News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Beware of Developers Who Do Negative Work by lmm on Monday December 19, 2016 @07:11AM (#13210917)
> I'm also involved in an education program for children and as a matter of fact computer science is among the most difficult subjects to teach, right up there with math. Yes, you can increase interest and engagement by better teaching methods (e.g. playing and building games), but that CS is hard is indisputable.

I'll dispute it. I did a year of a split maths/computer science degree, found the computer science easy, and so shifted into the maths degree (on the grounds that I was confident I could teach myself the computer science degree if need be, whereas I wouldn't be able to learn the maths without teaching). Now I work as a programmer.

Most of the best programmers I've worked with have had non-CS degrees - mostly mathematics/physics, but a few from chemistry/biology/engineering, even one historian. I would sooner trust a straight IQ test than CS exercises like reversing a binary tree - the first selects for general intelligence, the second selects for general intelligence plus having sat in a CS class and/or read some CS books, and is no more relevant to day-to-day programming work.

Re:Beware of Developers Who Do Negative Work by aninhumer on Monday December 19, 2016 @08:24AM (#13211197)
As I happen to know which course you're talking about, I would point out that the module of CS you took was the far easier half of the first year material, which was open to people from a variety of other subjects, and designed with that in mind. (And indeed, the Maths dept recognises this and doesn't reduce the workload to compensate for Maths students who choose it.)

While I wouldn't say the rest of the course pushed me exceptionally hard, and I do wonder if Mathematics might have been more useful overall, I don't think that module is particularly representative of the difficulty of the CS course.

Re:Beware of Developers Who Do Negative Work by lmm on Monday December 19, 2016 @08:55AM (#13211359)
> As I happen to know which course you're talking about, I would point out that the module of CS you took was the far easier half of the first year material, which was open to people from a variety of other subjects, and designed with that in mind. (And indeed, the Maths dept recognises this and doesn't reduce the workload to compensate for Maths students who choose it.)

I did everything other than the hardware module (digital electronics) AIUI? (Which was maybe the hardest part for some people, but doesn't really correspond to the kind of thing that's asked in interviews).

Re:Beware of Developers Who Do Negative Work by aninhumer on Monday December 19, 2016 @09:17AM (#13211488)
My understanding is that your course sits one of the two CS Papers? They tend to move modules around a lot, but based on a quick look through past years' material, I'm fairly sure Paper 2 would have covered significantly more than Digital Electronics in your year.
Re:Beware of Developers Who Do Negative Work by lmm on Monday December 19, 2016 @09:44AM (#13211662)
I don't remember which paper was which. I think my year ended up doing more courses than they'd originally planned because of a miscommunication between the departments about what was going to be covered where? I did an ML course, a Java course, Operating Systems, and part of Data Structures & Algorithms before I looked through the notes and decided I knew it all (and I think I also glanced over notes for a discrete maths course earlier in the year?). Certainly when comparing notes with full ("50%") compsci friends I remember Digital Electronics was the only obvious thing I was missing.

Come to think about it I do remember talking about a friend's question on sorting algorithms in an exam that I hadn't done myself. So possibly Data Structures & Algorithms wasn't on the exam for me? Afraid it was too long ago to remember exactly.