Re:Stephen Hawking outlines three theoretically realistic id...
by aero142 on Friday May 07, 2010 @04:34PM
(#1328681)
I always understood a dimension as "a variable that you can change to avoid occupying the spot." In 3d space, two objects cannot be in the same spot so either their x,y, or z coordinate must be different. If I add time as a fourth dimension then two objects can be at the same x,y and z, but not at the same time. You are right that time is a special dimension, but there are many things it has in common with the 3 spacial dimensions as well, my example being one.
Re:Stephen Hawking outlines three theoretically realistic id...
by Jun8 on Saturday May 08, 2010 @11:24AM
(#1330287)
You're right, in an intuitive sense. In math, especially dealing with weird stuff like extra dimensions, intuition may break down, though. For example, in the 4D Minkowski space you can have a unit sphere with a radius of -1! One has to understand what is meant when we say that "time is a special dimension". otherwise teh analogies we draw may fail. The Wikipedia article I linked explains these in a simple way.
Re:Stephen Hawking outlines three theoretically realistic id...
by derefr on Friday May 07, 2010 @08:49PM
(#1329258)
I've always heard dimensions being referred to as "timelike" or "spacelike", similar in vein (though not in concept) to the difference between "flat" and "rolled up" dimensions.
Re:Stephen Hawking outlines three theoretically realistic id...
by lutorm on Friday May 07, 2010 @04:28PM
(#1328652)
They said "4th dimension", not "4th Euclidean dimension" so I don't see that there was anything incorrect there.
Re:Stephen Hawking outlines three theoretically realistic id...
by mattheww on Friday May 07, 2010 @04:17PM
(#1328610)
While you're right that it's not a dimension in the sense that most people are used to, I think that it appropriately conveys the fact that time and space are intertwined. When you start traveling very quickly your sense of distance and time change in a way that is exactly proportional to each other. The fact that space and time need to be treated as a single entity was in fact one of the key conceptual advances that Einstein made.
Re:Stephen Hawking outlines three theoretically realistic id...
by jeffbradberry on Friday May 07, 2010 @08:29PM
(#1329219)
-1 (if I in fact had the points to do it), for assuming that changing the metric space obviates calling a dimension a dimension.
As Einstein says, "Make things as simple as possible, but not any simpler." The time as fourth dimension thing, I think, is an example of a wrong analogy pushed to make it easy for people to understand what in effect is quite hard to grasp.