Re:Dramatically Reducing Software Vulnerabilities [pdf]
by zzzcpan on Saturday December 24, 2016 @10:03AM
(#13250017)
I don't want to argue, but I don't think those assumptions are correct and even if some are extrapolating them on manufacturers of consumer devices is still wrong. And this is important, because not understanding their view of the world is not going to give us any ideas of how to improve security.
Re:Dramatically Reducing Software Vulnerabilities [pdf]
by nickpsecurity on Saturday December 24, 2016 @08:47PM
(#13252453)
I get not wanting to argue. How about instead you give me links explaining "their view of the world" with its principles, challenges, and/or tradeoffs. Even if I disagree, I might learn something about another sector of the market that I can tailor recommendations or solutions to.
"we just don't have a lot of Ada, SPARK, Rust programmers in the world"
Sounds bright until one remembers almost every significant market in this space is an oligopoly where there's only a handful of companies. Profitable, too. They could split all the Ada, SPARK, Rust, etc programmers while still making plenty of money and getting results. Worked for companies using Ocaml (eg Jane Street), Haskell, and even Prolog. Those sorts find they get better talent when they ask for uncommon, tougher stuff.
"ISPs already have the expertise and the infrastructure to deal with them, once it's going to cause too much problems for the quality of their service. I've witnessed this myself."
Didn't stop most DDOS's from doing their damage at all. Took many players working together. Recent one had a mitigation vendor straight-up dump Brian Krebs. The problem being as easy as you describe wouldn't have such results. It's either hard or they don't care so much.