News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mind as an emergent self-organizing process by mcguire on Sunday December 25, 2016 @05:51PM (#13255828)
"An observer (the awareness) misapprehends working of a set of semi-independent parts as a whole, like an observer of a large city from the top of a skyscraper could readily mistake it for a living organism."

So you (and/or Robert Wright) would argue that a city doesn't exist as something worthy of a name in itself? In other words, "Albuquerque" doesn't denote anything; the only thing that exists is a loosely related collection of buildings, people, etc.?

Re:Mind as an emergent self-organizing process by armitron on Monday December 26, 2016 @12:09PM (#13258891)
Of course his point of view also flies against systems theory and the last 60-70 years of radical progress that has been made in this domain. An ant colony is so much more than the sum of its parts. To call similar emergent systems "a delusion" is laughable. That he also mentions "Brahman" in the same post tells me that he's extremely confused and can't separate philosophy/mysticism from empiricism/science.

lngmn writes:

"The notion of mind is a delusion, caused by confused verbalized introspection in the first place. An observer (the awareness) misapprehends working of a set of semi-independent parts as a whole, like an observer of a large city from the top of a skyscraper could readily mistake it for a living organism."

So, in his view, there exists an "awareness" that acts as an independent, objective "observer" that is in the position to misapprehend and it is this "awareness" that is deluded about the mind? How is that for circular reasoning.

Even primitive Hindu mystics thousands of years ago when reflecting on the "awareness", what he calls Brahman, had the insight and reasoning ability to posit it as non-objective nothingness, non-dual, outside space and time, ineffable.

Coming back to this reality, feedback loops and emergent properties are _everywhere_, and as the loops get shorter and shorter, system cohesion strengthens and the properties become more _obvious_.

Arguments of the short that he put forth should be viewed with suspicion, if not outright dismissal and ridicule.

Re:Mind as an emergent self-organizing process by lngnmn on Tuesday December 27, 2016 @01:34PM (#13264972)
> extremely confused and can't separate philosophy/mysticism from empiricism/science.

That's rather bold generalization form a single term.) Nevertheless I would argue that I could easily hold a discussion on various branches of Eastern philosophy and modern sciences.

My friend, awareness does not act, it exist. Other parts of the brain are responsible for actions. That is the point. Awareness is a process (processing of a sensory input, if you wish), one of many, not the whole.

Awareness cannot be objective (or subjective) - this notion is inapplicable. Are camera and microphone in your phone objective?

Observer is a metaphor used to give an oversimplified but familiar example.

In philosophy of the mind an observer emerges as an abstract entity when awareness augmented with a language is directed toward itself in the process of verbalized introspection. A human language is a prerequisite for having such a notion. That is why modern science has no evidence that animals posses self-awareness.

That "mind" or "I" or "myself" with which the verbalized introspection has been labeled what it think it sees is mere a linguistic construct. A label. A name for a reflection in the water of consciousness.

The notion of Brahman is applicable to the nature of the universe and has nothing to do with awareness. The different notion - Atman - is used to convey fundamental idea, that what the nature of a Man is no different from the nature of the Universe - Man is mere a "product" of the Universe. This is the meaning of famous upanishadic "Atman is Brahman" and "I am that".

There, perhaps, no subject other than what we call the philosophy of mind, on which the best minds of the humanity has been working since the beginning of time, and the ideas and notions they have developed, principles they have formulated still stands, even if they were realized as mere insights and intuitions.

As for feedback loops and emergent properties - these are everywhere in biology. No one argues against systems biology or development. A brain has been emerged dues to accumulation of feedback and selection on "useful" patterns (I am oversimplifying for the sake of the argument). There is nothing to talk about.

Actually, what is really ridiculous is trying to put in a few sentences the findings of evolutionary psychology, the notions of social and cultural conditioning, that a language is conditioned by a sensory experience (and hence by physical shared environment - this is how we got these apriori notions of time and space, described by Kant).

What we call the mind is mere conditioning and memories of experiences, encoded using the very same conditioned linguistic forms and emotions (should I explain in what sense emotions are conditioned by the shared environment?).

I think you should take the Robert Wright's course and read a book or two on the subject before trying to piss on a wrong tree.

Re:Mind as an emergent self-organizing process by armitron on Tuesday December 27, 2016 @04:59PM (#13266564)
I had a look at Robert Wright's course, it's irrelevant to this discussion but I will devote some time to it since I'm interested in its subject matter and have been for years. Thank you for suggesting it.

