One of the reasons the forex markets are MUCH more difficult to manipulate is that you have $3.5 trillion traded daily. Not sure who can simply move that market. Equities on the other hand, much easier....
http://www.cnbc.com/id/36998463
That sounds hard for me to believe, but thats one rumor. That wouldn't account for the 10% drop but it might have put initiated the drop and then caused other people (and computers) to panic and sell.
[Edit] Actually the stock was down at $39.37 from $61. On normal days PG barely moves at all.
It probably should.
It's really surprising, assuming this is really the cause, that a single letter typo could have such an effect and this has 1) never happened before and 2) not been caught in testing.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/business/4512962.stm
In the above case the trader got the price and number of share fields confused.
I will tell you what though - someone... someone, made a lot of money from this. Inadvertently, but more than likely otherwise.
I have actually worked on such software. When a price comes in - a quote - you have a fixed amount of time to respond before it goes stale, usually a few seconds. It's assumed you know what you're doing and that you want to move quickly. Same as operating any other high-powered machinery.
I remember a feature request from a client of ours, we had keyboard shortcuts of k for thousand, m for million and b for billion. They wanted t as well.
Would this rumor create insane profits for some? If that is so, those getting the profits should be investigated. Some employee could have been promissed a large sum in a off-shore account to enter a 'b' instead of an 'm'. It should look like an 'oops' to everyone else while a bunch of HFT algorithms could rake in serious profits as everyone's stop-loss triggers get hit. The employee might get fired, but he the pay-off was large enough, he might not need to work ever again.
Welcome to the world of positive feedback loops, enjoy your stay.
CNBC: Trading Error at Major Firm Blamed for Market Plunge: Sources (Story Developing)
CNBC does NOT know what the cause of this was. The exchanges will come out with some "computer glitch" story or the "fat finger" excuse, but neither of those are true. FWIW, the fat finger excuse is, in a nutshell, some trader accidentally pressing the wrong button on the trading desk.
The market was at a technical support level with various moving averages, timelines, etc. all coming into play. Many people had/have stop losses because the market was/is looking due for a correction. Algo/HFT pounced on this, collectively, and thus the massive drop.
Trust me, if you are buying into what CNBC tells you, you are really missing the truth...
(...) on December 8, 2005 in which a Mizuho dealer mistakenly sold 610,000 shares in J-Com, a recruitment business, at 1 yen instead of selling 1 share at 610,000 yen.
The dealer, understood to be a 24-year old woman, immediately realised the mistake but was unable to cancel the trade because of a technical glitch in the exchange's trading system. Mizuho was forced to buy back the shares, leaving it with a 40.7 billion yen loss, prompting the firm to cancel year-end bonuses for all staff in the trading unit.
Note in Japan executed trades cannot be canceled (though in this case the trader was supposed to be able to cancel the orders before they were executed). Many brokers made a big profit. Some institutional investors too. One particular day trader became quite rich and to this day is a sort of legend on internet trading boards.
Breaking News of cnbc.com reads:
Trading Error at Major Firm Blamed for Market Plunge: Sources (Story Developing)
(I don't buy it. CNBC is propaganda.)
I call B$ on this.
Fast traders don't click on icons and enter values, they enter an entire trade on one line.
Buy 1000 shares of Apple computer at 250.05 might be entered as:
buy1000aapl250.05
Maybe you should have had an example not contrary to what you said.
Text based systems: FBSI, SIS
GUI based systems (when not pointing and clicking): Patsystems JTrader<A>, Trading Technologies' XTrader<A>
<A> These are systems I have used for personal use but not at work
However I find it extremely foolhardy that mistyping one character has an impact one thousand times greater, and that such an action can be performed without some kind of validation (whether explicitly via a confirmation, or implicitly in how the UX is designed).
Then again it is probably because of the typo risk that bankers get paid so much ...
I once deleted all my source code instead of backing it up to my floppy by doing "del ." while command.com was in wrong drive. (Should have done "del a:\."; two letters cost me a night of running an undelete program)
Interactive brokers has an API for their software. It's fairly easy to use.
http://interactivebrokers.com/en/p.php?f=programInterface...
They say it right on the web page and I'll repeat it here: Try it with paper trading first! Bugs in these kinds of algorithms are costly.
Just don't expect hand holding. You're supposed to be an experienced trader to even sign up with them (for a few products, like options, you have to pass a ridiculously easy test to trade them), and they won't save you from yourself - they'll happily let you buy 500k Euros with only $20k in your account, so be warned: if you'd made that mistake today, you'd be flat broke right now, though IIRC they do close out positions for you so at least you shouldn't end up too far in the red once your account is dunzo...
...which, to reiterate fnid2's point, it will be, unless you make sure to paper trade your damn code first! I'd also suggest that until you're really sure it's working, you never ever EVER leave it running unless you're watching it like a hawk. And code yourself a big bright red "PANIC" button that closes all your positions and shuts everything down, because you're going to end up in a situation some day where things go wonky and you just want to get out, but you'll have a dozen open positions and you don't want to have to click around to close them all.
Also, it's always a good idea to put in "everything's gone to hell" stops and place orders that time-out, even if your strategy doesn't require them (algo strategies don't typically use actual stop orders for exits): you never know when your connection might die, and you really don't want to end up stuck with nasty positions that you don't even have any way to track or close out b/c your cable went out...the positions that you hold when doing algo stuff can on occasion end up frighteningly large, which is only acceptable if you're holding them for very short period of time.
HFT computers identify "direct arbitrage," and make a profit off of someone else's loss.
In this case, essentially every person that had a "stop loss" order was just hunted down by a wave of HFT programs and all those stop loss orders were triggered, which send "market orders" which means, fill my order at the current market price.
When everyone does this at the same time, there are more sellers than buyers so prices drop dramatically. However, this presents an opportunity for HFT programs especially when they have similar strategies, meaning they all are doing the same thing, pushing the market in the same direction. Now, the HFT programs forced people to get stopped out, then they bid the market up and buy, which pushes it right back to the prior level.
Take a look at AAPL, RIMM, GOOG, SPY, etc. and you'll see it is all the same pattern.