That's how you end up with pay by seniority rather than performance
Frankly this is the fault of the employer not the union.Yes the union is the one _forcing_ the employer to enact such policies but _why_ does the union exist? Because the employer treated their employees unfairly.
Unions are a bandage on a gaping wound, yes you can say the bandage isn't doing the best job. But why do you have the gaping wound to start with?
Basic worker benefits and protection can happen regardless of the number of voting members...
If a driver drives once:
1. they have less knowledge about working conditions
2. the trip was more of a fling with being an Uber driver and not a source of income.
3. It is easier for Uber or Lyft to stack the deck with drivers who are less informed on the issues
My point is that while unions benefit some workers, they don't benefit all workers. It's not a black and white situation.
This will only apply to the top 10% of Union workers. The workers who came late (or the majority of Uber drivers) will receive less pay, have less power, work longer hours, and fewer benefits than the "senior" drivers. Do you really think unions will help everyone? They, just like everything else in this world, are designed to benefit the top.
Leaders are incentivised to minimise the number of key supporters they need to stay in power [1]. Having a large pool of potential supporters is a plus.
>"One tried and true union tactic is to negotiate with an employer to take money from non-powerful-union-members and give it to union members."
What exactly is negotiated directly between the employer? How does this redistribution work in practice? Thanks.
Edit: it looks like this practice is not legal in right-to-work states in the US. This article seems to explain "Union security agreements" pretty well if anyone is interested:
http://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/free-books/employee-r...
I wonder are non-union workers in union shops ever pressured to join?
You get pay by seniority as a compromise because it's an objective measure, it correlates with performance and it can't be gamed by either side.
"Results suggest that, contrary to common beliefs, job tenure is largely unrelated to job performance."
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0001879113...
Paywalled.
However, the abstract ("citizenship behavior" / "creativity"... meaning what exactly?) hints that the measures are largely subjective and somewhat bullshitty.
Here's another, unpaywalled study:
http://www.people.vcu.edu/~mamcdani/Publications/McDaniel,%2...
"Results indicate that for all levels of job experience and for both low- and high-complexity jobs, the correlation between job experience and job performance is positive. "
(up to 12 yrs)
* People who are new to Uber.
* People who don't work at Uber very much.
These are people who know less about what it's like to work at Uber or don't have very much skin in the game. In any voting system, if you let people vote who don't know very much about the environment they are voting in or don't have much at stake, it makes fair representation difficult (unless you have fractional votes). To take an extreme example: people who visit Louisiana or have family there are certainly affected by state laws but that does not necessarily mean it is fair for them to vote on the same footing as Louisiana residents.
A more insidious way for this to work is that Uber could slightly favor candidates who are likely to vote their way during the on-boarding process -- varying their strategy on a month by month basis, depending on what issues are coming up for vote. You don't need a crushing margin -- and maybe don't want one -- just a good solid 3-4%.
The city didn't want a bunch of part-time or brand new drivers killing a union for the larger "full-time" group over union dues. Its a smart and relatively fair play by the authors of the law. The reason Uber/Lyft want these folks to vote is that they're likely to opt out just because of the dues.
The union is going to hire an attorney to represent them in negotiations right?
And yes dues are a huge issue for new unions where members don't know what the benefits are yet - particularly for part-timers. My wife who's a management side labor attorney actually raised this point and said it was significant - and the law was written smartly to address this.
> only to drivers who have been with a company for the past 90 days and who have made at least 52 trips to or from Seattle during any three-month period in the past 12 months.
Lyft and Uber fought against this, under the logic that more part-time drivers are less likely to support unionization.
Meanwhile:
> Teamsters Local 117 and other drivers have pushed for stricter criteria
[1] http://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/politics/city-unvei...