News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by geoffc on Sunday May 09, 2010 @05:17AM (#1331769)
This works incredibly well. At my last company I fired about a third of the engineers I hired after 3 to 6 months and ended up with a great technical team. I never know how good an engineer is going to be during the interview process but after 6 months it is blindingly clear.

I am upfront about the winnowing process during the interview, it scares some candidates away but I often get a very positive reaction to this "meritocracy by proof" approach. Another advantage is you can take some flyers on people with nontraditional backgrounds and find the occasionally diamond in the rough.

Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by DavidMcLaughlin on Sunday May 09, 2010 @06:53AM (#1331827)
> This works incredibly well. At my last company I fired about a third of the engineers I hired after 3 to 6 months

Wow. I wonder, have you and this smug author ever considered that you are the problem?

Interviewing is a two-way process, it's the candidate's job to back up everything that's on their resume and make sure they present an honest view of their ability but it's also your job to decide if someone is a good fit for your team before making them quit their comfortable job and move to your start-up. By firing a THIRD of all people you convince to join your company, you are both incompetent and irresponsible. Precisely the kind of harmful deadwood people enjoy see getting fired.

Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by j_baker on Sunday May 09, 2010 @08:01AM (#1331879)
If you are convinced that someone is the perfect fit for you based on a few interviews, then you've either discovered a bullshit artist or haven't dug deep enough. Interviewing is a terrible way to make a hiring decision. We just haven't discovered a better way to do it.
Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by jacquesm on Sunday May 09, 2010 @08:11AM (#1331889)
Interviewing can definitely give you an idea about a person, bull shit artists exist (in vast numbers), but they're not that hard to ferret out at the interview stage, presuming the interviewer knows his stuff and is not some HR flunky.

The trick is that during an interview you can choose to concentrate on the person or you can concentrate on their technical skills. If you manage to concentrate on the person instead then you'll find out soon enough whether they'll be 'good' for your company. The technical stuff is the easy part.

I've never had to resort to 'trick questions' or 'test assignemnts' to find out whether or not someone is capable.

Discussing their past has been much more fruitful in spotting trouble early on.

Interviewing is an art, not a science. There has been a whole lot of fuss about google and other companies getting on the 'metrics' bandwagon. I think that only works because they can datamine tens of thousands of applications and spot interesting trends.

If you're in charge of a start-up or a mid-sized company with maybe 10 to 50 employees the number of people you will be hiring will be much lower and the hiring process itself will consume a disproportionate amount of time.

Keeping your turnover low (as in: hire the right people right away) has an immediate pay-off both in time spent as well as in keeping the peace within your organization, and not investing months of time in to the wrong people only to fire them.

Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by kls on Sunday May 09, 2010 @09:03AM (#1331948)
You hit the nail in the head, in my career I have fired 3 people (managed thousands). In the interview game to many people focus on the how long have you used X technology instead of the person themselves.

It is real easy people, interview the person and look for passion, seriously it overcomes all else. As long as the person has no obvious glaring personality flaws and passion, the rest will fall into place.

People in tech careers are for the most part self driven and want to do what they do.

If you (anyone in general) have had a problem with more than 5% of the people who have worked for you, then you may be the problem. Trust me I have meet far more incompetent tech managers than I ever have tech employees.

Who by the way are generally skeptical people who don't follow leaders that they do not respect. Given the grandparents cavalier attitude about firing tech people and the authors I would suspect that they are failing to position themselves as a leader in their technical talents eyes, and loosing their trust with every termination.

Seriously firing people does psychological damage to those that remain, it shows a lack of investment in people that resounds in their mind, it should be reserved for those that refuse to work for whatever reason.

Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by hga on Sunday May 09, 2010 @09:29AM (#1331976)
How do you figure out if purported programmers can "program their way out of a paper bag"?

As long as you have a good (enough) method for doing that I agree with everything you say above.

Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by jacquesm on Sunday May 09, 2010 @09:47AM (#1331993)
My way of addressing that part was to simply ask what the most complicated thing was they ever programmed, and then to ask one or two follow up questions about that. I've got enough field experience that just by asking that one question I'd be able to come up with a follow up question that would nail a 'poser' in one go, if the answer was satisfactory I'd let it go at that and assume they're telling the truth, if not then I would ask one or two more follow up questions and by then I'd usually know for sure if someone is fibbing or just nervous (people can be very nervous during interviews, the bigger problem to me always was to not discard 'good' people that are simply nervous and botch answers to questions rather than the fear of hiring the wrong person because they manage to bamboozle me).

Another thing I did was to take as much time as I wanted during an interview, I would schedule at most one interview per half day just to make sure that I didn't have to cut an interview short. This made the interview process more relaxed and on the whole gave me enough time to figure out what made someone tick. Most interviews were over very quickly anyway, but every now and then it took a long time to get a feeling for whether or not someone would fit.

One of my biggest discoveries was that when hiring someone good that they would refer their friends, and they would be pretty critical about who they'd refer, screening out a lot of potential duds for me without any effort on my part.

In the Toronto office we ended up hiring four guys that already knew each other previous to joining the company.

This can also work against you, another 'group of friends' applied and I would have been happy to hire just one of them, he stuck with his friends instead.

I once hired a guy that just wanted to learn how to program but did not yet have the ability. This was a risky move, because as a startup you don't really have the time to invest a lot of it in to a person that is not yet proven. But it worked out very well, and Jeffrey actually was one of our most reliably productive people, in part because we gave him a chance that probably nobody else would have.

Sometimes having a will and a drive trumps technical ability.

Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by hga on Sunday May 09, 2010 @09:59AM (#1332006)
Interesting.

I've never had the luxury of hiring a non-programmer to learn on the job, but I can see how it could work out. But perhaps you mean "technical ability when hired". I certainly am willing to let someone learn a lot of stuff on the job, including a new language.

However I quibble with your last point, or at least say that some jobs require an ability to grok abstraction, recursion and/or pointers and that no amount of will can overcome an inability to do that.

I'll also note that some paradigms cannot be quickly learned by most. I observed that in general for OO when it became "the thing" in the '90s and I suspect functional programming also takes "more than a month". E.g. one thing I'm saying here is that you couldn't necessarily expect a procedural programmer who already knew C to be able to really learn C++ or Java in a month. Yeah, they could learn how to write C in those languages, but learning the OO paradigm took longer.

Then again, the OO paradigms I learned (which did not include any Smalltalk ones) were both very hard (to get right) and I now think they are also very wrong. Learning functional programming might be much easier for those with flexible minds.

Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by jacquesm on Sunday May 09, 2010 @10:02AM (#1332011)
Hence the 'sometimes', that one person was an exception both in that I hired him without the ability to program yet and in the fact that he actually came through in the end, I doubt that that is something you should try to repeat. I just got lucky.

The way I found him was that his father was the cleaner at our offices and if I would please give his son one chance. I did and I never regretted it for one second.

Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by gruseom on Sunday May 09, 2010 @01:08PM (#1332374)
Then again, the OO paradigms I learned (which did not include any Smalltalk ones) were both very hard (to get right) and I now think they are also very wrong.

Based on this and your other comments, I'd like to hear more about how you came to this conclusion. This isn't the right thread for it, though... perhaps, if you're interested in writing about it, you could make a new post?

Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by hga on Sunday May 09, 2010 @02:11PM (#1332524)
I can put it simply: the only thing worse than an imperative style with side effects is one where the side effects are chained, in this case through a set of interacting objects. I came to it from the hard experience of doing it, e.g. think sequence diagrams; the methodology was OOSE.

However lately I have been wondering about the utility of this approach for GUIs.

Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by gruseom on Sunday May 09, 2010 @02:30PM (#1332585)
That's been my experience too. "Object model" almost always translates to "spaghetti". The promise of OO -- that objects would provide a flexible abstraction mechanism for writing software at the level of the domain while encapsulating low-level details -- has not been realized in practice.
Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by kls on Sunday May 09, 2010 @09:21PM (#1333248)
I think the promise can be realized in pure UI and AI other than that it is much a-due about nothing. COCOA is a good example of pure UI, as well as some of the JavaScript UI kits. I.E Dojo or YUI. Given that UI objects are well encapsulated via OO is is a natural fit. When you get back to the service layer, you end up either writing overly complex OO stuff or butchering the language to make it functional.

Thankfully Rich Internet Applications are cleanly separating these concerns and you can use an OO toolkit for pure UI and a functional language the stand up RESTful services.

The days of bastardized JSP/HTML/TILES/STRUTS/Kitchen sink are numbered, for just that reason. Trying to shoehorn all of these technologies into a server side OO framework was becoming way to cumbersome.

Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by hga on Sunday May 09, 2010 @03:55PM (#1332758)
You left out that the promise of reuse doesn't seem to be borne out and is perhaps harder when doing OO than in other domains. Probably because side effects are more pervasive and it's damned hard to design good object hierarchies (and heaven help those who don't have the discipline to keep their class relationships in a directed acyclic graph).

Modularity is a win and OO only superficially encourages it.

Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by vitovito on Sunday May 09, 2010 @04:37PM (#1332816)
I haven't interviewed as a programmer in a long time, so I'm curious, what defines "the most complicated thing was they ever programmed?"

Algorithmic complexity, like a graph database or a computer vision system or an AI? Does it matter if they just read a bunch of papers and implemented the formulas? Does it matter if they used libraries like OpenCV? Does it matter if they decided the best implementation path was to outsource it and use a SaaS like DirectedEdge?

Social complexity, like a Facebook or Meetup or Digg? Does it matter as to whether they came up with the technical architecture or social architecture to actually process all those votes and friend requests and event managements, versus just doing what the tech arch or design lead told them to do?

I've implemented device drivers in x86 assembly (a well-trod path and it wasn't very original work) and AI (for a video game, original work but with lots of abstractions provided) and an embedded systems JPEG block rewriter in C (abused the spec to create something very original, but was ultimately only a few dozen lines of code when all was said and done). Which of these is "most complicated" and why?

Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by jacquesm on Monday May 10, 2010 @07:24AM (#1334088)
Sorry for the sluggish response, I completely missed your comment.

Any one of the answers you gave there would have sufficed to be used as the 'platform' for further discussion, if you had named those three with the 'Which of these is the most complicated and why?' I think if would have led to a very interesting discussion about your past work for a bit.

Let's take the video game AI as an example. My follow up question would have been something along the lines of 'That's an interesting one, what kind of behavior did your AI govern, and how did you go about implementing that?' or 'How did you protect your AI from getting stuck in a loop or becoming too predictable?', or any one of a bunch of questions about the sort of thing you run in to when you build a video game AI. I'd know pretty quickly if you actually did write a video game AI (I wrote a bunch of video games, and even though I wouldn't class the routines governing the bots as 'AI' I think I can relate enough to the problem domain to come up with some questions) or if you're making it up.

For myself, if someone would ask me that question I'd answer a fully integrated cad-cam system for lathes and mills. That one kept me busy for two years, ended up as about 50K lines of high level code and another 20K of assembler to make it fast. The hardest part there for me was the equidistant operation, it took me quite a while to get it right because I'm weak in the mathematical department, it's actually one of the few times in my programming career that I got so stuck on a problem that I hired a tutor to brush up on the required math.

Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by kls on Monday May 10, 2010 @09:32AM (#1334340)
In my opinion that is the easy part, It is a testable skill (not trick questions). I always have a dummy environment set up with a skeleton app set up and once I am down to the last few quys I ask them to write something from scratch. Generally something simple like a CRUD screen that takes no more than an hour. I generally pair with them and work as a sound board to work out the problem with them. It is very natural and puts a real developer in an environment they are comfortable with. As soon as they see an IDE and no trick questions, the good ones tend to fall into a groove. The cool part is that I have learned so many tricks from many of these sessions.
Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by geoffc on Sunday May 09, 2010 @12:27PM (#1332279)
>Wow. I wonder, have you and this smug author ever considered that you are the problem?

