I usually find that if my C++ code required little to no mental tracking of ownership or borrowing or lifetimes, the rust was straight forward. And if the rust was complex, the C++ required me to keep too much in my head (or even had bugs).
I cannot address the latter part of your argument (the more important part, I think), however, because as I stated, I have not invested serious effort in Rust. Intuitively, from the code and documentation I've seen, I'd be wary of trying to implement, say, highly performant (emphasis on the performance) cyclic graphs in Rust rather than C++, but that's merely an impression, hence my interest in learning more. And certainly, whatever the difficulty, the likelihood of bugs in C++ would be higher.
Move-by-default, elided lifetimes on many parameters, etc, are all verbosity-free.
Not your parent, but instead of writing my own thoughts here, I think I'll write a blog post tomorrow :)
Anyway, looking forward to your post.
Rust traits are more powerful, expressive, and maintainable than other polymorphism systems like inheritance.
First (and this is the less important one), the syntax seems second only to Java in verbosity and often seems different for no readily evident reason. Secondly, virtually any time someone's advocating for Rust, you get a long lecture about how memory safety is the most important thing in the world and anyone who disagrees is so hopelessly backward that they should be disqualified from writing any code at all. Well, it happens to be very low on my list of concerns. In fact, for most of the low level code I write, memory safety, ownership tracking, borrow checking, etc. are wholly irrelevant. So, given that, should I look at Rust (as compared to C++ and D, which I use and enjoy)? Does it have meaningful advantages that compensate for its syntax, immaturity and performance limitations (vectorization, etc.)?
I've asked a few Rust users this before, but never really gotten a satisfactory answer that didn't involve the same memory/thread safety argument. Give me one and I'll happily give Rust a try, no coffee necessary. :)