It looks like their benchmarks are particularly friendly to their cache size.
The biggest difference is that you still have to speak to Redis over the wire within a single machine, where Redis has it cached and replies. The (terrible terrible?) choice of JavaScript gets around this, once cached, it is directly in the app logic's memory - so you don't even have to perform any request. And that is where you get the speed gain.
Summary: GUN's caching is closer to the end result you are measuring, therefore it is faster. Not magical algorithms.
- What does GUN do badly?
Banking. Anything relating to strong consistency. GUN is an AP system which means you really shouldn't use it for anythign involving accounting, money, etc. - read more about that here: https://github.com/amark/gun/wiki/CAP-Theorem
Where should you use it instead of Redis? When you want realtime updates or graph data. There is a 10 minute guide on how to use graphs from a key/value, table or relational, or document oriented way here: https://github.com/amark/gun/wiki/graphs .