News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Architecture of Evil: Dystopian Megacorps in Speculat... by vtange on Thursday December 22, 2016 @11:55AM (#13238502)
Back in my days of architecture school we threw around terms such as "human scale" and "typology" in classes.

The article demonstrates well the idea of "typology" - how we came to associate Brutalist structures with FBI-style surveillance states. Did you know we also associate stuff like Greek Columns with government in general?

The "human scale" term refers to how a building's shape and texture should be broken up to break up any notion of the building being looming/threatening to tiny humans by comparison - kind of like how a person would prefer wearing different colors as opposed to a monocolor jumpsuit.

Almost all "evil" architecture fails human scale design on purpose by making oversized elements or using the same material everywhere - the idea is to make the organization seem greater than the individual or even society, and make it seem impossible to challenge. This is also seen in architecture built or designed by fascist Germany and Italy back in the 1930s, for exactly this reason. Look up https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fascist_architecture if you want more.

Re:The Architecture of Evil: Dystopian Megacorps in Speculat... by jrochkind1 on Thursday December 22, 2016 @04:28PM (#13240543)
There's a lot of brutalist architecture which is actually delightfully human scale. I love the good stuff and hate how 'brutalist' has become a synonym for 'domineering and brutal' to many.
Re:The Architecture of Evil: Dystopian Megacorps in Speculat... by jpindar on Friday December 23, 2016 @11:59AM (#13245748)
Same here. While there are obvious exceptions, the style often makes me think of colleges and especially community colleges, which is a very good association. College buildings in this style are typically not as huge and monolithic as government buildings and often have brick, glass, and wood accents, which soften the look.
Re:The Architecture of Evil: Dystopian Megacorps in Speculat... by Finnucane on Thursday December 22, 2016 @01:28PM (#13239237)
That's funny, in the context of American buildings, the first thing that comes to mind when I think of Greek columns in Georgian mansions. Only after that do I think of perhaps courthouses.

Here in Boston, the brutalist monstrosity that is our city hall has its Soviet oppressiveness enhanced by the pillbox-laden concrete wasteland that surrounds it. It really is a monument to government power.

Re:The Architecture of Evil: Dystopian Megacorps in Speculat... by ghaff on Thursday December 22, 2016 @01:42PM (#13239342)
Boston City Hall really is an epic attempt to outdo Soviet era totalitarian architecture. There is at least some effort to do something with the windswept brickyard that surrounds it. [1] I haven't followed these plans all that closely but, to the degree the surrounding space can be made more useful/inviting, it would help a lot.

I'd also note that the brutalist addition to the Boston Public Library always struck me as rather a desecration of the original Beaux Arts structure but the recent remodel and cleanup actually created a rather open and airy space. I still don't love the architecture but it's a big improvement.

[1] https://nextcity.org/daily/entry/boston-city-hall-plaza-rede...

Re:The Architecture of Evil: Dystopian Megacorps in Speculat... by hx87 on Thursday December 22, 2016 @01:51PM (#13239411)
Pure brutalism is bad enough, but in Boston (and to a lesser extent, the rest of the US) we just had to muck it up with fake-traditional touches like brick facing that make it look so much worse. IMO the worst part of City Hall isn't the concrete honeycomb superstructure, it's the brick-clad base. Brick is good when its appearance makes structural sense: arches or lintels over openings, proper sills, a combination of headers and stretchers, etc. However it's always monolithic, and the only thing worse than monolithic concrete is monolithic brick. That's why I'll take the BPL extension over city hall any day--at least BPL is purely brutalist and makes no apologies for it.
Re:The Architecture of Evil: Dystopian Megacorps in Speculat... by stcredzero on Thursday December 22, 2016 @02:46PM (#13239772)
Pure brutalism is bad enough

I think, just for the building itself, that the Houston Public Library serves its function very well. It is an excellent building for its purpose, and I rather like going there. The courtyard outside, though, is a stellar example of how US culture has completely forgotten how to create public spaces of value. (Why is it that Houston, of all places, seems to be challenged to remember why shade is useful!)

