research on P vs NP, not some summary of what P vs NP means.
That said, all scientific writing (including those aimed/produced by experts in a field) could take from the quality of the wording, and the attention to clarity. It doesn't mean it has to also follow the lengthy introduction to its subject.
In other words, it seems to me like we're splitting hairs, while the intended meaning was pretty clear from the GP's comment context.
Nothing wrong about directing a technical writing to people other than "theory-of-computation" researchers. Most people are not theory-of-computation researchers, not just laymen, but also also statistics researchers, topology researchers, geometricians, logicians, etc.
>If all scientific writing would be written like this, then all papers would be at least hundreds of pages long and skip important details.
GP obviously means all scientific writing aimed at the same kind of audience.
Theory-of-computation researchers would obviously not need such a volume at all in the first place: they already know this stuff, and they can just directly read pure research on P vs NP, not some summary of what P vs NP means.
That said, all scientific writing (including those aimed/produced by experts in a field) could take from the quality of the wording, and the attention to clarity. It doesn't mean it has to also follow the lengthy introduction to its subject.
In other words, it seems to me like we're splitting hairs, while the intended meaning was pretty clear from the GP's comment context.