I'm positive I am part of the problem but I haven't found a better way for me to build a top notch team given my skill set and inclinations. As we grew I hired a good engineering manager who was able to reduce that ratio significantly.

To reiterate, in the interview process I explicitly lay out the methodology and all the risks involved as I understand the pain, stress and cost that a failed hiring causes. The end result of all of this was a very talented and efficient team that produced a great product which dominates it's vertical.

Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by philk on Sunday May 09, 2010 @08:06AM (#1331881)
I'm not sure it's possible to make the right choice every time when hiring - and even if he's firing a third of his hires it means that he's getting it right two thirds of the time.

Given how lousy interviewing is as a method for discerning quality employees, I'm not sure that's a bad result.

Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by rnugent on Sunday May 09, 2010 @01:35PM (#1332439)
This ain't Baseball, it's a horrible result. I would NEVER hire a manager or leader that fired a full 1/3 of his hire. It just shows a lack of any kind of management skill and behavior like this will quickly tell your remaining 2/3rds that you are not very good at management. They will leave soon thereafter. Now, I realize that a lot of the folks on YN are young and probably thrust into their first management role without any training or mentorship. Best advice I can give is to NOT discount the generations of study on this topic and try to make shit up on your own. Read a few books on how to motivate and make employees more productive and you'll be a lot more successful than the idiot blog author
Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by hga on Sunday May 09, 2010 @08:10AM (#1331888)
While I agree with the essay (will write on that next), firing a full 1/3 of those you've hired is going to be very debilitating for the organization. And not something I think most startups will be able to afford.

And if you report or have to answer to anyone, they're not likely to be impressed that you hired that many duds/people who just didn't work out.

Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by jacquesm on Sunday May 09, 2010 @08:21AM (#1331901)
> firing a fill 1/3 of those you've hired is going to be very debilitating for the organization.

Exactly, hiring the right people is good for the employees (they have steady jobs in an environment where not all the faces are new all the time) and for the company because of the high cost associated with new hires.

The cost of bringing a new employee up to speed is usually taken as anwywhere from 6 to 12 months of their gross pay, assuming they're engineering positions (and that's what we're talking about).

For other work the cost can be lower or higher depending on how much time and effort needs to be invested by the company to get a new hire up to speed on the company procedures, code base (in case of software), work out team issues and any in-house training programs.

Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by mmt on Sunday May 09, 2010 @11:00AM (#1332101)
And if you report or have to answer to anyone, they're not likely to be impressed that you hired that many duds/people who just didn't work out.

I think it's important to note that the author is writing from the viewpoint of a serial entrepreneur, which means the context is small startup environments.

Presumably he still might answer to a board, but those may all be co-founders. Regardless, I don't think they would need to be impressed by his management style so much as his end results.

Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by hga on Sunday May 09, 2010 @11:34AM (#1332150)
How many startups are funded entirely by real co-founders? Some, I'm sure, and a lot more now, but is that the exception rather than the rule?

So if you have "normal" investors, unless the board that includes them is really hands off they'll notice and I can't imagine it will help his credibility. If it's that hands off you're in trouble in that they aren't likely to be very committed to the venture.

Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by mmt on Sunday May 09, 2010 @11:54AM (#1332207)
I'm not suggesting funding entirely by co-founders but, rather, controlled by them.

It also seems a bit like speculation, unless you're a VC or angel who has seen this.

Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by rnugent on Sunday May 09, 2010 @12:30PM (#1332286)
Exactly! This concept of "firing" is the purview of assclowns. People that have no management skill yet who lust after director or VP titles after a year in the industry. These people are doomed to building small things. Small companies, small product, small careers. You better wake up and realize the world is made up of people not code.
Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by jacquesm on Sunday May 09, 2010 @08:06AM (#1331880)
I'd fire you and find someone that is better at judging fit beforehand.