Re:The Architecture of Evil: Dystopian Megacorps in Speculat... by ghaff on Thursday December 22, 2016 @02:57PM (#13239876)
One of the things that seems to happen is that there's often a sufficient aversion to businesses making money in public spaces that you end up with barren expanses rather than cafes, shops/stalls, etc. In Boston the difference between the utilization of City Hall Plaza and Quincy Market/Fanueil Hall is instructive.

That's not to say that public parks need to be crammed full of commerce but people often need some reason beyond "open space" to go into an area.

Re:The Architecture of Evil: Dystopian Megacorps in Speculat... by linksnapzz on Thursday December 22, 2016 @02:10PM (#13239534)
If you can find it, Walt Lockley's "Brutalized in Boston" essay from 2007 is the best critique I've ever found of city hall, and what motivated the design of what appears to be an enormous concrete ziggurat fired point-down into what used to be Scollay Square.

I wish I had a copy-it is an enormously enjoyable piece.

Re:The Architecture of Evil: Dystopian Megacorps in Speculat... by ghaff on Thursday December 22, 2016 @02:30PM (#13239647)
Here you go, courtesy of the Wayback Machine: https://web.archive.org/web/20081227044845/http://www.waltlo...

(waltlockley.com still exists although it looks as if it hasn't been updated for almost 10 years. But some of the older content doesn't seem to be there any longer.)

ADDED: One fun paragraph from the piece:

So imagine the real experience of government through the eyes of a pedestrian forced to traverse a windswept empty plaza ('windswept' is just a word, but, please, understand that it's a whole set of unpleasant sensations, 'windswept' is shorthand for windswept, snowswept, exposed to cold wet penetrating Boston wind, featureless, hard and flat, forbidding, uninteresting, vulnerabilzing, isolating, scaled-to-intimidate), past the broken promise of a fountain that has never ever worked (too bad we don't have a Broken Fountains theory to go along with the Broken Windows theory), to approach the underside of a top-heavy, brooding, hulking concrete fortress (and by 'fortress' I mean instantly, cinematically, viscerally, recognizably-by-shape-alone out of human scale, comparable to the worst of Soviet work), rough to the touch and confusing as hell, a building that wastes your time, a building with cavernous voids vaguely threatening and vaguely empty, so he or she can climb upstairs and register to vote. All metaphors aside, that voter learns things during a journey like that. That voter draws certain conclusions about Boston and voting and his role as a citizen. Whether he knows it or not.

Re:The Architecture of Evil: Dystopian Megacorps in Speculat... by azdle on Thursday December 22, 2016 @01:50PM (#13239393)
For anyone else interested, here's a picture: https://c.o0bg.com/rf/image_960w/Boston/2011-2020/2016/09/07...
Re:The Architecture of Evil: Dystopian Megacorps in Speculat... by kofejnik on Thursday December 22, 2016 @03:07PM (#13239956)
this is fugly even by Soviet standards, esp. constrasted to e.g. this one in Moscow: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seven_Sisters_(Moscow)#/media/...
Re:The Architecture of Evil: Dystopian Megacorps in Speculat... by ghaff on Thursday December 22, 2016 @03:18PM (#13240026)
The Seven Sisters aren't representative of ugly mass of concrete Soviet-era architecture though. I'm not sure I'd call them beautiful but they're rather distinctive and they don't jump out as particularly ugly. Wikipedia claims they're a combination of Russian Baroque and Gothic styles but someone with more architectural background than I may have a better classification.

As the Wikipedia article also notes the Seven Sisters have considerable similarities to icons like the Wrigley Building in Chicago. (Not sure I buy a couple of the other comparisons.)

