I was about to agree with the GPP, but you have a really good point. This would be the sort of loophole that would be exploited.
It's a market for intangibles; over the short term it's zero-sum. The only way to profit is to induce mistakes; to get someone on the other side of a trade that's profitable to you and damaging to them.
If algorithmic trading causes vulnerability to mistakes, they need to revise their algorithms or factor in the risk of this type of loss; that's the way free markets work. The externalities of a sudden crash suck, but other than as a one-time emergency measure, rolling back all the trades isn't a good solution. Wall Street firms should've learned something since 1987.
My guess is that the algorithms are already being adjusted. My fear is that a bunch of politicians who are as clueless as most everyone else are going to try use this as yet another opportunity to grab the spotlight. Expect congressional hearings.
This is the normal operation. The "undo" key is not supposed to be used unless something abnormal happens.
if someone figures out a way (and that's rather easy) to induce mistakes and to profit from them, it will shortly become the prevalent form of trading
That sounds contrary to what Goldman Sachs is saying why they shouldn't be sued. They are using the "big boys" defense.
http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2010/04/21/politics/washingto...
There has to be a mechanism to undo cascade mistakes because, if someone figures out a way (and that's rather easy) to induce mistakes and to profit from them, it will shortly become the prevalent form of trading. We want exchanges to foster investment on productive companies.