News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by brownbat on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @08:27AM (#13219550)
The most moving and informed coverage of the US education system I've heard have all been through This American Life.[0][1][2][3]

Ok, there's an easy four hours of content to listen to. Enjoy!

The short takeaway for me was basically that local funding through property taxes is a terrible idea if you want anything approaching fairness.

If you can afford to live in an area with high property taxes, the US school system is great, your kids probably go to a great school. If you are struggling to get by, though, living in an apartment? Your kids are usually banned from going to that same great school by law.

It's like anti-literacy laws were too obvious, so we just made them more byzantine.

[0] http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/562/t...

[1] http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/563/t...

[2] http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/512/h...

Significantly, on how redlining contributed to the achievement gap. The heartbreaking story of why a girl who wants to go to school down the road is turned away.

[3] http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/534/a...

A description of another poor high school where the kids basically have recess, lunch, or permanent substitutes all day, because it's failed by local control.

Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by phd514 on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @09:12AM (#13219908)
The problem with that conclusion is that some of the highest-funded public schools in the country such as DC are among the worst performers. Funding is not the sole (or even most important) determinant of quality in education.
Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by jschwartzi on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @09:49AM (#13220225)
Do you have a breakdown for how much of DC schools funding makes it to the classroom and to teachers? It's my understanding that administrators soak up a huge amount of budget in many districts.
Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by hawkice on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @11:13AM (#13221112)
Administration does take a lot of money, but instruction is somewhere in the 35-53% range. That may sound low, but that's still quite a lot considering it buys only ~60% high school graduation rates -- worse than, for instance, Chile, which costs ~10x less to administer.

Suffice it to say, the operation of these schools is inefficient in the extreme by any way I can measure it. That's why a relatively poor country like China can even generate headlines like this. But the problem persists across private schools, too, largely, so I think it's fair to say this is a tough problem to solve.

http://www.ncpa.org/pub/ba745

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/local/wp/2015/06/02/the-...

http://www.pbs.org/newshour/rundown/high-school-graduation-r...

http://www.ascd.org/ASCD/images/publications/books/stewart20...

http://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php/...

Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by aviator168 on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @02:25PM (#13223038)
Don't about DC. In Long Island, New York State. Per student funding is $22K+. Our kids get very good educations.
Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by brownbat on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @08:18PM (#13226000)
Sorry, wasn't clear. This conclusion isn't limited to funding.

It doesn't necessarily mean that the high performing schools are high performing because they have a high tax base, that's just a correlation.

Quality teachers may not be attracted to inner-city schools because of unstated biases, or because they prefer to live in other areas and have short commutes.

Or maybe you have a safety issue due to a school's location or an aging building and high rents that diverts resources towards countermeasures or repairs.

For whatever reason though, busing led to miraculously improved outcomes. Then we stopped doing it for some reason. Now, instead, we make some kids stay in schools where they have six hours of recess or lunch or study hall, then one session with a permanent math substitute with no lesson plans.

So yeah, funding isn't everything--but some schools can't even afford teachers for every hour of the day, or roofs that aren't collapsing. If there is a minimum threshold not being met, funding's probably part of it. The better solution is to just not bar kids who want to learn from functioning schools.

Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by devinhelton on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @08:48PM (#13226168)
For whatever reason though, busing led to miraculously improved outcomes.

This is asserted in episode 562, but no evidence was cited. I did a deep dive on this myself, reading numerous studies and various books, and in my opinion any link between integration and academic achievement is minimal at best. Read the two books by Raymond Wolters, and then compare with the American Life episodes, and make your own judgement about which side has the more accurate narrative.

Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by miles7 on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @10:18AM (#13220492)
Some
Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by devinhelton on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @11:20AM (#13221190)
The most moving and informed coverage of the US education system I've heard have all been through This American Life

What makes you think it is the most informed coverage? These episodes only give you one side of the argument. If you want the other side try reading The Long Crusade and/or The Burden of Brown by Professor Raymond Wolters. I also myself wrote a long blog post about integration/desegregation as it happened in Boston, a post based on very credible academic histories, which gives a very different take than the NPR/PBS take: https://devinhelton.com/busing-in-boston

Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by burkaman on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @12:31PM (#13221905)
This seems well-researched, and there are some reasonable points, but your section #4 and conclusion really discredit the rest of the article.

