News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lessons from 3,000 technical interviews by geebee on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @02:55PM (#13273139)
Interesting bit on the MS degree. I followed the link, and I'm not quite as surprised that the correlation is poor, or even negative, given the way the data was collected and analyzed.

Absolutely agree that some MS degrees are pretty much less rigorous cash cows by now, that allow students to skip the fundamentals such as data structures, operating systems, and compilers.

However, many CS MS degrees actually do require this as a background, to the point where some programs have emerged to prepare non-CS majors for MS degrees, kind of like those post-bac premed programs. It's hard to believe that those MS degrees, which require a decent GPA in those core courses, along with high GRE scores (sorry, but we are talking about interviewing skill, which may be more related to exam taking ability than job performance), wouldn't result in a similar profile to people with CS degrees from top schools.

This is fully acknowledged in the text of the article referenced in a link, but unless people follow it, I do think the message may be a bit misleading.

That's an aside, though. The value may very well be in the prep for these degrees (ie., the post-bac CS coursework required for admissions to a reputable MS program). If you can get that through online courses (udacity or coursera) through genuinely rigorous self-study? Yeah, that might do it, for far less money. I've audited a few of them, and they're the real deal, that's the real coursework there.

Re:Lessons from 3,000 technical interviews by okreallywtf on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @03:53PM (#13273538)
I got a CS masters and even though it was a worthwhile experience to me but I never expected to necessarily make more or be chosen over another candidate purely based on education (assuming all other things being equal.

I felt like my knowledge definitely cured during the process with graduate level data structures, architecture, operating systems and networking. The 2nd pass on some of these areas (despite getting mostly A's from a generally-considered challenging but now well known program). I took the opportunity to craft my program of study more than I would have been able to as an undergrad (both due to lack of knowledge and how undergraduates are given a lot less leeway) to include electronics and automation courses. It also gave me the opportunity to work with and mentor other students which was rewarding and I think has benefited me in and out of the workplace.

I wouldn't argue for doing it purely for career reasons and its not something to do just because you've been in school so long you don't know how to do anything else, but I found it worthwhile and you just need to consider what you want out of it.

Re:Lessons from 3,000 technical interviews by matt_wulfeck on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @03:50PM (#13273513)
> Absolutely agree that some MS degrees are pretty much less rigorous cash cows by now, that allow students to skip the fundamentals such as data structures, operating systems, and compilers.

At what point do we not consider operating systems and compilers "fundamental"? What percentage of CS/programming jobs require deep knowledge in these arenas?

Re:Lessons from 3,000 technical interviews by hackcrafter on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @03:54PM (#13273545)
Absolutely I think they still should be considered fundamental.

By definition, these are the subjects that allow you to keep going when your abstractions leak[0].

To say a job "requires" them is pedantic, but what's the point of calling something a CS degree if it is not at least signaling an understanding of these fundamentals.

[0] https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2002/11/11/the-law-of-leaky-a...

Re:Lessons from 3,000 technical interviews by geebee on Thursday December 29, 2016 @12:42PM (#13278688)
That's a really complicated topic, of course. CS is in an interesting spot, in terms of how people perceive it and what students expect from it.

On one extreme, people see CS as a kind of trade school housed in a research university, teaching only what is useful on the job. Some people see CS as professional degree, kind of like law - you must teach theory for students to understand the field, but in the end, you're producing practicing lawyers, not abstract thinkers. And then, at the other end of the distribution, you find people who see CS as an academic field, a branch of scholarship, where the question "what percentage of programmers need to understand compilers" would be akin to asking "what percentage of math majors who become actuaries use real analysis?".

Re:Lessons from 3,000 technical interviews by erroneousfunk on Thursday December 29, 2016 @12:32PM (#13278612)
I did general engineering in undergrad, and software engineering (not CS) for my master's, so I'm somewhat of an outsider to a "computer science" degree. But if you have 6 whole years to turn someone into a "computer scientist," I would expect that, in ADDITION to compilers and operating systems, they'd also have a healthy dose of physics, chemistry, and especially math. I mean, for crying out loud, the degree has the word "science" in it.

My freshman year physics class had us building computer models of the solar system from Kepler's laws, constructing vocoders by manipulating raw sine waves, and discovering the equations that governed op-amp circuits through experimentation and a little deep thinking.

At my last job, one of my first tasks was to take raw data from truck engines computers (a data point ever 300ms) and turn point measurements like "instantaneous velocity" into data like "how far as the truck traveled over the last week"? Trivial. By combining that with engine speed and fuel usage, you could also say things like "what gear is the truck in?" "Has the engine performance declined recently?" "What percentage of the time has the driver idled in the last month?" And roll all that data up into an efficient database, build a super-flexible API around it, and create a series of web apps to display the useful stuff that managers wanted.