A full third is really very high. Consider apprenticing yourself to someone more experienced for a while to figure out what it is that you are missing while hiring, especially if the absolute numbers are high. If you've hired six people in all your time and fired 2 of them then we'll take it as a statistical anomaly.

Out of 25 people hired I've had to fire exactly 1, but I rejected almost 95% of all applicants to open positions, not limited to the engineering department.

I think one big difference in the way we look at this is that if you hire someone you also have a responsibility to them, evaluating fit is something that is your responsibility, and failure is up to you to correct, through teaching, training and mentoring.

It seems you think that you have no responsibility for them other than to fire them when you've decided your 'extended interview' is over.

In most countries there is an agreed upon 'trial period', which allows an employer to terminate a contract without any penalties, depending on the country these periods last from 30 days to 6 months. But it is actually pretty rare to have to fire someone within that period, even if there does not have to be 'cause' a high firing rate during the trial period reflects bad on the hiring manager.

The reason for that is simple economy, hiring people and firing them within 6 months is a very bad investment for the company, that person cost almost as much in time spent getting them up to speed as a person that is productive for multiple years.

If you're hiring someone that is out-of-work and down on their luck then you could argue that something is better than nothing and you gave them a chance, if you entice people to leave a job where they've worked for years and you then end up firing because of a mis-judgment them you've caused a real problem.

Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by hga on Sunday May 09, 2010 @08:44AM (#1331927)
Urk, I had forgotten about the problem of enticing people from good jobs. Many of them will be your best employees, but if you have this sort of "fire 1/3rds" process and are up front about it you'll lose this entire talent pool.

And it won't do anything good for you company's reputation. Read Death by Lethal Reputation http://www.asktheheadhunter.com/halethalrep.htm; I'll also note that failed startup Thinking Machines (the Connection Machine company) had absolutely the worst hiring practices of any Cambridge, MA area company in the '80s (details upon request).

Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by calibraxis on Sunday May 09, 2010 @12:52PM (#1332331)
I'd like to request details on Connection Machines' hiring practices. (Or do you prefer people to privately email?) I've read some things about them, but there's usually more lore than reality in post-mortems.

I've worked mainly in startups and think that startups rarely approach their potential. The managers often comfort themselves with delusions, and the employees for their part often passively take the work they're handed.

Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by hga on Sunday May 09, 2010 @01:03PM (#1332355)
In short:

Like a men's club, one blackball from any employee and you weren't hired. I think this is documented, and I don't know how long they continued the policy (see below, I passed that test).

Early on at least they took forever to hire. E.g. I did a serious interview with them (my interview with Danny Hillis, who was part of my social circle, started with an aggressive "Why aren't you in school!??" (the answer was money)). They got back to me more than a month after that interview, by which time I'd accepted a much less desirable job (sysadmin for their Lisp Machines).

I was told they failed the second time to fill this job and that three full calendar years later (!!!) they hired a classmate of mine in their third try (I pretty much knew the entire talent pool available at the time).

We can be quite certain that damaged their productivity early on; my experience was at the very beginning of 1984 and I'm not sure they failed to hire anyone for this slot in the meantime.

In one well sourced account, they asked for a reference from an applicant's current employer (of course without clearing this with him first). Except for that case, I've never heard of anyone doing that, ever.

While they were the coolest place to work at in Boston, I can see how they might in part have suffered a "death by lethal reputation" (there are many additional and well documented reasons in the public record, of course).

Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by calibraxis on Sunday May 09, 2010 @03:30PM (#1332716)
Thanks for the peek behind the curtains. I just googled "thinking machines hiring" and came up with this article:

http://thedailywtf.com/Articles/Thinking-Machines.aspx

I agree, I've never even known a company to even verify anything on a resume, much less tip off an applicant's current employer.

Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by mmt on Sunday May 09, 2010 @11:38AM (#1332163)
I'd fire you and find someone that is better at judging fit beforehand. A full third is really very high. Consider apprenticing yourself to someone more experienced for a while to figure out what it is that you are missing while hiring

This advice seems ill-suited to someone founding a startup. A founder is a manger out of necessity, not out of an affinity for people-managing. Are such apprenticeship opportunities readily available?

