Re:IPhone, Gizmodo, and moral clarity about crime
by illumin8 on Wednesday May 05, 2010 @03:11PM
(#1322191)
Your argument seems to be: everybody is doing it, so it's not morally wrong.
Would you feel the same way if it was your intellectual property that was stolen? What if you spent the last year of your life in stealth mode, working 120 hour weeks and Gizmodo published your business plan on the web for everyone to see?
Re:IPhone, Gizmodo, and moral clarity about crime
by _delirium on Wednesday May 05, 2010 @04:11PM
(#1322400)
It's more like: this isn't morally wrong in the sense that stealing someone's iPhone is wrong, but morally wrong in the sense that corporate espionage is wrong, which is a whole different and fairly complex beast.
Mostly, I don't think it's any worse when Gizmodo publishes it on the web for all to see than when the tech companies buy and teardown "found" prototypes. If people want a wholesale clampdown on that sort of thing, applied evenly, that might be worth considering.
Re:IPhone, Gizmodo, and moral clarity about crime
by chaosmachine on Wednesday May 05, 2010 @03:53PM
(#1322323)
Sounds like good publicity to me. Especially if you've already got that much (6000+ hours) of a headstart on your competition.
Re:IPhone, Gizmodo, and moral clarity about crime
by anigbrowl on Wednesday May 05, 2010 @03:58PM
(#1322338)
nobody important ever goes to jail for it
This might have something to do with the fact that the US doesn't have any extradition treaties with China or Taiwan. People do go to jail over this if their activities are discovered while they're in US jurisdiction.
Re:IPhone, Gizmodo, and moral clarity about crime
by _delirium on Wednesday May 05, 2010 @04:13PM
(#1322406)
The management of these companies is mostly in the U.S. and knows about it, though, even if they're careful never to themselves touch the "found" prototypes.
Re:IPhone, Gizmodo, and moral clarity about crime
by anigbrowl on Wednesday May 05, 2010 @04:29PM
(#1322467)
Perhaps so, but in most economic espionage cases the police are tipped off by the competitors to whom the secrets are offered - possibly out of fear that they're being set up for a sting, but that's neither here nor there.
Yes, technically selling found property is a crime, but morally, this looks more like a trade-secret dispute between businesses than a normal stolen-property dispute, i.e. the harms suffered are not primarily the loss of the device, but of the secret information. And I think people are pretty jaded when it comes to inter-business trade-secret/corporate-espionage sorts of disputes, because it happens all the time and nobody important ever goes to jail for it, even though there's a lot of wink-wink in which executives are aware of it.
The main difference here seems that it was made public instead of kept secret, and the people doing it were amateurs. If Gizmodo were a consulting firm instead of tabloid, paid $5k to see the prototype for a bit, took a bunch of photos and information, quietly returned it or didn't, and then quietly sold that info to one of Apple's competitors, we probably would never have heard of it. (There's a whole little cottage industry doing teardowns of "found" hardware.) I wouldn't be surprised if Jobs himself has purchased such information at some point in his long business career--- taking care to maintain plausible deniability of course.