Section 4 describes how racism (or tribalism or whatever you want to call it) is really natural and healthy, with no references except your own "common sense".

> Now imagine growing up and looking forward to playing on the same football team as your elders in front a cheering hometown crowd. And then that dream is taken away from you by some unelected judge. At his order, another tribe invades, takes your spot on the football team and dates the girl you were wooing. You are not going to like that very much. You might want to join with your tribal brothers and brawl with this opposing tribe in the lunch room. And of course the other tribe is going to fight back.

What the fuck? Why would I want to fight people for being better at football than me? Why would I start a race war because some guy with different skin than me is dating a girl I like? How can you possibly see this as acceptable? You can argue that it's natural, but natural doesn't mean good.

Do you understand that not everybody thinks like this? If a black guy gets promoted over me, I don't get angry at the black tribe for invading my homeland. That line of thinking is, as you say, cartoonishly racist.

And then in your conclusion, you correctly identify racial disparities, and then sort of argue that's the way it should be. The fact that black people do worse than white people in school is a problem worth solving, not a convenient method of grouping students, right? The only way this status quo could be acceptable is if you think black kids are genetically predisposed to be less intelligent. Your article on racism does bring that up, but I can't tell if it's a belief you hold. If you do believe that, you should be more clear about it in this school segregation article, otherwise your conclusions don't make sense.

Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by devinhelton on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @01:28PM (#13222509)
Section 4 describes how racism (or tribalism or whatever you want to call it) is really natural and healthy, with no references except your own "common sense".

My view on tribalism is similar to my view on "greed" or "personal self-interest." It exists. We are a tribal species, as any survey of human history will show, from the time of the Chimpanzees onward ( https://www.amazon.com/Demonic-Males-Origins-Human-Violence/... ). Specifically, humans form tribes that are some combination of clan/ethnicity based, or are synthetic tribes based on ideology/beliefs/religion/nationalism. Social policy must be made with awareness of this tribal nature, not in defiance of it. Tribalism can be reduced, channeled, defanged, changed in form (to be non-racially based), but only by being aware of it.

What the fuck? Why would I want to fight people for being better at football than me? Why would I start a race war because some guy with different skin than me is dating a girl I like? How can you possibly see this as acceptable? You can argue that it's natural, but natural doesn't mean good. Do you understand that not everybody thinks like this? If a black guy gets promoted over me, I don't get angry at the black tribe for invading my homeland.

One of the main arguments for integration is needed to fix historical problems of bad race relations. My point is simply that large-scale, forced integration made race relation problems much worse. It created problems where little existed. Yeah, maybe working class teenagers should be less tribalistic and shouldn't think that way. But in the 1970s Boston was a city of tribes, it had neighborhoods of Irish ethnics, Italian ethnics, Jews, and blacks. Just adding 400 kids from another tribe to a school, and creating competition for the things that 16 year old male hominids value, was going to create conflict. I am just pointing out that the "solution" to race problems made race problems worse, and for very obvious reasons. Even if you think that forced integration was a necessary way to break the back of tribalism altogether -- there should have been a plan to actually break tribalism. Just throwing the kids together and putting the two groups in competition was not going to accomplish the goal of breaking tribalism.

And then in your conclusion, you correctly identify racial disparities, and then sort of argue that's the way it should be.

I didn't go into the reasons for the disparities because it wasn't really relevant to the point about de facto segregation. For instance, the NY Times has run a bunch of articles blaming academic gaps on stuff like early childhood nutrition [1], or disadvantaged kids having as many high-quality words spoken to them [2] [3], or not as many books in the house [4]. Conservatives sometimes blame single-parent families and poor attitudes towards education. So let's say that those one of those early childhood or home-based reasons are the reasons for the academic achievement gap. The result is that the achievement gap is already in place by the time the kids are at 8th grade or 10th grade. So just merging the black kids who are two grade levels behind into the same classrooms as white kids isn't going to help the black kids at all. It's just going to make it really hard for the teacher to help kids who will need an entirely different lesson plan.

[1] http://www.nytimes.com/2009/04/16/opinion/16kristof.html?_r=... [2] http://www.nytimes.com/2012/10/07/nyregion/for-poor-schoolch... [3] https://www.nytimes.com/2014/10/17/us/quality-of-words-not-q... [4] http://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/05/16/a-book-in-ev...

Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by hurbledr on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @04:01PM (#13223920)
> My point is simply that large-scale, forced integration made race relation problems much worse. It created problems where little existed.

Are you really arguing that desegregation created these problems? Seems a bit backwards to me. I think it's incredibly obvious that race relation issues existed long before the desegregation of schools.

You could argue that desegregation caused problems for white people where there were none before, but even that I find a bit questionable. There are many disadvantages to growing up in a homogeneous society.

I think everyone agrees that correcting racism, or tribalism if you prefer, is a difficult task, and one that we are still grappling with. Of course, there were other methods of desegregation proposed at the time, but very few were proposed in good faith, and none that I know of were as swift or effective as mass desegregation.

Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by devinhelton on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @05:14PM (#13224672)
Are you really arguing that desegregation created these problems? Seems a bit backwards to me. I think it's incredibly obvious that race relation issues existed long before the desegregation of schools.

Did you read my post? https://devinhelton.com/busing-in-boston I'm talking mostly about Boston, though I've found the same things when researching other northern cities. I'm not sure about the American south, I haven't studied it enough to either confirm or question the conventional wisdom.

In Boston, there was surely some racial animosity and shit talking before forced busing became a big issue. But it didn't seem to be that bad -- for example there is that quote in my post of the black school teacher who said she never had problems at Southie High before the busing. The busing made relations much worse, and the images we have of people being cartoonishly racist only came after forced busing.

none that I know of were as swift or effective as mass desegregation.

In the northern cities, mass desegregation failed in every single way. It did not improve race relations, it did not make black people better off, it did not result in more integration. Read my post.

Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by hurbledr on Thursday December 22, 2016 @03:12PM (#13239985)
>Boston did not have a Jim Crow system – if a black child lived in a white area, he could go to the local mostly white school.

So you are arguing that Boston was so racially tolerant in the 70's that they had no racist policies either explicit or implicit, and that a black kid could go to a white school completely unmolested? That they wouldn't be yelled at or beaten? That they would be welcomed with open arms?

Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by devinhelton on Thursday December 22, 2016 @11:53PM (#13242930)
What I wrote is what I wrote, and what argued is what I argued. Boston did not have a Jim Crow system whereby all blacks kids went to black schools and all white kids went to white schools. Schools were assigned by neighborhood, (with some ability for transfers). So if a neighborhood was all white, then you get a very white school. Mixed neighborhoods had more mixed schools. Here is a racial breakdown of the schools, two years before forced busing: https://repository.library.northeastern.edu/downloads/neu:m0...

So what was the experience like of the non-white kids in a majority white school (or vice versa)? That would vary a lot based on the particular school. I certainly do not argue that all schools would "welcome with open arms" outsiders of a different ethnicity. And especially not Charlestown High and South Boston High -- those neighborhood were quite parochial. When Italians started going to Charlestown High for instance, they were called "Wops" and such and there were fights. I don't have any good information on the experience of any black students attending those schools before forced busing. Most black students taking advantage of open enrollment would have gone elsewhere because Charlestown High and South Boston HIgh were crappy and overcrowded.

There was a voluntary busing program in Boston called Project Exodus in the mid 1960s whereby up to 600 black students were bused to mostly white schools. There was a survey of parents, that found ( https://repository.library.northeastern.edu/downloads/neu:m0... ) : "Other findings indicate that the mothers think that grades have improved, the amount of homework the children have to do has increased, their children have more white friends, that there is not a lot of prejudice or discrimination encountered at the new schools. With respect to this last distribution, only seven (or 10%) of the respondents felt that their children encountered a lot of prejudice, fifteen percent thought their children encountered some, while 70 percent thought their children encountered litttle or no prejudice or discrimination"

Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by burkaman on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @05:10PM (#13224628)
Your view on tribalism as described here is fine, but the tone of the article is not "tribalism is an unfortunate reality", it's "tribalism is normal and healthy".

> Peace occurs when tribes exist in a stable equilibrium. Peace exists when boundaries are clear, ownership of turf is clear, and when overstepping the boundaries will result in swift and sure retribution, thus making conflict unprofitable.