As someone who has only been on the receiving end of managerial treatment, I agree, emotionally, with your position (and presumably would enjoy working for you). However, I'm not sure it makes rational sense.

It seems you think that you have no responsibility for them other than to fire them when you've decided your 'extended interview' is over.

It's important to note that it's an extended paid interview.

The reason for that is simple economy, hiring people and firing them within 6 months is a very bad investment for the company, that person cost almost as much in time spent getting them up to speed as a person that is productive for multiple years.

I've heard and read assertions to this effect before. Do you have studies (or even anecdotal evidence) you could provide that would quantify this?

This also begs the question of the overall productivity of the team, rather than any given individual, or is that what you mean by time spent getting them up to speed?

if you entice people to leave a job where they've worked for years and you then end up firing because of a mis-judgment them you've caused a real problem.

Possibly, but if the firing is from a startup and the stable job was a larger company, I suggest this is to be considered part of the risk.

I did exactly such enticing with a friend and colleague of mine to a startup which eventually failed (and again to another one, which is perhaps in the process of failing).

His original employer valued him enough that they were more than happy to have him back, even a year later. I expect this to extend to all "A players."

Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by jacquesm on Sunday May 09, 2010 @12:09PM (#1332241)
I suspect this is going to be a long thread ;)

For a start-up the rules are a bit different, but in a way for a start-up it is even more important to hire the right people rather than to use a more trial-and-error based approach to hiring.

Start-ups as a rule have less time to lose on stuff like that and replacing a person in a start-up usually carries a severe penalty. The teams are usually much smaller and dropping a team member will have a significant impact, much more so than in a larger organization (but even there it can hurt a lot). A start-up I invested in lost their #2 programmer due to a series of problems and it almost killed the company.

As for apprenticing, the possibility to learn is always present, but maybe not in your own company. When you find yourself in the need of knowledge it doesn't hurt to go through your addressbook, find someone with more experience in the field that you want more knowledge in and ask.

I've done that quite frequently in my career (and I still do that, as some HN'ers can attest to) and I've found that people are usually very happy to teach a new skill or to augment an existing one if you ask them. Of course they're not obliged and you can't make any demands but as a rule it doesn't hurt to ask.

> It's important to note that it's an extended paid interview.

Yes, that's true, there is some compensation. But I always looked at firing someone - and it fortunately was very rare - as a sort of divorce on bad terms. The better way to go about it is to talk things over, if possible help find your employee a spot where they're more in their place rather than at a high pressure start-up where the margin for error is a lot lower.

> I've heard and read assertions to this effect before. Do you have studies (or even anecdotal evidence) you could provide that would quantify this?

As a rule I ask companies where I do technical due dilligence how long it takes them to get a new hire up to speed. The companies where this goes fasted are around the 3 month mark, as a rule those companies have fairly simple systems and no long running projects or large code bases. The longest are around 2 years, these are companies that usually have a limited size in house development team, sometimes requiring skills on the cross roads of two or more disciplines working on technically complicated projects.

On average, assuming a linear increase in productivity over the time that you hire someone to the time that they are as productive as the 'old hands' it seems to work out to at least several monthly salaries of time wasted, for one because the new hire is not yet productive, but also because he/she is a drain on the members that were already productive before the hire was added to the team. The latter factor is one that is overlooked very frequently.

> This also begs the question of the overall productivity of the team, rather than any given individual, or is that what you mean by time spent getting them up to speed?

The team as a whole.

> Possibly, but if the firing is from a startup and the stable job was a larger company, I suggest this is to be considered part of the risk.

That's true, but then only if the person hired is made well aware of the risk and can balance it with a pay-off in proportion to that risk.

When I was young and without responsibilities other than to myself I would work simply on what I thought was interesting and I couldn't have cared less about the compensation, so if I would have gotten fired (which never happened, but theoretically it could have) I wouldn't have cared much about it.

