I used:
- avant window navigator (https://launchpad.net/awn)
- Murrina Eternal Blue theme from http://www.gnome-look.org/content/show.php/Murrina-Eternal_b... (uses murrine engine)
- Humanoid-OSX Black window border (http://www.gnome-look.org/content/show.php/Humanoid-OSX-Blac...)
- Emacs theming: Clarity and Beauty (https://gna.org/projects/color-theme)
- Conky system monitor (yet to create my own config file)
edit: Try gyachi for better yahoo chat support. Haven't used it myself, but it seems to be pretty popular on the forum.
Window Theme: http://www.gnome-look.org/content/show.php/Humanoid+-+OSX+-+...
I think I got the background from DeviantArt, not positive though. And I just messed with the window color settings until the menus were a grey / titanium color.
edit: make sure you install the compizconfig-settings-manager package. That gives you the ability to set your own compiz settings for animations, transparencies, etc.
a good place to start for appearance is http://www.gnome-look.org
as far as apps go, here's what I have running: VLC (multi-format media player), songbird, deluge (GNOME BitTorrent client), Eclipse, GnomeBaker, Avant Window Navigator (OS X-like dock), Blender (3D authoring software), Inkscape(vector imaging), Picasa, some others... of course, all the plugins, apache, languages / libraries for whatever you plan on running...
There are a lot of different ways you can go with it; it would help if you gave an idea of what functionality you 're looking for. Is this for strictly dev, or do you do image / graphics work, etc? The Ubuntu forums are a good place to start.