Re:Kaspersky: SSL interception differentiates certificates w...
by idlewords on Tuesday January 03, 2017 @07:24PM
(#13314585)
Because the simpler explanation (that this is a stupid bug) is borne out by the uniformly horrible state of AV software.
Re:Kaspersky: SSL interception differentiates certificates w...
by tptacek on Tuesday January 03, 2017 @07:37PM
(#13314674)
And also the relatively limited capability it offers to attackers, compared to other bugs in AV software.
Re:Kaspersky: SSL interception differentiates certificates w...
by btilly on Tuesday January 03, 2017 @08:49PM
(#13315033)
Now THAT is a good reason to think that this particular item is not intentional.
But I would still bet money that there is at least one intentional hole, somewhere.
It is easy to say whatever you want, but impossible to prove either way.
Kaspersky comes from Russia, and has high level connections within the Russian government. Past actions (eg their analysis of Stuxnet) have been in line with Russian foreign policy goals.
Everything that they do is easily explained by their being a normal company. But multiple things that they have done fit very well with their working for Russian policy goals in a smart way. Which theory you find more plausible depends on your level of paranoia about Russia, and how much pressure you think that Putin would bring to bear behind the scenes to force cooperation. And even if they are subject to state backdoors, any particular one might or might not be one.
I personally am inclined towards paranoia. Russia using Kaspersky would be perfectly in line with standard fare in lots of countries. For example here in the USA look at how the NSA created the FREAK attack. Or look at Lenovo's use of Superfish in their BIOS. Why would we expect Russia to be more restrained than other state actors with as tempting a channel as Kaspersky? I see no reason to expect that. No reason at all.