Employing someone with a wife, kids and a mortgage and then throwing them out in the callous way the poster suggests, after hiring them capriciously is really bad for your business' reputation as well as for your employees.

You really don't want to get known as a company bad attitude towards new hires, the better people will simply not even apply to a company like that.

In the end all you'll get is people that more or less expect to be fired in the next 6 months.

One of the best companies that I've read about culture wise was the 'old' HP, I've done my best to try to learn as much as I could from how they treated their employees and I think it did me well. If this stuff interests you, then there is plenty of stuff documented on the web about it, there is also a book called 'the HP way', which contains a few valuable insights.

Other books that I've found great showing me bits and pieces of how to grow in to the role of a manager after being a techie all my life were 'the soul of a new machine' by Tracy Kidder and a book about the very first computers in war time England, but I can't recall the title.

> did exactly such enticing with a friend and colleague of mine to a startup which eventually failed (and again to another one, which is perhaps in the process of failing).

His original employer valued him enough that they were more than happy to have him back, even a year later. I expect this to extend to all "A players."

That's great, but the economy is not what it was several years ago, and I suspect that people leaving a good job will expect their new employers to treat them with some respect, it may be that by making such a move they are taking a considerable risk. Of course, nobody is forcing them, but it doesn't hurt to be careful with other people.

edit: I'm sorry you got modded down, I don't see any reason for that in your writing.

Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by mmt on Sunday May 09, 2010 @01:15PM (#1332392)
I suspect this is going to be a long thread ;)

Probably not, unless someone else jumps in, since I actually agree with you and am merely exercising skepticism to solidify my conclusion. [1]

As a rule I ask companies where I do technical due dilligence how long it takes them to get a new hire up to speed

At the risk of quibbling, this strikes me as a couple steps removed from anecdotal. I expect a degree of subjectivity, but without direct observation, it's merely hearsay (not entirely unlike some interviewing techniques, but I digress).

On average, assuming a linear increase in productivity over the time that you hire someone to the time that they are as productive as the 'old hands'

That's a big assumption, and one I would suggest is false for experienced technical people, especially non-programmers.

I detect an additional, implicit assumption, that a new hire's productivity will ever reach (and/or not surpass) that of the veterans around them. Similarly, you're assuming that they will, at some point, cease to be a drain on the team.

Employing someone with a wife, kids and a mortgage

I don't think it's any of an employer's concern what an employee's personal/family situation is, nor appropriate to base hiring/firing decisions on it. Fortunately, the labor laws in my jurisdiction support such a view quite strongly.

and then throwing them out in the callous way the poster suggests, after hiring them capriciously is really bad for your business' reputation as well as for your employees.

This may be true, but you haven't pointed out where capriciousness or callousness (beyond a separation of business and personal) is advocated, either by the OP or the OC.

[1] I hesitate to use the term "Devil's advocate," as it carries a connotation of absence of engagement or conviction.

Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by jacquesm on Sunday May 09, 2010 @01:59PM (#1332490)
At the risk of quibbling, this strikes me as a couple steps removed from anecdotal. I expect a degree of subjectivity, but without direct observation, it's merely hearsay (not entirely unlike some interviewing techniques, but I digress).

It's not even removed, it is anecdotal, I don't even know for sure if they are telling the truth, and possibly neither do they. But the universal component seems to be that they all agree that it takes time, so the only thing left to argue about is how much time, and hence roughly how much cost. We're talking about a fair sized sample though, so even if it isn't a research project it will hold some water.

The question is born out of my own experience that it can take some time to get a new hire trained, coupled with a bit of information about the complexity of the subject matter it usually gives me some insight in to how well their documentation is and how good their teams are at communication and dealing with integration issues.

That's a big assumption, and one I would suggest is false for experienced technical people, especially non-programmers.

I detect an additional, implicit assumption, that a new hire's productivity will ever reach (and/or not surpass) that of the veterans around them.

Not necessarily, there is probably some correlation with how fast someone gets up to speed and how far they'll go, sometimes you get lucky and you find someone that managed to outperform the people that you already had. But as time progresses the chances of that are smaller and smaller, simply because of the body of accumulated knowledge by the 'old hands'.

