News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Deep Learning Cannot Be Applied to Natural Languages ... by visarga on Monday January 02, 2017 @05:55PM (#13305234)
The Chinese room argument is just a modern rehash of incredulity that physical systems could give rise to consciousness - which is absurd because that's what we know we are.

The argument goes - "when you look inside, it's just things pushing at each other. How could that produce perception and the conscious mind?"

So, a failure of imagination and incredulity based on how they understand the world and the mind makes them reject AI. They feel that the special place of the soul was traded for "information processing" which is dry and mechanical - a form of dualism creeping up in our day and age.

I would have felt the same if I didn't learn and use neural networks such as CNNs, RNNs and MLPs. Now I know how simple mechanical systems can recognize patterns and process information to generate complex behavior and I don't feel that "explanatory gap" any more.

Reinforcement learning is a good base for consciousness research - much more precise and with scientific results, not just p-zombies and bat based armchair experimentation. There's a limit where you can go with just pure thinking and then you need to start direct implementation.

There are no comments on this comment yet.