I'd need to think about it a bit more to convince myself it doesn't have any significant downsides though; it's less obvious to me. For one thing, requiring an OTP approach seems to constrain the set of encryption schemes you can use. (e.g. imagine an algorithm that reverses all the bits of every block before doing anything else.) Furthermore, if your custom encryption scheme happens to leave any kind of "watermark" on the ciphertext that makes it obvious it wasn't something standard like AES, applying the standard layer last will prevent the attacker from realizing you have a custom layer at all, until the standard layer is broken. Whereas if you use the OTP+XOR scheme, it might become obvious something else is going on too.
That said, this approach might actually be stronger than the layered approach, so it might actually be better. Need to think about it more :)
Not going to rehash the arguments, but this was discussed recently: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13199471