News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The hunt for dollars to build the $64B bullet train by dragonwriter on Monday December 26, 2016 @03:57AM (#13257552)
> Not a single yard of track has been laid.

True but misleading. Actually laying track is the cheap and easy final part of construction; building the viaducts, grade separations, etc., and doing the other construction which prepares the route for track to be laid.is the time consuming, expensive part, and plenty of that has been done and is being done in the initial segment.

> Here in India, we've built an entire city Metro system for about $6B.

Which is a very different problem than a regional transit system. And, in any case, acquiring right of way is cheaper in India, due to land prices.

> That's twice what it cost California to explore the idea of maybe someday laying track

California's done a lot more than explore the idea of construction.

> Anyone who talks about finding $64B and 12 years for what should be a $2-4B railway in 4 years is fundamentally unserious.

Anyone who thinks that a statewide high speed rail system in California should be $2-$4 billion dollars in 4 years is fundamentally unserious.

Re:The hunt for dollars to build the $64B bullet train by trome on Monday December 26, 2016 @05:23AM (#13257753)
The right of way, design, and labor differences are the main differentiator, besides the fact that this is high speed rail over a few hundred miles, not a few dozen mile light rail alignment.

That being said, here in Seattle we approved nearly as much money to build out our light rail network, and in the context of the US and what it costs to build bridges, freeways and rail here, that cost isn't far out of line. Considering the state of our region currently, even if the economy imploded tomorrow it'd still be a sound investment to do, especially since we are connecting all the way from Tacoma to Everett, with 116 miles of rail.

Re:The hunt for dollars to build the $64B bullet train by jack9 on Monday December 26, 2016 @08:14AM (#13258111)
> California's done a lot more than explore the idea of construction.

That's irrelevant. There is no planned path, just patches and the project is going to be scaled back to an absurd degree (or sold off, which is basically the same thing).

> Anyone who thinks that a statewide high speed rail system in California should be $2-$4 billion dollars in 4 years is fundamentally unserious.

The project start, Prop 1A, was for almost 10 billion in 10 years (procedurally discussed, not legislatively enforced).

Much like Federal budgets and projects, anything extended beyond the current administration's term limits means it's someone else's problem. Putting people on Mars and this project, should become a reality about the same time.

Re:The hunt for dollars to build the $64B bullet train by dragonwriter on Monday December 26, 2016 @11:46AM (#13258805)
> There is no planned path

Yes, there is a planned alignment for the entire system (and not just the LA to SF "Phase I" for which most of the cost estimates and timelines usually discussed apply, but also the Sacramento to San Diego "Phase 2".)

> just patches

No, even if you are referring to the context of the initial construction, that's not true; it's directed with a clear plan of a specific segment for initial operations between Silicon valley and the Central Valley.

> and the project is going to be scaled back to an absurd degree

Pure speculation; it's true that there is uncertainty, largely political in nature, about funding for the portion beyond the part that is supposed to be operational in 2025. But there's also plenty of time to resolve that.

> The project start, Prop 1A, was for almost 10 billion in 10 years

It was a $10 billion conditional bond authorization (one of the funding challenges has been meeting the conditions in that bond authorization) which was very explicitly not expected to cover full construction cost of the system (nor was there ever a 10 year timeline.)

Re:The hunt for dollars to build the $64B bullet train by stuaxo on Monday December 26, 2016 @10:20AM (#13258489)
Yup, compare to HS2 in the UK £55bn for 225km, it actually sounds like not bad value.