1) There is evidence that prolonged lack of sleep (6h/night or less) leads to an early death
2) Many polyphasic sleep methods involve dramatically less sleep than 6h a night
3) There is no implied correlation between those two statements, but a cautious person who wants to maximise their chance of living as long as possible would infer that:
- Given the lack of data, it is probably a better idea to avoid polyphasic sleep altogether until proper studies are conducted.
Previously, the argument was that there is no evidence linking lack of sleep with death, therefore why not give polyphasic sleep a go. I think that argument is not valid anymore.
Edit: Of course, that's assuming the study results are actually correct, which according to ajkirwin's comments, they're possibly not.
Monophasic sleep deprivation doesn't have as many cycles of REM sleep as polyphasic sleep, given equals amounts of time slept.
To compare monophasic and polyphasic a study should include both types of sleepers.
Perhaps such study could find a proper pool of candidates in forums like