Re:Brain Enhancement Is Wrong, Right?
by Tichy on Sunday March 09, 2008 @07:12PM
(#132784)
I always ask myself: if substance X is supposedly so beneficial, why doesn't the body manufacture it by itself? Or just creates the effect the drug is supposed to create to begin with?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Brain Enhancement Is Wrong, Right?
by jamesbritt on Monday March 10, 2008 @01:44AM
(#132960)
"If substance X is supposedly so beneficial, why doesn't the body manufacture it by itself?"
Well, it does. Many nootropic drugs work either by stimulating the production of, or blocking the absorption of, otherwise normally occurring brain chemicals.
I believe, for example, that methylphenidate (Ritalin) stimulates the production of dopamine, while bupropion (Wellbutrin) blocks dopamine reuptake.
I used to do a fair amount of wetware hacking, and one of the concerns was avoiding the crash that comes when your brain is depleted of one or another chemical.
One path to a better brain, then, is to feed it the material it needs to produce the more interesting (noradrenalin, dopamine, etc.) stuff.
But wouldn't it be trivial for evolution to change the quantities of those chemicals in the brain? Meaning, if other quantities were preferable, evolution would have adjusted those quantities long ago?
Re:Brain Enhancement Is Wrong, Right?
by jamesbritt on Wednesday March 12, 2008 @03:17AM
(#134987)
Perhaps they just not preferable for reproduction, or the current quantities are simply good enough for evolution's pressures.
Re:Brain Enhancement Is Wrong, Right?
by noonespecial on Sunday March 09, 2008 @09:27PM
(#132842)
Perhaps it used to, and is broken now. Putting the chemical back is fixing it, like a diabetic with insulin.
Why would it be broken, though? It seems with diabetic, at least with type II, Insulin is not necessary, just change the way you eat. Likewise with the brain I would rather know the causes of the problem, than experiment with drugs.
No doubt this is true to an extent - some folks need the assist. But this article is about much more than that. A diabetic doesn't take insulin to get an edge in business or sports or academics.
Re:Brain Enhancement Is Wrong, Right?
by noonespecial on Sunday March 09, 2008 @11:45PM
(#132906)
If all the world were diabetic, the edge would be to the one with the insulin, no?