Let's put this more simply, if that is even possible.
You visit a site. You do not pay anything, but you log on.
You put stuff on the site.
Regardless of the business model, do you have any sort of reasonable expectations?
That's Facebook. That's HN. That's LinkedIn. That's any site that the visitor does not pay for yet is able to store things on there. Simple question.
Well, any sort of javascript that loads in on a page that comes from a central location could track you across sites. Advertisers have long tracked you. Google tracks you on the search, their browser tracks you on each page you visit, and Analytics tracks all site activity. A lot of browsers track you and provide feedback like PageRank.
All of these are free applications.
Perhaps this is the special case of 1) It being a web app, and 2) changing terms without notifying the user
I dunno. But I know lots of free services that you can sign up for (or not) track you in a lot of places you wouldn't expect. The difference is that you don't have this nifty little page to go to where you can see it all happening.
There is a bit of distorted thinking and mob mentality going on here. It's beginning to seem like every other week the tech community is out with torches and pitchforks. Kind of a "burn the witch!" thing going on.
I use FB, but I think it's model is about as evil as it can get, and that was before this happened. I'll be happy when we have some options.
I don't mind everybody piling on, but it is interesting to note the vast amount of inconsistencies in people's thinking. For me, I can handle the app stuff -- it's the use of my friends to make me act against my own interests that I find truly diabolic.
In this case, the customer is the advertiser, Facebook is the broker, and the users (and their data) are the product. With its recent action, Facebook is clearly saying "the customer comes first."
> Or one that says that people who visit free sites shouldn't complain?
Facebook may be free in the sense that I'm not giving them my credit card number and they are not charging me a monthly monetary fee, but the price of admission onto Facebook is your private information. Even if you don't enter anything in your profile, your friends will start to form the links (by searching for you and sending friend requests (even if you don't accept them) or tagging your face, etc.) that any marketing person pays big money for.
Facebook is not free and the customer is definitely coming first.