Re:Time Machine: H.L. Mencken's 1925 Review of 'The Great Ga...
by ashark on Thursday December 22, 2016 @01:44PM
(#13239353)
Mencken's chosen qualifiers are right there in the text:
"I make much of this improvement because it is of an order not witnessed in American writers; and seldom, indeed, in those who start off with popular success."
Emphasis mine. American writers and the one-hit wonders of the literary world tend to get worse rather than better, he's saying. The first is probably a justifiable statement at the time—decent-to-good American literature was rare (though not entirely absent) in the English corpus before the moderns (many of whom preferred to live in Europe, anyway).
"I make much of this improvement because it is of an order not witnessed in American writers; and seldom, indeed, in those who start off with popular success."
Emphasis mine. American writers and the one-hit wonders of the literary world tend to get worse rather than better, he's saying. The first is probably a justifiable statement at the time—decent-to-good American literature was rare (though not entirely absent) in the English corpus before the moderns (many of whom preferred to live in Europe, anyway).