This breaks the HN guidlines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html. Please edit downvote-baiting out of your comments here.
I didn't bait anyone nor did I say I expected it. I said I was risking downvotes by having a contrarian opinion. Expectation and acknowledgement of risk are not identical.
In any case, you've won dang. While I've been a user here for nearly four years, you've really convinced me that participating in this community is wasted effort. Feel free to delete this account. I won't be back.
Antipatterns are on rather firmer academic ground than the guy at the airport barstool. Antipatterns are simply a negative version of design patterns. Design patterns in software started with the book Design Patterns: Elements of Reusable Object Oriented Software (aka Gang of Four or GoF), one of the greatest classic works in software engineering. GoF was itself based on the book A Pattern Language, by Christopher Alexander, a classic of the architectural field.
Alexander came up with the idea of a "pattern language" to describe patterns in architecture, a formal structure for observable phenomena. The GoF reused pattern language in a formal way to describe software patterns. Part of the pattern language describes how to implement the pattern. Antipatterns first appeared in the book Antipatterns: Refactoring Software, Architectures, and Projects in Crisis. Again, pattern language was used, including patterns for solving the problems caused by the antipattern.
So yes, this is rigorous. Not math-rigorous, but rigorous.
Whose---The authors of the articles', or "HNers"'?
They're just some people trying to help others by identifying some common problems they've encountered. Sure, the presentation might not be the best (though most of them don't have "properties", they're just a discussion), but does it really merit the epithets?
Also, regarding the camel case, that's just the Wiki's own linking format. I agree it wasn't the best decision, but considering this is the first invented Wiki ever, surely Ward can be excused a bad decision or two?