News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Today the Dow dropped 1000 points in about ten minutes. by sonnym on Thursday May 06, 2010 @04:22PM (#1325589)
There are far too many speculative comments on this story. I normally find the comments on HN to be well thought and reasoned - not rapid posting of wild rumors that are currently prevalent.

Perhaps people should wait until the facts emerge before posting more stories filled with inaccurate information.

Re:Today the Dow dropped 1000 points in about ten minutes. by jsm386 on Thursday May 06, 2010 @05:15PM (#1325750)
Well, here's a statement from the NYSE:

"There were a number of erroneous trades," said NYSE spokesman Rich Adamonis."Our guys just told me Nasdaq is investigating the erroneous trades. What happened today in P&G for instance, the bad print was on Nasdaq, not here," he said, referring to a 37 percent plunge in Procter & Gamble Co.

The Nasdaq said it is investigating the plunge.

http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601087&sid=aQKb...

And more - including canceled trades of Accenture:

Nasdaq OMX Group Inc. said it’s investigating potentially erroneous trades involving multiple securities between 2:40 p.m. and 3 p.m. New York time, when the U.S. stock market tumbled.

Trades in Accenture Plc that drove the second-largest technology consulting company’s stock price down more than 99 percent to a penny were canceled by the CBOE Stock Exchange, according to data compiled by Bloomberg.

A total of 19 trades of 100 shares each were executed at 1 cent in seven seconds from 2:47 p.m. to 2:48 p.m. in New York, a minute after the Dow average plunged by the most since the market crash of 1987, the data showed.

Eighteen of the trades were executed on the CBOE Stock Exchange and were canceled. The first trade that sent Accenture to a penny was executed on the Nasdaq Stock Market. That transaction has yet to be canceled, the data showed.

http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601087&sid=a3ti...

Re:Today the Dow dropped 1000 points in about ten minutes. by lotharbot on Thursday May 06, 2010 @09:02PM (#1326317)
From what I've read, one key issue was that some exchanges stopped trading or updating certain prices for a few minutes, which led to other exchanges making trades in isolation instead of tying them into the larger market. With just a few more "sell at any price" than "buy at a reasonable price" orders for a given stock on a given exchange, and with no tie-in to other buy orders from other places, the "buy at a ridiculously low price" orders that many traders leave in place just to take advantage of algorithmic glitches of this nature were triggered.

It's like being at a car auction with a robot auctioneer and putting in a one-penny starting bid, and then the robot's sensors malfunction so he can't see any more bids. He'll declare you the auction winner, but that result doesn't reflect the car's actual value and will almost definitely be canceled.

Re:Today the Dow dropped 1000 points in about ten minutes. by rdtsc on Thursday May 06, 2010 @11:41PM (#1326641)
> result doesn't reflect the car's actual value and will almost definitely be canceled.

Unless the value of the car is defined as whatever someone on NYSE or NASDAQ is willing to pay for it.

As the result of this there were some losers and some winners. Losers will want the trades reversed, winners won't. Reversal of trades could start a dangerous trend. Who gets to decide which trades get reversed? I wonder if many HFT firms will start to incorporate such kind of behavior into their trading model, so we'll see more of these "accidents" in the future.

Re:Today the Dow dropped 1000 points in about ten minutes. by lotharbot on Friday May 07, 2010 @02:45AM (#1326882)
The way the stock exchanges are set up, they can cancel trades that are considered "erroneous". It's in the contract, and it has been done before. Either party can trigger a mediation attempt [1], but in this case the exchange itself determined that they made a mistake in generating trades that shouldn't have actually happened and was only triggered by a glitch in the system, and made a blanket declaration. Since any trade on their system is actually just a contract to exchange the stock in the next 3 days, they don't have to take back any stock, they just have to declare the contract as invalid.

Last I heard, the Nasdaq was going to cancel any trades that were during the glitchy time window and were more than 60% away from a baseline price (an amount people were "willing to pay for it" when the system wasn't glitching). I don't know how they came up with the number, nor how deeply the SEC and other agencies were involved in setting it. There will still be plenty of winners and losers coming out of this, just not the ones who thought they bought or sold Accenture at a penny.

I'm not saying this is a "good" fix, but it is well within the Nasdaq's authority.

[1] http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1325574 - notes that broken trades are fairly common, and that they're usually quickly mediated

Re:Today the Dow dropped 1000 points in about ten minutes. by eru on Friday May 07, 2010 @02:42PM (#1328372)
> [...], so we'll see more of these "accidents" in the future.

No, we'll see less of these trades. Because the next guy will set up "buy everything at $ 0.02", so that the $ 0.01 guys don't get everything. Of course they anticipate each other, and will bid each other up to sensible prices.

Re:Today the Dow dropped 1000 points in about ten minutes. by sireat on Friday May 07, 2010 @02:35AM (#1326868)
The question is where do we draw the line?

Ok, we disallow 0.01% of price,penny bids. However, should 10% of price bid orders be left standing, how about 20%, 50%? Certainly 75% of price bids should be honored?

Re:Today the Dow dropped 1000 points in about ten minutes. by jfornear on Thursday May 06, 2010 @05:42PM (#1325825)
I think the speculations and rumors are very interesting and relevant to learning more about how the market works (or doesn't work), a topic that no one is ever going to have enough "facts" to fully understand.
Re:Today the Dow dropped 1000 points in about ten minutes. by rdtsc on Thursday May 06, 2010 @11:47PM (#1326647)
The market broke today. However, as you pointed out, the _way_ it broke and the way it was fixed has been observed by all. So everyone just learned a new piece of information about the market behavior. This kind of behavior will certainly end up being encoded into the HFT models -- both as a way to react to it, and (perhaps what is terrifying), as a way to trigger it.

I am afraid we might seeing these kind of things more often.

Re:Today the Dow dropped 1000 points in about ten minutes. by jimmyrcom on Thursday May 06, 2010 @06:11PM (#1325895)
ARE YOU NOT ENTERTAINED

IS THIS NOT WHY YOU ARE HERE?

Personally I checked only to see everyones noodles flailing.

Re:Today the Dow dropped 1000 points in about ten minutes. by supaflyhigh on Thursday May 06, 2010 @05:07PM (#1325732)
For a definition of the Internet please see above^
Re:Today the Dow dropped 1000 points in about ten minutes. by migpwr on Thursday May 06, 2010 @05:09PM (#1325739)
Try the newspaper. What exactly do you expect on an open forum?
Re:Today the Dow dropped 1000 points in about ten minutes. by stanleydrew on Thursday May 06, 2010 @09:06PM (#1326323)
normally I find the comments on HN to be well thought and reasoned...

I believe he made clear what he expects on this forum.