I don't like to mix philosophy or mysticism with science. In both your posts, you are going back and forth between the two, mixing and matching, and while everything may make sense to you, it's not really helping when other minds come into play. It's far more productive I feel to talk from one or the other perspective, but not both.

This was the major point of me disagreeing with your first post, and also that you seemed to dismiss "the process" itself. Surely the mind is not mere conditioning and memories of experiences, maybe you could get away talking like this with other Buddhists or mystics or Vedantic followers — and then they'd tell you that none of that really exists — but when talking with cyberneticists or system theorists you'll be laughed out of the room. And this is coming from someone who is very familiar with the first and well-versed in the second of these domains.

You talk about the brain having "emerged" but this risks confusion when applied to the topic at hand. The brain may have emerged through evolution and natural selection, but it is not emerging right now.

The mind is an emergent process altogether.

The conditioning and memories that you talk about is really the "self-model", data, but not the process-in-execution itself. Maybe you will say that the mind emerges from said data and that therefore this sort of data is a pre-requisite. I could argue for or against this depending on day or phase of the moon, it's an interesting point. But it's erroneous I feel to identify the mind with said data.

In deep sleep, there is no mind even though the brain is physically there and so are the memories and experiences and conditioning. The mind begins to emerge in dreams and is fully emergent in wakefulness. There is a clear distinction between data as stored in the brain and the process of becoming self-aware.

Finally, there is plenty of evidence that certain animals possess self-awareness without possessing anything close to human language. Dolphins, some apes and birds (parrots and magpies). And again, all of this makes a lot of sense from a cybernetic perspective but it makes no sense whatsoever from your mystical/philosophical pov. Which is why it's a mistake to apply notions from the second to the first.

Re:Mind as an emergent self-organizing process by lngnmn on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @07:08AM (#13270000)
Forgot to ask - what exactly are the evidences of possessing sefl-awareness? Which experiment has been accepted as a proof? How did they proved that an animal subject does not see a mere another animal, but exactly "that is me" or not just merely confused, like all these babies with ridiculous looking time experiments?
Re:Mind as an emergent self-organizing process by lngnmn on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @06:11AM (#13269812)
There is a story about blind philosophers touching an elephant. Fortunately, in the case of mind they all are touching the same elephant, contrary to some theoretical physicists and dark matter/dark energy astronomers who are touching imaginary spherical elephants in vacuum, or french existentialists touching each other.

This means that after pruning out, like in a search algorithm, obvious nonsense the remaining insights and formulated principles "describe" the same phenomena from different perspectives, so the process is still have good chances to converge to some approximation of what is (or truth or absolute, if we wish to use archaic terms) while other processes are not even convex (this is another analogy). So, dismissing a proper philosophy as unscientific is a bit premature, in my opinion.

Sometimes metaphors are the only way to correctly express certain notions, which are foreign to our conditioned and specialized brains, like the notion of non-existence of time as a distinct phenomena, or that there are such things as appearances - patterns of sensory input which interpreted by the brain, conditioned to do it by the environment in which it has been evolved, to accept these perceptions as ultimately existing. Forth grade example with zooming form a solid into atoms and then "particles" would illustrate it best.

For the system theorists the analogy would be that they are talking about implementation details, while philosophers are talking about higher lever, linguistic abstractions, the domain of what we call the mind. It is easy to see that linguistic abstractions of the mind does not necessarily exist, like angels or dark energy.

The state of deep-sleep or losing of consciousness has been used as a counterargument to refute the separate good-created-soul dogmas back in the times of Upanishads. Nowadays we would say that some processes are suspended and then recreated, which at least refutes the dogma of separate, permanent self as a distinct entity. Obvious examples from software systems one could find himself.

The good AI research, like a good philosophy, which could be characterized by pruning of nonsense and collecting non-contradictory general principles, with help of evolutionary and social psychology already got what is possible and how it works in principle. What they, obviously, do not know is how exactly it works (due to complexity) and how it came to be, but these are non-principal questions.

At least, there is no doubt for a modestly educated person that most of mind-created appearances does not ultimately exist, like socially constructed dogmas or memes.

Time, soul, self are a memes of the mind, if you wish. Implementation details are irrelevant.