Re:The Space Shuttle Challenger Explosion and the O-ring
by aidenn0 on Thursday December 22, 2016 @05:53PM
(#13241131)
That Robinson paper is amazing, and I hadn't seen it before.
TL;DR:
The engineers said "Make these two fixes" and got 1.
The engineers said "Don't launch until the O-rings are redesigned" and were informed that 2 years of no-launch was unacceptible
The engineers said "Okay then, at least don't launch with an O-ring colder than any previous launch[1]" and this was accepted until a high-profile launch was repeatedly delayed.
Finally they were told "We will launch unless you can prove to us it's not flight ready" and due to natural uncertainties and a small number of data points they could not meet this burden of proof.
1: Well actually they weren't focused just on temperature, so it was really more of "outside of the envelop of previous launches"
TL;DR:
The engineers said "Make these two fixes" and got 1.
The engineers said "Don't launch until the O-rings are redesigned" and were informed that 2 years of no-launch was unacceptible
The engineers said "Okay then, at least don't launch with an O-ring colder than any previous launch[1]" and this was accepted until a high-profile launch was repeatedly delayed.
Finally they were told "We will launch unless you can prove to us it's not flight ready" and due to natural uncertainties and a small number of data points they could not meet this burden of proof.
1: Well actually they weren't focused just on temperature, so it was really more of "outside of the envelop of previous launches"