And they are fine with that too. That's the case of VC-backed startups: they accept a negative ROI to get the chance to start making money one day.
Then you have the less consciuous ones, which might be big brands who want to experiment a bit with new media/ad formats.
In any case, if you think about it, the real losers are...the honest publishers. Because the money on the table is not increased by fraud, it's just shared in a way that takes something away from good publishers to bad/fake ones.
I'd guess most of the big brands doing advertising look at it more from a brand building standpoint than a direct performance standpoint. You certainly can't compare it apples-to-apples against something like search advertising.
Ha ha, sure they do.
Brand advertisers, in particular.
You know that 1-inc by 1-inc 'video' ad playing in the corner of your screen, that vaguely has a car, but it's designed for TV and you really don't get to see 'what the product is' until the end of the spot, but by then, you've already scrolled past it?
That is 100% a waste of money for the advertiser.
There are tons of large companies with 'ad spend' and they just spend a lot of it without really knowing how effective it is.
Obviously, a lot of it it is, but many campaigns are a ridiculous waste.
They are definitely not doing that. The sheer amount of profitable arbitrage proves that point. Ad networks remain one of the best business models around, this is what Facebook is. The main problem is that there are no real barriers to entry or oversight which leads to thousands of poorly run, unscrupulous, spam/malware infested networks which make an outsized impact on both the market and consumers.
Ending it is necessary and possibly sufficient for Internet ads to stop being awful for both advertiser and publisher.
(I've worked in the space buy-side)
Outbrain/taboola style indiscriminate dealing doesn't add any value.
It would be interesting to know what proportion of total advertising spending this represents.
So essentially we've got a whole bunch of companies with no growth desperately vying for the attention of 23-year old media buyers who in turn are mostly interested in getting someone to take them clothes shopping and picking up the bill. These companies are doing it mostly by doing ever more intrusive things, since advertisers can't accept that the reason their ads don't perform is that nobody wants their stuff and keeps looking for a silver bullet.
I've come to believe that the only reasonable justification for most advertising is that it's in some sense a way for other industries to subsidize journalism. Since that's going away, I'm looking forward to the inevitable ad tech carnage ahead, and if a potential next wave actually brings higher quality advertising and better end user experiences I'll happily eat my shoes.