News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How inconsistent design will save iTunes by MWinther on Thursday May 06, 2010 @08:40AM (#1324263)
Apart from the fact that I believe this is a horrible, horrible idea (MS Office used to this to me with the menu items, worst idea ever) I believe there are more pressing matters to attend to when it comes to iTunes.
Re:How inconsistent design will save iTunes by Terretta on Thursday May 06, 2010 @11:41AM (#1324640)
Agreed -- controls that reconfigure themselves disorient habitual users who begin to rely on spatial memory.

Even the iPad's reflow of icons when rotated is mildly disorienting, even though each group stays on its own page.

Ribbon bars and self-hiding menus do ok in focus groups for first time users because they haven't yet formed spatial memory around the task.

Blur your eyes so you can't read text and you still know where the Edit menu is. You know where it is, so that's where it should be.