This worldview has caused so much pain and suffering that I can't really believe you would write it with a straight face. You're basically describing the Cold War as the most stable and peaceful state of geopolitics. You're advocating for all people to define themselves primarily by race, never associate with other races, and violently defend their race when there's an infraction.

> Thus the entire liberal cure for racism, at least in Boston, was actually the cause of the most virulent racism. By forcing these groups together, and putting people in conflict over girls, basketball courts, spots on varsity, etc, the busing created friction and animosity.

Another huge problem with your article, demonstrated here, is that you never once acknowledge a time before 1977. You write as if everything was great, and then those meddling liberals tried to integrate schools and thereby invented racism.

> My point is simply that large-scale, forced integration made race relation problems much worse. It created problems where little existed.

Really, no big problems before desegregation? I know you know this isn't true, why write it? I don't think desegregation is a magic cure any more than you do, and I don't think anyone claims that, although I've never seen Eyes on the Prize. But while segregated schools might have been a nice local minimum of racism, violence, and suffering, they were not anywhere close to the global minimum. Forced integration, while obviously not perfect, was necessary to start solving some big problems, even if it caused some new problems of its own.

> I am just pointing out that the "solution" to race problems made race problems worse, and for very obvious reasons.

No, that's one of your points, but the thesis is much broader. You claim that these beliefs are wrong: "racial segregation was bad, and that efforts to integrate schools were worthy moral crusades."

Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by devinhelton on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @08:00PM (#13225906)
"Your view on tribalism as described here is fine, but the tone of the article is not "tribalism is an unfortunate reality", it's "tribalism is normal and healthy"."

It's the same thing.

Compare again to greed or selfishness. An excess of selfishness, avarice, is pathological. But having zero regard for self-interest, being altruistic to the extent of self-denial, is also bad. A modest amount of selfishness is natural and healthy.

Traits are healthy when then form a productive, evolutionary stable strategy. If I am ultra-altruistic, that is not stable because those who are more selfish will win out and become dominant. If people are predatory, that is bad because it leads to everyone bringing each other down. If people are modestly selfish, while engaging in reciprocal altruism, and a tit-for-tat (or maybe tit-for-two-tats) strategy against defectors, that is a healthy, productive, and stable strategy.

The same goes with tribalism. Tribalism can generally be defined as forming a tight bond with a group in order to perform coordinated action. If you avoid any form of tribalism as a strategy, then a group that acts tribally will dominate you. Avoiding tribalism is not an ESS. If you are tribal and predate on other tribes, that is also bad, it makes everyone worse off. The healthy strategy is for a tribe to look after its own interest, engage in reciprocal altruism with other tribes, and a tit-for-tat (or maybe tit-for-two-tats) strategy against other tribes that break the peace.

Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by devinhelton on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @05:44PM (#13224969)
This worldview has caused so much pain and suffering that I can't really believe you would write it with a straight face. You're basically describing the Cold War as the most stable and peaceful state of geopolitics. You're advocating for all people to define themselves primarily by race, never associate with other races, and violently defend their race when there's an infraction.

Oh come on. I clarified that people can be tribal in different ways -- by national identity, by religion, by polis, by clan, etc. You cannot get rid of people being tribal. You can change the type of tribalism (although that is not easy), but you cannot get rid of it. Since tribalism exists, you have peace when borders are clear, and you have war when borders between tribes are unclear, or when one tribe is actively preying upon another.

The Cold War was violent to the extent that boundaries were not clear. There were lots of fighting over third world countries that weren't clearly owned by either sphere (hence the very definition of the word "third world"). There was global conflict between the USSR and USA because both felt the other was predatory, both thought the other was trying to actively extend its territory. That is not a good equilibrium, that is not a good state of affairs.

Also, conversations are better when you make an effort to read with a little bit of charity. By "boundaries are clear" I do not mean that people should never associate with each other. The US and Canada have a clear boundary, with clear rules for coming across the boundary. That doesn't mean we never associate with Canadians. And if a Canadian commits a crime upon an American, they will be arrested by an armed American and suitably punished. And vice versa. That's a stable, good equilibrium.

Another huge problem with your article, demonstrated here, is that you never once acknowledge a time before 1977....Really, no big problems before desegregation? I know you know this isn't true, why write it?

