News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Postmodernism Generator by mistersquid on Sunday December 18, 2016 @02:13PM (#13207084)
I was mistaken about the peer review, as _Social Text_ was not peer-reviewed.

The article I was remembering discusses how Sokal refused to make the edits requested by _Social Text_'s editors. [0]

  > Having established an interest in Sokal's article, we did
  > ask him informally to revise the piece. We requested him (a)
  > to excise a good deal of the philosophical speculation and
  > (b) to excise most of his footnotes. Sokal seemed resistant
  > to any revisions, and indeed insisted on retaining almost
  > all of his footnotes and bibliographic apparatus on the
  > grounds that his peers, in science, expected extensive
  > documentation of this sort. Judging from his response, it
  > was clear that his article would appear as is, or not at
  > all. At this point, Sokal was designated as a "difficult,
  > uncooperative author," a category well known to journal
  > editors. We judged his article too much trouble to publish,
  > not yet on the reject pile, perhaps of sufficient interest
  > to readers if published in the company of related articles.
http://linguafranca.mirror.theinfo.org/9607/mst.html
Re:Postmodernism Generator by FabHK on Sunday December 18, 2016 @02:36PM (#13207176)
It is understandable that Sokal was hesitant to remove the footnotes: they contain many of the best jokes and outrageous postmodern quotes (and also make it quite clear to any reader with a basic knowledge of the sciences that this was not meant seriously).