And please infovis-wiki, that criticism with just Inbar et al. seems pretty lame (their subjects were 87 students - not a good sample at all for something about perception!)
I would argue that there are consequently very good reasons to believe that the problems you described are not a issue with the redesign or that there are certain advantages to the redesign which make up for other disadvantages.
And yet it moves! (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E_pur_si_muove!).
Google "testing it" isn't an iron clad guarantee that the feature doesn't suck.
Anyone who has worked in a large company can well imagine how "tests" can support predetermined positions of higher management (say). I suspect the reason is simpler - these days Google is fat and slow and infested with mediocre MBA types who love nothing better than to "launch an initiative" like this. Never attribute to malice etc.
Irrespective of how well Google tested this, if enough users say "And yet it sucks", then that's that.
You could argue about how many users are "enough", but "Google tested it so they have to be right and everyone else is wrong" is a very fragile argument.
A couple of ways to do it.
(1) On Firefox install the stylish plug in (https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/2108/). Then go to http://userstyles.org/styles/29418 and install the style.
After installation, if you are not using google.com(say google.ca or google.co.in), edit the css (left click on icon at bottom right, select manage, select the style edit) to reflect whatever google engine you are using.
(2)In Chrome the Hide Google Options addon works perfectly (http://www.seotools.com/hide-google-options/#Chrome). There is a firefox equivalent but for some reason it didn't work for me so I went with the above (stylish) option on FF.
No idea about any other browser. Sorry. But I guess there is always GreaseMonkey?
I'm surprised Google would make a mistake of such magnitude. Anyone who's read Tufte would know not to do this. They've effectively reduced the data-ink ratio of the page, when you weight each pixel by its proximity to the upper left corner.
http://www.infovis-wiki.net/index.php/Data-Ink_Ratio
http://inspiredimpressions.files.wordpress.com/2006/04/Googl...
Oddly enough, it would actually be better if the left bar were entirely boilerplate, because that would make it easier to tune it out.
http://www.useit.com/eyetracking/eyetracking_corporate_site_...
Then the new design would merely waste space. Filling the left side of the page not merely with crap, but with changing crap, is the worst case scenario.