News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Two Years of Voice-Based Assistants, Echo and Home by Waterluvian on Monday December 26, 2016 @12:59AM (#13257181)
What I need is natural natural language processing to become so good that it just works. I don't respect voice as an input method because I feel uncomfortable using it, since I have to pre plan my question rather than stream consciousness like I will to my family and peers. I want to be able to have this conversation:

"Computer, how much does a.. hmm what's it called.. uhh.. a loud keyboard, what's that called?"

"A mechanical keyboard?"

"Yes. The ones from the.. uh I forget the company name."

"Corsair? Razer?"

"Razer! How much does their newest mechanical keyboard cost?"

"The newest keyboard from Razer is...<etc>"

Re:Two Years of Voice-Based Assistants, Echo and Home by kalleboo on Monday December 26, 2016 @05:28AM (#13257762)
Heck screw the helping you complete your thought for you, if it just handled umms and uhhs and pauses without going "I didn't get that" I would be 100% happier
Re:Two Years of Voice-Based Assistants, Echo and Home by dqv on Monday December 26, 2016 @02:24AM (#13257346)
>What I need is natural natural language processing to become so good that it just works.

That's supernatural language processing. You're asking the system to recognize a thought you have in your mind that you can't effectively communicate with words.

The loud keyboard - makes sense. But the company name? My first thought was IBM or Cherry.

I think it can be improved, but I'm never going to expect voice recognition to fill in the blanks for something I can't describe with my voice.

Re:Two Years of Voice-Based Assistants, Echo and Home by frankomonster on Monday December 26, 2016 @02:43AM (#13257400)
Filling in the blanks is something that humans do all the time with conversation. Just the other day I was asking my girl what was the last name of that woman named Susan from Britains Got Talent. Conversation went like this:

Me: Babe, do you remember the last name of Susan from Britains Got Talent?

Her: Susan... kinda...

Me: I think it began with a "B"

Her: Boyle!

Maybe todays systems would understand me if I phrased the question in a context they understand but why bother taking the time. I can just talk to a human.

It'll get interesting though as computers continue to improve.

Re:Two Years of Voice-Based Assistants, Echo and Home by harisenbon on Monday December 26, 2016 @10:18AM (#13258479)
I was curious, so I asked Siri your question: what is the last name of Susan from Britain's got talent? She successfully answered Boyle.
Re:Two Years of Voice-Based Assistants, Echo and Home by visarga on Monday December 26, 2016 @03:36AM (#13257510)
You know, the first and probably most important step into realizing natural-NLP is to make a dataset of such prompts and answers. I really like the examples.
Re:Two Years of Voice-Based Assistants, Echo and Home by enobrev on Monday December 26, 2016 @08:52AM (#13258220)
Excellent examples. I can't imagine an AI ever picking up on conversations between my wife and I.

Me: Honey, can you grab me the thing on that thing.

Her: Oh, this thing?

Me: The other thing... Perfect, thanks!