News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:‘Routine’ Jobs Are Disappearing by tptacek on Tuesday January 03, 2017 @01:06PM (#13311293)
Are you conceding the economics? (You probably should, unless I'm missing some subtlety of your argument.) That's really all I care about here.
Re:‘Routine’ Jobs Are Disappearing by metaphorm on Tuesday January 03, 2017 @01:23PM (#13311498)
no, I'm not conceding the economics. I don't have any hidden subtlety here, it seems fairly obvious to me that elder-care is redistributive (money from old people to their servants) rather than productive. quite a lot of service jobs are like this, except in many other cases the redistribution is not from accumulated wealth from the past, but from newly produced wealth in the present.

that might be of some net economic benefit anyway, purely on the basis of freeing up money that would otherwise be stuck in sequestration from the rest of the economy. however, I'm not sure what "flaw" in my economic claim you're trying to point out. can you be more explicit?

I would ask you, however, to actually care more about the non-economic part of the argument. I believe that's the more important part.

Re:‘Routine’ Jobs Are Disappearing by shkkmo on Tuesday January 03, 2017 @01:59PM (#13311932)
I believe the general view is that 'non value producing' service jobs add value by saving the time of and thus amplifying the productiveness of individuals with 'value producing' jobs.

If you are comparing the economic effect of a growing industry of elder care to a society where no elder care occurs, then I can see how you might draw the conclusion that growth in this industry is a waste because these are not 'value producing' jobs.

In reality, a society where no elder care occurs is not the alternative as some form of elder care would be taking place. People who work doing elder care are amplifying the productiveness of the friends, family and neighbors who do have 'value producing' jobs.

Personally, I think our current styles of elder care and our ageist biases waste a lot of economic potential and social value by wasting the time of our elders. I think that finding ways to tap this potential while providing better care for our elders would be the OPPOSITE of spiritually corrosive. As it is, many find working in elder care quite rewarding, especially when that elder care happens in less institutional and dehumanizing settings.

Re:‘Routine’ Jobs Are Disappearing by tptacek on Tuesday January 03, 2017 @01:58PM (#13311927)
This isn't even wrong. In market transactions, there's no dichotomy between "redistribution" and "productivity". There's "redistributive" tax and economic policies that governments enact, by political fiat. Those policies are almost the opposite of market transactions.

Using the definition you've proposed, it's hard to think of any service transaction, from doctors visits to architectural consults, that isn't somehow "redistributive".