That said, I doubt home routers are de-pritoritising UDP to any extent, or it would be a big topic of discussion among gamers.
(Of course, I'm pulling all of this out of my nether regions without a lot of thought, and you may well be right, the sheer volume of such requests might lead to problems.)
DNS caching is a good thing, but it certainly doesn't eliminate this problem. Web browsing still produces a lot of DNS requests, and any cache upstream of the bottleneck (ie. any cache operated by your ISP rather than in your own router) doesn't help against loss during congestion.
Without active queue management, a single bulk upload can break DNS. When the bottleneck link (usually your cable/DSL modem) is saturated by the bulk upload, it will start dropping new packets that come in while the queue is full.
When a single packet worth of space frees up, the chances are that the bulk flow will instantly take it, such that nearly all outbound DNS packets get dropped, and DNS queries time out.
The solution is active queue management (CODEL is a good choice) at every bottleneck.
Since UDP isn't as common of a protocol I can certainly see some routers treating it a second class traffic when it comes to packet shaping.