News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mind as an emergent self-organizing process by cocktailpeanuts on Sunday December 25, 2016 @02:36AM (#13253372)
It's kind of weird how this comes from a "scientist" instead of a philosopher. I read the article and it's basically saying this scientist guy came up with the definitive "definition" of the mind so other scientists can have a common ground to build upon.

While I understand where this is coming from, I still don't understand why a "scientist" is advertising this concept as something novel. Also I can't believe a scientist--who should know better--is trying to define this.

This debate has existed throughout human history and you could even arguably say the entire history of philosophy is to figure out the answer to this problem.

I also visited the author's book page on Amazon https://www.amazon.com/Mind-Journey-Heart-Being-Human/dp/039... (of which this article is an advertorial), and just look at that cover art. This is not a "scientist" material. Really reminds me of some Eckhart Tolle stuff.

Re:Mind as an emergent self-organizing process by infpetal on Sunday December 25, 2016 @07:58AM (#13253973)
Hi cocktailpeanuts,

Can I share with you some of the things I learned through reading his books?

You say he did this for scientists to share a common ground, but there is a more practical reason too. He's a practicing psychiatrist who has written books to help the general population with their mental health and relationships.

That is how I found him - through exploring attachment theory, of which he discusses a great deal.

What does this have to do with the idea of the mind as a self-emerging process, or a healthy mind as integrated?

It's this idea that is leveraged in his books to help teach people how to develop their mental health. It gives them a clear and concrete path to follow. The idea of integration is not just for intellectual beauty - it is a teaching tool.

He used an analogy of a choir to teach attachment theory. Anxious attachment: multiple people singing the same, prolonged, single note - connected, not differentiated. Avoidant attachment: everyone singing a different song - differentiated, not connected. A choir of people singing the same song, connected, and in harmony with a variety of pitches, differentiated, represents secure attachment and integration.

There is a visceral experience of something wonderful emerging when you hear the secure choir vs insecure, and likewise the well-being and health that comes from a secure attachment relationship (or an integrated mind) is viscerally wonderful too.

If you are happy to look at his ideas for their teaching applications, I encourage further investigation of his books and talks. They have been an anchor for my healing from trauma and I am deeply thankful.

Re:Mind as an emergent self-organizing process by mcguire on Sunday December 25, 2016 @05:40PM (#13255773)
If you have read his books, is this a suitable description of his definition of mind:

"After much discussion, they decided that a key component of the mind is: “the emergent self-organizing process, both embodied and relational, that regulates energy and information flow within and among us.”"

Just between you and me, I don't think that is very spectacular. But it's been years since I kept up with readings in the theory of mind.

Re:Mind as an emergent self-organizing process by inpetal on Sunday December 25, 2016 @09:12PM (#13256532)
Yes, in a similar way to saying 'I am a human being' is a description of me. :)

What I mean is that a brief, minimal description can be accurate but missing the joy, wonder and nuanced intimacy that comes from a deeper relationship.

For example, there is a wheel of awareness practice where you develop your ability to 'regulate energy and information flow'. You practice directing your consciousness to different points of awareness, one by one, and linking them together. Awareness of awareness itself is part of this practice too.

An exercise like this is when the definition above can come to life in your personal, subjective experience, and you get to observe how it looks and feels to you. You feel whether these ideas resonate with you, not just from assessing its logic, but from your felt experience. This is the spectacular part for me, the movement from abstract ideas to taking actions in the world that help improve my ability to thrive.

The emergent self-organizing part... think of a flock of birds in the sky and the shape it creates. No-one told the birds to make that specific shape. Likewise, no-one is telling me to speak these exact words to you. They have emerged from a combination of many processes coming together, culminating in an orchestra that somehow is coordinated well enough to let these ideas flow coherently from me to you. I can find this meaningful in many ways, some of them are: a sense of wonder, gratitude, trust, understanding how rigidity and chaos affects the shapes I make, looking at relationships and observing the emerging flow we make together and how it changes over time and what influences us.

This is my current understanding, but I am no expert. I can say that exploring a personal relationship with these ideas, developing my own hypotheses and observations and comparing them, and looking to observe these concepts in the world around me, has been deeply fulfilling.

Re:Mind as an emergent self-organizing process by naasking on Sunday December 25, 2016 @11:10AM (#13254506)
> Also I can't believe a scientist--who should know better--is trying to define this.

We're all philosophers, some are just better than others. The legitimacy of his argument is not dependent on his formal training, and so using this as a reason to dismiss his argument isn't valid.

Re:Mind as an emergent self-organizing process by cocktailpeanuts on Sunday December 25, 2016 @02:08PM (#13255058)
where did i dismiss his argument? I said he shouldn't sell "science" to tell this story. This is not science.
Re:Mind as an emergent self-organizing process by naasking on Sunday December 25, 2016 @05:37PM (#13255759)
Interpretation is part of every scientific theory. Many scientific theories that start exploring a new domain posit working definitions that and change and get refined over time.
Re:Mind as an emergent self-organizing process by fiatjaf on Sunday December 25, 2016 @06:30AM (#13253768)
You're probably right on all the other comments, but to say that "the entire history of philosophy is to figure out the answer to this problem" is bad.

Real philosophers, like those who lived from Socrates until Descartes, care too little to this question to even mention it, as the answer is given from the start.

Re:Mind as an emergent self-organizing process by cocktailpeanuts on Sunday December 25, 2016 @02:09PM (#13255062)
Are you saying everyone who called themselves philosophers after Decartes is fake? And I wouldn't just call someone "wrong" when it's obvious that you're making an opinion. As for the "real philosophers" thinking about this, learn more here https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophy_of_self
Re:Mind as an emergent self-organizing process by fiatjaf on Sunday December 25, 2016 @02:39PM (#13255148)
When I say "like those who..." I mean that all these were real philosophers, after Descartes that is not a rule anymore.

I would say that the real rule today is: everyone who publishes in philosophy magazines or has a chair in some philosophy department on some university is NOT a philosopher, all the others are.

As you can see from that Wikipedia article, the theme is totally ignored by philosophers. Wikipedia makes a huge effort to make a full article for it, but only achieves a small text full of sparse references to unrelated topics (self-knowledge, which is clearly not the same thing as we are talking about here; and various superficial silly comments from post-Descartes people).

Re:Mind as an emergent self-organizing process by WhitneyLand on Sunday December 25, 2016 @09:35AM (#13254196)
Yes, it's a mess. Its a poor mixture of:

- Scientific hypothesis of consciousness

- Self help / therapeutic framework

- Biology

- Metaphysics

The author should pick one of these perspectives and make a stronger case for one rather a weak case for all.

Re:Mind as an emergent self-organizing process by Cybiote on Sunday December 25, 2016 @08:29AM (#13254039)
I'm skeptical he made up any definitions since it hews quite close to existing ideas. With developments in AI, neuroscience and even physics, this stuff is starting to enter into science proper. The errors of the piece are no worse than your average pop piece (mostly in placing too much emphasis on chaos given how theoretical, compared to even the rest, that viewpoint is).