Having a deep understanding of the physical relationships between measurements, understanding what the data can and can't tell you, being able to spot potential problems in a proposed project (for instance, something that relies on an impossibly accurate GPS in a subtle way) -- these are all things that computer scientists absolutely should be able to do.

Yes, they should understand their computers from the electrons on up -- operating system included -- but they should understand the world that the computers interact with, as well.

Re:Lessons from 3,000 technical interviews by rfrey on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @04:09PM (#13273678)
from Latin fundamentum "a foundation, ground-work; support; beginning." Whether these subjects are fundamental is totally detached from whether they are useful in a certain percentage of industry jobs.

I agree that knowing fundamentals is not that essential for a large number of programming jobs. They're still fundamentals though.

Re:Lessons from 3,000 technical interviews by kowdermeister on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @04:09PM (#13273674)
It should be optional or advanced level. If you are a web developer for example OS and compilers are totally not important to get along and have a healthy career.
Re:Lessons from 3,000 technical interviews by guntars on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @04:17PM (#13273740)
I disagree, compilers are relevant to web development because of all the compiling and transpiling that a single source file goes through in large application development.
Re:Lessons from 3,000 technical interviews by kowdermeister on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @04:33PM (#13273856)
If you are interested in _writing_ compilers then sure. If I just want to use those compilers, then I don't really need to understand them just use them as specified.

Now you'll say that I'll make a mess if I don't know what the compiler does. That's what best practices are for if say I pick TypeScript. Also, optimization is the compilers responsibility.

Re:Lessons from 3,000 technical interviews by JamesBarney on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @03:30PM (#13273376)
What about the way she collected and analyzed the data caused the correlation to falsely be poor or negative?
Re:Lessons from 3,000 technical interviews by geebee on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @04:13PM (#13273705)
Nothing! The author explicitely states that the data and analysis was not granular enough tp make distinction between the different kinds of MS degrees.

This leaves open the possibility rhat some categories of MS degrees might correlate positively, even though MS degrees overall correlate negatively.

Re:Lessons from 3,000 technical interviews by eanzenberg on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @05:56PM (#13274386)
This

>>>No surprises here. I’ve ranted quite a bit about the disutility of master’s degrees, so I won’t belabor the point.

is literally all she says about MS degrees. Wow the bias of this site is incredible..

Re:Lessons from 3,000 technical interviews by eanzenberg on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @05:56PM (#13274391)
This

http://blog.alinelerner.com/how-different-is-a-b-s-in-comput...

Is what she says about MS degrees in another post. No data or analysis is shown, just opinion.

Re:Lessons from 3,000 technical interviews by sporkenfang on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @03:25PM (#13273325)
I'm curious what would happen if they looked at, as separate categories, people who mastered out of a doctoral program, people who did the 5-year BS/MS, and people who obtained a doctoral degree as well as a master's.
Re:Lessons from 3,000 technical interviews by geebee on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @05:26PM (#13274229)
That could be useful. The article mentioned rhat there was no distinction made between CS masters degrees and Info Systems degrees.

My guess is that pure MS would correlate positively from CS programs that require a background in more advanced math and algorithms. Info sys degrees typically don't.

I'm not knocking those degrees, keep in mind we're measuring performance on a technical interview, which often leans very heavily toward algorithms, trees, sometimes graphs, and occasionally numerical analysis or computing.

If the MS degree data includes a lot of programs that dont include this background, then this woukd not be a surprising result.

Re:Lessons from 3,000 technical interviews by adjkant on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @04:41PM (#13273920)
Agreed completely. I would suspect that BS/MS and Ph.D. interviewees would be very distinct from a straight MS, but this was a missed opportunity to look at that, even if it is just interview performance.
Re:Lessons from 3,000 technical interviews by eanzenberg on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @05:54PM (#13274377)
Um, did you actually look at the article? There was no data shown between interview performance and MS degree status. The graph you saw was interview performance vs. years of experience. This isn't surprising since a person with 20 years experience will generally interview for a much more challenging job than someone with 0 years.
Re:Lessons from 3,000 technical interviews by geebee on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @09:42PM (#13275345)
Yes, I read the article. Under the section "Master’s degree & years of experience", the author writes:

"No surprises here. I’ve ranted quite a bit about the disutility of master’s degrees, so I won’t belabor the point."

And provides a link to another post the author has written. Look for ("disutility of masters degrees"). That page will contain more of the content we are discussing.

This is what I was referring to when I wrote:

"This is fully acknowledged in the text of the article referenced in a link, but unless people follow it, I do think the message may be a bit misleading."

I would agree that no data is provided here, the author simply states MS degrees are an indicator of poor technical performance "in my experience" and goes on to list reasons why this might be the case.

I'm sure there's a reasonable case to be made that an MS in CS isn't worth the time, effort, and money, even from a top school. But I don't think that grouping these degrees with MS degrees in Info Sys (among others) and then reporting experiences without that distinction provides much useful insight into the topic.