If we just consider problems of racial animosity in Boston, on a scale of 1 to 10, they were maybe at 3 before forced integration and at 8 afterwards. That is my sense from reading the historical accounts. See the example of the black Southie school teacher who did not notice problems before the forced busing.

Obviously racial problems and disparities across the country go much further back. I intend to write more on that. Follow my blog if you are interested. But this post was already at 15,000 words so I just wanted to focus on the direct before and after impacts of busing in Boston.

Forced integration, while obviously not perfect, was necessary to start solving some big problems, even if it caused some new problems of its own.

No, in Boston, it failed in every single way. And there is no reason to think mass forced integration is necessary or even net helpful with regards to fixing problems of racial disparities.

Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by brownbat on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @08:31PM (#13226084)
It's definitely well cited, but the issues you lay out are completely orthogonal to my concerns, which aren't primarily about race or integration.

If you are at a failing school and can get to a good school and want to learn, it seems immoral to force you to stay at the failing school.

Your thoughts about race relations or the quality of particular facilities don't really move me on this point.

Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by greghendershott on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @09:03AM (#13219820)
> If you can afford to live in an area with high property taxes, the US school system is great, your kids probably go to a great school

Such affluent towns are effectively private schools by other means.

They are a kind of boarding school where the entire family resides.

Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by michael_h on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @09:16AM (#13219938)
Just to clarify: if you rent an apartment that is in an area with high property taxes, you still get to go to the same local school as the people who own their homes.
Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by Symmetry on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @09:33AM (#13220078)
Yes, but these towns go to great lengths in their zoning codes to exclude affordable apartments. If we could decouple education from locale then maybe there wouldn't be so many municipalities trying to explicitly prevent affordable housing.
Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by briandear on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @10:45AM (#13220768)
And yet those opposed to school choice are the very ones whose contituencies would benefit most. Being against school choice is almost a liberal mantra; likely because the teachers unions are major contributors to Democrat politicians. They also oppose charter schools for the same reason. Look at Elizabeth Warren's flip flop on charter school quotas in Massachusetts; it wasn't an accident hat she received significant campaign donations from teachers unions before she took her 'principled' stand favoring keeping quotas low.
Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by mywittyname on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @11:19AM (#13221177)
I support free choice in education because it's fair and gives poor students with dedicated parents a chance to get a great education.

I oppose private, for profit charter schools because they are notorious for corruption and poor education in both the college and K-12 sectors.

There are regions where parents can choose the public school their kids attend. My home city does exactly that and is home to some top-notch magnet schools which have graduated several famous individuals.

Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by brownbat on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @08:42PM (#13226143)
> I oppose private, for profit charter schools because they are notorious for corruption and poor education in both the college and K-12 sectors.

I've heard the same complaints about corruption in teachers unions and poor education at urban non-charters. Everyone has their own examples for each side of the argument.

I can never tell how much of the pro- or anti- charter allegations are politically motivated or real science.

Best option I have is to rely on actual research. Stanford provides some periodic in depth studies of school performance, and has found that "across 41 regions, urban charter schools on average achieve significantly greater student success in both math and reading."

http://urbancharters.stanford.edu/news.php

That's heavily caveated. There are regional variances. Maybe charters don't outpace peers outside of urban environments. Still, it's enough for me not to dismiss them out of hand.

Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by jefurii on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @01:21PM (#13222442)
"School choice" is code for rich people sending their kids to private schools and not contribute to the public good, or for businesses trying to squeeze profit out of taxpayer money. I'm sick of that bullshit.
Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by sjg007 on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @09:21AM (#13219981)
Yes but the rents are high!
Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by spacemanmatt on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @11:20AM (#13221194)
Those apartments are high-rent compared to areas near districts with lesser schools. I guarantee, every realtor factors the local school quality into house valuations.
Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by kefka on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @11:15AM (#13221140)
I listened to that last one..

It tells me how tenuous local government really is, and how usurpation of local government isn't really that terribly difficult.

Yeah, in that case it was Hasidic Jews. I'm shocked that there wasn't more anti-semetic actions, primarily because the Jews there were trying to turn the local educational system into one for them. But I digress; it would, and has been the same for Christian control as well.

