Re:Rust vs C Pitfalls
by Manishearth on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @01:13AM
(#13268784)
> This is because the garbage collector tends to have preallocated memory lying around,
This is an allocator feature independent of garbage collection; jemalloc does this for example. GCd languages have the potential to do this better since they can do additional analysis whilst tracing for little additional cost, but non-GCd languages can still benefit from this.
Part of this is also that Go is really good at not allocating from the heap when it can allocate from the stack (escape analysis). Until Go 1.5 the Go garbage collector was pretty weak, but it didn't matter as much as it would have for a language with heavier heap allocation.
Another factor could also be that the GC in the Go examples just never runs since it doesn't allocate enough memory. It's hard to say exactly what's happening without tracing the runtime, which would also affect the benchmarks a bit.
It's important to note that while both languages are natively compiled (and I suspect Rust would inch out in that category due to LLVM's backing) most of the overhead would probably be from memory, whether allocations, or cache usage, which makes comparing them in microbenchmarks a little inaccurate.