News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Social Security Garnished for Unpaid Student Debt by vkou on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @04:06PM (#13223968)
Actually, almost all of the time, when you take out a loan, you can choose to repay it, or file for bankruptcy. In the case of uncollateralized loans (Credit cards, utilities), the lender is quite likely to receive next to nothing for it.

We just need to make student loans dischargeable through bankruptcy, and all of these problems will be fixed. Lenders will stop lending children hundreds of thousands of dollars to get a European history degree, tuition fees will implode...

Re:Social Security Garnished for Unpaid Student Debt by generj on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @04:14PM (#13224069)
I agree with this, but there has to be some kind of reasonable time limit where bankruptcy doesn't apply. Otherwise every cunning student will just apply for bankruptcy right after graduation (made very easy because they don't yet have a job and have almost no assets).

I'd be OK with bankruptcy ending student debt after a time frame of 5-7 years.

Re:Social Security Garnished for Unpaid Student Debt by new_hackers on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @04:31PM (#13224228)
Yup, and this is what was happening (AFAIK) and why they added the stipulation that student loans weren't absolved in bankruptcy.

Otherwise, why not everyone become a neuro-surgeon? A couple hundred thousand dollars wiped away right after collage, only so they can become paid far beyond reasonable wages afterward and owe nothing.

Re:Social Security Garnished for Unpaid Student Debt by brazzledazzle on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @04:55PM (#13224467)
So it stands to reason that if you create a special class of debt you should have a special class of debt collection. If your income and/or assets are greater than $X then collect. That would keep people from playing the system and keep someone who depends on social security to survive from having their checks garnished.

We're so obsessed with stopping cheats in this country we'll cut off our nose to spite our face.

Re:Social Security Garnished for Unpaid Student Debt by vkou on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @04:44PM (#13224359)
Except that you're setting yourself up for a lot of suffering for the next decade, as your credit rating is destroyed. This cuts you out of a lot of opportunities. Very few people are in a position where they can opt out of having a passable credit rating.
Re:Social Security Garnished for Unpaid Student Debt by generj on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @05:02PM (#13224548)
Absolutely true, but it wouldn't prevent some people from making a bad decision anyways.

I'll also note that many student's credit ratings are garbage anyways, or they have no credit history to speak of. So the immediate consequences may be limited, and many people don't fully think through future impacts. These kinds of people also tend to be the kind of people who take on a lot of debt for a non-marketable degree.

Re:Social Security Garnished for Unpaid Student Debt by LeifCarrotson on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @04:46PM (#13224386)
> We just need to make student loans dischargeable through bankruptcy, and all of these problems will be fixed. Lenders will stop lending children hundreds of thousands of dollars to get a European history degree, tuition fees will implode...

And lenders will also stop lending children a few tens of thousands of dollars to go to a reasonably priced state school and get an education that's valued by the job market. This can allow them to escape poverty and have comparable equality of opportunity to the children whose parents happen to be wealthy.

Taking away student loans is not fair to those kids.

Re:Social Security Garnished for Unpaid Student Debt by vkou on Wednesday December 21, 2016 @03:30PM (#13232356)
The government should be directly subsidizing education for the poor. In the long run, it's a lot cheaper then letting them continue to be poor.

There are ways to do this, and, at the same time, limit upward price pressures. Also, it does so already, as if you default on your student loans, the lender still gets paid - but the government foots the bill.

Re:Social Security Garnished for Unpaid Student Debt by msandford on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @04:15PM (#13224079)
In the long run that'll solve the problem. In the short run, however, there will be bad side effects. My hope would be to change the law with a 5-10 year roll-out period so that people who just started high school know what kind of deal they're getting sooner rather than later. That way they and their parents can have time to plan intelligently even if they don't really like the new rules, at least they won't be ambushed by them.