Re:Mark Cuban: place a 25 cent-per-share transaction fee on ...
by davi on Saturday May 08, 2010 @09:48PM
(#1331340)
Did you read the article? The proposal seems reasonable to me, much more so than your comment gives it credit for: a small per-share transaction fee which could be fed into "an annual payment towards the next time Wall Street screws up and we have a black swan event that no one planned on".
It's just an inflammatory, link-bait headline (which maybe I should edit).
-----
edit: I changed the title from its original, "Mark Cuban: Tax the hell out of Wall St. and give it to Main St.", to the current "Mark Cuban: place a 25 cent-per-share transaction fee on Wall St. trades"
Re:Mark Cuban: place a 25 cent-per-share transaction fee on ...
by Aetius on Saturday May 08, 2010 @09:52PM
(#1331345)
Not only is the title link-bait. The plan is pure red meat. We all know that it's not just financial engineering responsible for the crisis. It wasn't just Wall Street. Wall Street just happens to be Washington's latest political scapegoat. What I'm saying is beware when their attention turns westward.
Re:Mark Cuban: place a 25 cent-per-share transaction fee on ...
by davi on Saturday May 08, 2010 @09:57PM
(#1331355)
Adding a little bit of friction to vast, interconnected networks of automated high speed trades doesn't seem like the worst thing in the world to me. It seems like it might dampen otherwise wildly oscillatory behavior from the system.
Re:Mark Cuban: place a 25 cent-per-share transaction fee on ...
by yummyfajitas on Saturday May 08, 2010 @10:21PM
(#1331379)
Why do you feel that raising the bid/ask spread to $0.25 will prevent wildly oscillatory behavior?
If anything, it will probably increase strange behavior. If you want to buy shares, you'll either need to pay a largish premium or else you'll need to wait a while. Fun fact: for the most part, prices have stabilized and spreads have narrowed as HFT has entered the game.
Re:Mark Cuban: place a 25 cent-per-share transaction fee on ...
by _delirium on Saturday May 08, 2010 @10:36PM
(#1331395)
If everyone, even the huge institutional players, has to deal with non-zero bid/ask spreads, it does reduce incentive to spend a lot of effort exploiting tiny arbitrage opportunities with huge-volume trades, which could stabilize things overall. Admittedly, it's something economists disagree on.
Re:Mark Cuban: place a 25 cent-per-share transaction fee on ...
by yummyfajitas on Saturday May 08, 2010 @11:07PM
(#1331446)
It also reduces the incentive to engage in market making. This makes it more difficult to buy/sell stocks when you want to, and generally makes all trading (even the long term speculation which Cuban favors) more difficult.
Re:Mark Cuban: place a 25 cent-per-share transaction fee on ...
by hugh3 on Saturday May 08, 2010 @11:12PM
(#1331451)
Arbitrage-exploiters do the worthwhile task of removing arbitrage. Putting arbitrage back into the market, visible to everybody but which everybody will sit on their hands until it becomes worth the 25 cent fee to exploit, seems like a way to create more instability.
Re:Mark Cuban: place a 25 cent-per-share transaction fee on ...
by _delirium on Saturday May 08, 2010 @11:29PM
(#1331470)
It can add instability though, if the arbitrage-exploiting is too large a proportion of the market. If 95%+ of trades are trades based on statistical market patterns, which are themselves created by those same 95%+ of trades, you get weird feedback loops that have more to do with chaotic systems and attractors than with supply or demand.
Re:Mark Cuban: place a 25 cent-per-share transaction fee on ...
by hugh3 on Saturday May 08, 2010 @11:31PM
(#1331475)
Looking at prices of any given share for any day other than Thursday (was it Thursday?) would you say that such instability and big feedback loops are a big problem?
Re:Mark Cuban: place a 25 cent-per-share transaction fee on ...
by AKSHAYUDAYBHAT on Saturday May 08, 2010 @10:22PM
(#1331380)
Yes it would mostly dampen, but in certain case the systems might go out of control. Since no one know what are the parts of the systems its very hard to predict.
edit: you laugh now...