Re:Adding up the cost of uncontrolled immigration
by Smutte on Tuesday January 03, 2017 @04:23AM
(#13307957)
Depending on how and where you spend it, its about $7500 or more to save a life.
http://www.givewell.org/giving101/Your-dollar-goes-further-o...
Re:Adding up the cost of uncontrolled immigration
by woodruffw on Tuesday January 03, 2017 @04:30AM
(#13307986)
But is that life worth $7500? More seriously, is a life that costs more to save more valuable?
I think the answer to both of these is an unqualified 'no.'
Re:Adding up the cost of uncontrolled immigration
by Smutte on Tuesday January 03, 2017 @04:51AM
(#13308066)
A life is a life. If one life costs 7500 to save and another costs 15000 they are both still lives if you ask me. Should you spend 15000 to save one life or 7500*2 to save 2? If the one that costs 15000 is your child? Thats complicated of course. But the numbers arent really. Again, 7500 or more. As long as you have resources to share you can choose which life to save (or if you want to spend it on a computer and time on HN and let them all perish).
Re:Adding up the cost of uncontrolled immigration
by chillacy on Tuesday January 03, 2017 @04:59PM
(#13313519)
Depends if the economics are zero sum or not, it could be that helping one group necessarily harms the other. Evidence in the article would imply that to be true, at least how we do things today. I'm not convinced there isn't a non-zero-sum solution though.
What is the cost of a human life? What is the cost of the welfare of children whose only crime is following their parents across a border?
I don't pose these questions to signal virtue, but to point out the absurdity of assigning something like a cost function to something as natural as wanting a better life for oneself or one's children.
It might very well be true that "uncontrolled" immigration has an impact on the livelihoods of poorer Americans. Does this really imply that we should hurt the former in favor of the latter instead of helping both?