News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Update on Multi-Process Firefox by JoshTriplett on Wednesday December 21, 2016 @11:52PM (#13234926)
Apparently the SSL certificate for that site expired a few days ago and nobody renewed it.

Certificate expiration seems like one of the most ridiculous aspects of TLS. Its only use case (apart from generating more money for CAs) seems like "we somehow can't revoke the certificate, but if we wait it'll expire".

Re:Update on Multi-Process Firefox by yuubi on Thursday December 22, 2016 @02:44AM (#13235637)
If the cert is revoked, the revocation notice only needs to be published until the expiration date instead of forever.
Re:Update on Multi-Process Firefox by TheRealPomax on Thursday December 22, 2016 @12:18AM (#13235043)
that's kind of also a really important use case. "There is no reason to trust this certificate in perpetuity, so pretending it hasn't been compromised over a long period of time would be stupidly insecure. Let's expire it after X months". There is no reason to trust a certificate that's older than a year, for instance, there's been more than enough time for someone to reverse engineer the keys if they wanted. The real part you should be questioning is why no one renewed it. It's pretty trivial to set up cert renewal, so why didn't they? Maybe the site's no longer maintained, maybe it's not actually intended to be secure. Important questions.
Re:Update on Multi-Process Firefox by JoshTriplett on Thursday December 22, 2016 @12:48AM (#13235163)
> There is no reason to trust a certificate that's older than a year, for instance, there's been more than enough time for someone to reverse engineer the keys if they wanted.

Cryptography does not work that way.

> It's pretty trivial to set up cert renewal, so why didn't they?

That holds true today, with Let's Encrypt; their short expiration date seems to exist largely to force people to automate it, and in that regard it seems quite effective. But prior to that, many CAs did not have scriptable automated processes to renew certificates.

Re:Update on Multi-Process Firefox by fgonzag on Thursday December 22, 2016 @03:35AM (#13235853)
> There is no reason to trust a certificate that's older than a year, for instance, there's been more than enough time for someone to reverse engineer the keys if they wanted.

> Cryptography does not work that way.

But it kind of does. Imagine if we were still using certificates signed with DES and MD5 hashes because they were available perpetually. Certificate expiration at the very least means that whenever you renew you're keeping up to date with whatever vulnerabilities have been exploited in the past 3-5 years.

It also keeps CRLs short and concise as those certificates that have expired do not need to be included.

Re:Update on Multi-Process Firefox by JoshTriplett on Thursday December 22, 2016 @03:44AM (#13235881)
> Imagine if we were still using certificates signed with DES and MD5 hashes because they were available perpetually.

We don't rely on expiration or revocation for that; we rely on clients and servers refusing to use insecure algorithms.