Similarly, you're assuming that they will, at some point, cease to be a drain on the team.

Well, everybody is a 'drain' on everybody else in that respect, but during the initial period where someone is entirely new to something that drain can be considerable.

Especially in those 'rare' cases where the documentation leaves something to be desired. Of course that would never happen in real life ;)

I don't think it's any of an employer's concern what an employee's personal/family situation is, nor appropriate to base hiring/firing decisions on it. Fortunately, the labor laws in my jurisdiction support such a view quite strongly.

No, but that doesn't mean that it hurts a lot more to fire someone for whatever reason if you know that it will affect his or her dependents as well. I agree that's arbitrary but I'm by no means perfect.

Downsizing is the hardest in this respect, it causes no end of grief, nobody did anything really wrong, but still you would have to let people go.

This may be true, but you haven't pointed out where capriciousness or callousness (beyond a separation of business and personal) is advocated, either by the OP or the OC.

I think the capriciousness is in the part where he says 'in startups, where you hire fast and loose', which is something that I don't think is necessary at all, and then corrects the failure to invest enough time in the hiring process by firing an overly large portion of his hires, most likely people that he would have never hired in the first place if he had spent a bit more time in the beginning.

Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by elblanco on Sunday May 09, 2010 @09:35AM (#1331985)
A company I know puts all new hires on 90 day probation. If, within 90 days you can't show you can begin the process of integrating, out you go. Their ratio is about 1:5, though typically they let the people resign since it's far less damaging to their future careers.

I say 1:5, which I feel is high, this number despite a rigorous technical interview process.

On a different note, another company that somehow started in small-town U.S. needed to expand their engineering staff. They looked in the Bay Area but the salary reqs were far too high so they settled on Portland. Got a team of engineers stood up in a satellite office. And then because of some minor personality conflicts and a lack of management skill failed to use them. This gave that team a bad reputation as "the team that sucks".

Now to be fair, they weren't the hottest rock-star coders in the world. But they could take a detailed spec and put out some reasonably solid work -- in other words, the absolutely normal, run of the mill developer. The problem was with the front office, not the engineers, they simply didn't know how to put together technical requirements that a remote site could follow. They conducted all of their engineering task assignments with daily, in-person staff meetings, verbally assigning tasks to engineers and writing down the task name in a development tracker (usually with lots of white board time).

A year later, the Portland team, unable to ever attend any of the daily, in-person, task assignments, and the front office unable to put together a decent set of specifications to send to a remote office, had no assignments, and a bad rep. The whole team was ultimately let go.

Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by tristan_juricek on Sunday May 09, 2010 @09:09AM (#1331953)
A third seems like an awfully high ratio; as someone else has pointed out, there are real (and immediate) repercussions from firing.

I've fired someone before, and I'd do it again. But it was a horrible experience; and I would want to avoid that kind of experience, especially for 3-6 months.

One thing that gave me a lot of confidence was to set up a peer review system. Once I saw that the group had the same instincts I had, it was a no brainer. (Peer reviews are so much more interesting on many levels, actually. I don't know why this never occurred to any of my bosses.)

Other than this, the "one week trial period" proposed in Rework (http://37signals.com/rework/) seems like a good way to avoid a "several month realization of uh-oh". Has anyone ever tried this out?

Re:There is no such thing as good hiring, only good firing by jbellis on Sunday May 09, 2010 @09:16AM (#1331963)
Marc Andreesson wrote (about hiring suits, not engineers): "if you know what you're doing, the odds of a given executive hire working out will be about 50/50. That is, about 50% of the time you'll screw up and ultimately have to replace the person. (If you don't know what you're doing, your failure rate will be closer to 100%.)" http://pmarca-archive.posterous.com/the-pmarca-guide-to-star...

From my own experience, the best team I ever worked on was one where we had a rigorous interview process... and fired 2 of the first 6 engineers, i.e., one third.