Re:The Architecture of Evil: Dystopian Megacorps in Speculat... by wott on Thursday December 22, 2016 @04:25PM (#13240520)
But Russians sometimes call the "ugly mass of concrete Soviet-era architecture" French style... And well, as a French, I can't claim they are wrong about that :-/
Re:The Architecture of Evil: Dystopian Megacorps in Speculat... by ghaff on Thursday December 22, 2016 @04:56PM (#13240723)
No, Le Corbusier and all that.
Re:The Architecture of Evil: Dystopian Megacorps in Speculat... by wott on Thursday December 22, 2016 @05:14PM (#13240863)
Yes, that accounts for one part, the one with ideas behind, a style, a urban and a life project. And then there is the other part, the loosely inspired, derived copies with no real plan.

Not sure which part brought the worst failures :-)

Re:The Architecture of Evil: Dystopian Megacorps in Speculat... by abrowne on Thursday December 22, 2016 @10:56PM (#13242717)
(Who was Swiss.)
Re:The Architecture of Evil: Dystopian Megacorps in Speculat... by ghaff on Friday December 23, 2016 @08:09AM (#13244523)
Who lived and worked in Paris for most of his life.
Re:The Architecture of Evil: Dystopian Megacorps in Speculat... by DrPhish on Thursday December 22, 2016 @12:51PM (#13238956)
If you're interested in a good overview of Architecture in the context of period art/philosophy (and culture in general), it would be hard to recommend Kenneth Clark's Civilisation [0] series more. It shows the development of architecture through the ages in context, and he has extremely interesting and insightful views on what that says about the human condition of the people living at the time.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civilisation_(TV_series)

Re:The Architecture of Evil: Dystopian Megacorps in Speculat... by semi-extrinsic on Thursday December 22, 2016 @12:31PM (#13238787)
Out of curiosity, how do you think the SIS building in London fits in architecturally?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SIS_Building

Re:The Architecture of Evil: Dystopian Megacorps in Speculat... by vtange on Thursday December 22, 2016 @12:59PM (#13239013)
This building is less brutalist and more postmodern - notice how it has a less obvious shape (it's not just a tower or a big rectangle or anything) and is instead made up by many different shapes. Postmodernism actually tried to remedy some of the downsides of modernism/brutalism by trying out mixtures of forms and textures.

The SIS still suffers from a limited material palette and needs further break-up to reach the human scale. Especially at the ground level - imagine standing next to that building - it would feel like standing beside a huge wall!

Re:The Architecture of Evil: Dystopian Megacorps in Speculat... by jrochkind1 on Thursday December 22, 2016 @04:35PM (#13240592)
Eh, that sounds like a 'no true scotsman' argument -- if the building doesn't suck, it must not be brutalist!

Some of my favorite brutalist buildings are libraries, somehow it works very well for the kind of very public building a library is. And the best definitely feel human-scale to interact with (often _especially_ in the interior plans, which you can't get from a picture really), and are more visually interesting than a big rectangle. I don't think anyone said if it's not a big rectangle it's not brutalist!

Here's one I'm fond of:

https://library.ucsd.edu/about/us/geisel-building.html

Re:The Architecture of Evil: Dystopian Megacorps in Speculat... by linksnapzz on Thursday December 22, 2016 @11:11PM (#13242768)
Funny enough, Geisel has many of the same problems that Boston City Hall/ Gov't Ctr. does...two that leap to mind is that the entrances to both are hidden under the concrete superstructure, and that the pedestrian approach to both at ground-level involves crossing a flat, empty concrete plain.

Rarely if ever did I see anyone at UCSD taking advantage of the area underneath the stack tower, even for shade on hot summer days. That said, the view from the stacks, with the floor-to-ceiling glass, was spectacular. Especially looking north, down the slope of pepper canyon. The rest of the library has the sort of issues that are common to Brutalist buildings in La Jolla-for instance, reinforced concrete is not as durable when sitting close to the ocean as you might hope. As was put by a faculty member I worked with "...the windows don't open; but they do leak!"

I prefer the enthusiastic futurist poured-concrete '60s buildings to the craptacular corporate office-park nonsense that so many newer buildings on campus have.

Fun fact: Pereira did not intend the Geisel Library stacks to look like the concrete & glass banyan tree that got built...it was originally supposed to be a concrete sphere on a single, giant column!