News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OpenPGP really works by dom0 on Monday January 02, 2017 @01:12PM (#13303045)
> No one criticizes openPGP on the crypto point of view.

Hm?

Of course PGP is criticized for that, just less vocally.

- Authentication is off by default in GPG

- Even so, it's very complex, and most of the protocol isn't authenticated

[ This is problematic, because ciphers tend to be more or less easily malleable, so non-signed messages can be tampered with; this is also an issue for encrypting files symmetrically ]

(- Compression is on by default and makes everything super-slow for no good reason)

- Widely used defaults for encryption and key derivation are rather arcane (eg. CAST5)

- PGP signatures, by principle, are non-repudiatiable, unlike most modern encrypted chat applications, so they prove to _anyone_ _forever_ that your key signed that message.

- PGP format announces all recipients to the world

- No forward secrecy possible

- ...

Re:OpenPGP really works by criddell on Monday January 02, 2017 @01:17PM (#13303092)
Would the lack of perfect forward secrecy be considered a shortcoming?