So to discuss further; how does one prevent takeovers of simple majority trouncing the significant minority (technically 50% - 1) with onerous laws? How would one make a government that is resistant to takeovers, and still maintain democratic principles? Are those 2 ideas incompatible?

Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by brownbat on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @08:50PM (#13226181)
The Federalist Papers have a few good ideas on this.

Next best thing to finding a philosopher king is to try to create lots of warring interest groups that prevent each other from doing much at all. Or maybe make everything take supermajorities...

In a small setting like a school district, it's not clear there's any way to protect the rights of a minor subset of the population without simply granting them disproportionate power and making the other subset of the population the maligned group.

If group A wants x, and group B wants y, then you can either solve it by majoritarian or anti-majoritarian rules. Depending on the issue, I want majorities to decide in some cases, and not on others. I don't feel like issues of slavery, for example, are appropriate democratic questions.

You could put a special court on top of the structure with the goal of looking out a sort of "Rawlsian fairness," trying to seek the outcome that both parties would agree to if they were both spending some time in each others' shoes.

I'll admit I don't know what the fair resolution should be in a school district where a majority of parents prefer no school taxes and no public schools, just that people seem to get pretty unfairly hurt as this one unfolded.

Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by kombucha2 on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @01:59PM (#13222794)
>Are those 2 ideas incompatible?

Well that is that the point of a republic/representative democracy/federalism?

Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by lintiness on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @09:56AM (#13220291)
property taxes in the suburbs of denver are on the order of .5% a year. compare that to the suburbs of chicago where they're north of 2% a year. the school quality and education provided are AT LEAST SIMILAR.

the difference in cost is a product of two things: pensions and legacy costs (overly rich in chicago), and population growth. chicago has become a game of musical chairs where the last man standing has to pay the retired teachers. north shore property values reflect this reality.

Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by hash-set on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @09:38AM (#13220116)
Not true in MN--you can open enroll your kids in any district. You may not get the exact school you want due to demographics, but it's still a valid counter-example.

By the way, why do you think wealthier people shouldn't get more advantages in life? I'm all for trying to pull people up by their bootstraps, but we can't just level everything out in some misguided attempt at 'fairness.' You will never achieve that fairness. The wealthy will always find ways to gain an advantage.

Sucks about that high school, but a lot of these areas need serious political reform first before anything else can get fixed.

Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by nkrisc on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @10:04AM (#13220364)
> By the way, why do you think wealthier people shouldn't get more advantages in life?

Sure, let wealthy ADULTS have more advantages. However, children have no say in their circumstances, so I do think it is right to at least give CHILDREN equal opportunity and resources.

Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by SapphireSun on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @10:54AM (#13220874)
Agree with your point, but bear in mind that any time you use caps lock on the internet for emphasis you start to look like a yelling crazy person and it reduces the impact of your argument regardless of its correctness.
Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by hash-set on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @04:05PM (#13223960)
Focus on what I said: You can never achieve that. The wealthy will always find ways to undo whatever leveling you attempt. The elite social class in the US is its own little society and most of us are not in it!
Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by brownbat on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @08:52PM (#13226189)
> You can never achieve that.

You can't live forever but I still believe in hospitals.

[dead]
Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by nkrisc on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @12:43PM (#13222040)
There isn't a correlation? I'll have to look more into that but it seems to me you picked the one notable exception. The cultural problems are describe are the symptoms of much larger problems, particularly systemic and deliberate deprivation of resources and opportunities for more than a century. You are correct to an extent though that part of that problem is political: the lack of political will to spend any amount of money and effort to seriously interrupt that vicious cycle.
Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by hash-set on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @04:07PM (#13223981)
Well, we have thrown welfare at what? Three generations now? How has that worked out? It hasn't. We're right back where we began but now with three generations of people who have never worked for a living.
Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by nkrisc on Wednesday December 21, 2016 @10:49AM (#13229988)
That's because you can't just throw money at people and tell them to better themselves. It starts with drumroll a solid educational and support system. And we've come full circle.
Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by coldpie on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @09:54AM (#13220279)
> By the way, why do you think wealthier people shouldn't get more advantages in life?

When you're talking about fundamental education of your population, this is a pretty short-sighted argument. Under-education means fewer skilled workers and more bad decision making, both of which will have an impact on Mr. Rich. Mr. Rich has a personal interest in ensuring a good education for everyone.

Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by throwaway729 on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @01:34PM (#13222561)
That's assuming Mr. Rich controls capital. But a lot of Mr Riches aren't actually very rich -- they just happen to be well paid laborers in high prestige fields.
Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by Pharylon on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @09:57AM (#13220307)
> By the way, why do you think wealthier people shouldn't get more advantages in life?

Wealthy people will always have nicer cars and better vacations and bigger houses, but that doesn't mean the children of poor people should be relegated to terrible schools where they'll have no future.

Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by lintiness on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @10:00AM (#13220328)
sorry, but schools are a lot less important than families.
Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by Pharylon on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @10:13AM (#13220455)
It's not either/or, it's both/and. Having parents that are willing and able to be involved with their children is huge, but going to a good school is to. The top rated comment linked to a This American Life story on achievement gap and how busing poor black students to white neighborhoods in the 80s and 90s almost magically improved their scores.

Don't forget that part of being an involved parent and making sure your kids get a good education is, critically, getting them in a good school.

Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by lintiness on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @11:06AM (#13221038)
plenty of home schooled kids do just fine without attending "good schools".
Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by athenot on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @10:17AM (#13220482)
True. And the poor have severely amputated family time due to job requirements. If both parents work a combined 3 jobs (and probably don't have the luxury of personal transportation, meaning increased transit times), how many hours are left with their children?

Yes, family education cannot be fully replaced by school instruction. But the reality for many struggling families is that they need as much help from the schools as possible.

I'm very pro-family but I take issue at the wealthy who point their fingers at struggling/broken families who haven't been dealt the same cards in life, and justifying blame by judging their lifestyle.

Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by indigo_rex on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @10:12AM (#13220449)
They're both important, and one could argue that schools are more important to children with less supportive families. You also have to consider what is breaking up the families you appear to be referencing - over-policing, redlining, etc. Even if you come to the conclusion that the poor deserve everything they get (which would be a myopic conclusion), why should children suffer for the sins of their parents?
Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by CJefferson on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @10:40AM (#13220729)
In that case, let's do inverted funding -- we seriously underfund schools in rich districts, and overfund in poor ones.
Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by lintiness on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @11:09AM (#13221067)
"under" and "over" fund are subjective measures of nothing. the us spends substantially more per pupil than it did 40 years ago with roughly the same results.

further, we spend more per pupil than other developed countries that are delivering superior results.

Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by ohyes on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @09:58AM (#13220308)
Wealthier people do have more advantages in life. It's tautological to the extent that it describes what it is to be wealthy.

We're talking about public education though, ideally, public education would have a universally high standard, and making funding for public education based on something like property values ensures that in certain areas it will be underfunded.

So it's really about whether we take universal public education seriously or if we're just providing education to some and a state sponsored daycare service to others.

Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by hash-set on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @04:09PM (#13223998)
But it doesn't matter how it gets funded, it will always be chronically under-funded! I have watched this going on for thirty years! There is something inherently wrong with public education systems. I don't know if it is the unions or what, but no matter how much money we throw at them, they are always under-funded. It's amazing.
Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by ohyes on Wednesday December 21, 2016 @01:10AM (#13227132)
This is a pretty interesting chart.

https://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d10/tables/dt10_083.asp

If you go and plug the numbers in from 1970 to something that adjusts for inflation to ~2008, it doesn't seem that teacher salaries have really changed that much, maybe a 10% increase on average? Hardly seems like throwing tons of money at the problem.

Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by masonic on Wednesday December 21, 2016 @04:26AM (#13227836)
It's not adjusted for reduced time spent on actual classroom and prep time or for increased benefits and pensions.
Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by ryandrake on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @10:00AM (#13220326)
Yes, the wealthy will always find ways to gain an advantage. That doesn't mean society should design the system to given an inherent advantage to them from the start. At least make the system fair and make the wealthy have to find a loophole.
Re:If the U.S. Won't Pay Its Teachers, China Will by jschwartzi on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @09:53AM (#13220260)
> By the way, why do you think wealthier people shouldn't get more advantages in life?

He's not saying that. The idea he's espousing is closer to the idea that there are lots of talented kids in poor districts that get completely left behind because they live in a poor area. The only way to solve that is to provide some funding, and funding is scarce in poor districts.