News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why won't biologists say that animals might be conscious? by robbrown451 on Saturday December 17, 2016 @02:28PM (#13202019)
The word consciousness, as most people seem to use it, is not defined in a way that science can touch it. It only makes sense from a certain perspective, and that is not the perspective of science.

Asking "is some entity X conscious?" is sort of like asking "last December 6, what were the chances of there being a big earthquake in Indonesia the following day?" The only way to answer a "what are the chances?" type question is from the perspective of someone with limited knowledge. From the point of view of us, today, we don't have limited knowledge, we know the earthquake happened. So the question doesn't make sense.

Likewise with consciousness. You can't analyze it from a perspective other than that of the entity in question. It doesn't make sense.

There are plenty of other ways of defining consciousness that make it more accessible to science. But you might find it difficult to make sure it isn't inclusive of things that you don't consider conscious, like a self driving car or even your phone.

Re:Why won't biologists say that animals might be conscious? by judahmeek on Saturday December 17, 2016 @03:17PM (#13202294)
I once read someone theorize that the terms "consciousness" and "artificial intelligence" are much like the dragons & sea monsters that used to be drawn on ancient maps. "Consciousness" is what we don't know about how the human mind works and "artificial intelligence" is what we don't know about how to get a computer to work like the human mind. Once we learn something new about the human mind or getting a computer to act like the human mind, it is no longer "consciousness" or "artificial intelligence", but is filed away as psychology, neuro-biology, machine learning, or some other field of study.

Basically, because science can not define terms like "consciousness", because the term represents what we don't know and we can not define what we don't know.

Re:Why won't biologists say that animals might be conscious? by pixl97 on Saturday December 17, 2016 @03:31PM (#13202379)
Re:Why won't biologists say that animals might be conscious? by mikeash on Saturday December 17, 2016 @02:31PM (#13202035)
I think this is not quite true. If an entity describes its own consciousness without any outside prompting, I think that's pretty good evidence that it actually is conscious. The odds of a non-conscious entity acting that way are minimal. This is why I'm pretty sure other people are conscious, for example. Of course, it doesn't work so well with animals....
Re:Why won't biologists say that animals might be conscious? by robbrown451 on Saturday December 17, 2016 @03:00PM (#13202193)
Ok, so say a self driving car has a natural language interface. It can describe everything it knows about its environment, its relationship to its environment, and so on. And pretty much anything else that a decent phone or computer could talk about, given a few more years of advances in natural language processing, machine learning, etc.

What are examples of things it might say that would cause you to conclude it must be "conscious", by your definition?

Also, you seem to have ruled out animals like dogs or chimps. I've never heard of one them them describing their own consciousness. Are you saying they aren't conscious if they can't describe it? (should we not be concerned if an animal is in pain, if it can't describe pain to your satisfaction?)

Re:Why won't biologists say that animals might be conscious? by mikeash on Saturday December 17, 2016 @03:37PM (#13202406)
A self-driving car built by humans would convince me of its own consciousness if it started describing to me its own consciousness, the idea of qualia, etc. But, crucially, only if it could be demonstrated that it had never been exposed to these concepts. Which is probably impossible.

I'm not saying animals aren't conscious. I'm saying they can't prove it. Remember, if A implies B, then not-A does not imply not-B. I'm saying that if a creature can describe its own consciousness without having learned of the concept elsewhere, that's good evidence that it's conscious. If it can't, that doesn't mean it's not.

Re:Why won't biologists say that animals might be conscious? by drjesusphd on Sunday December 18, 2016 @06:29AM (#13205394)
> But, crucially, only if it could be demonstrated that it had never been exposed to these concepts. Which is probably impossible.

Not at all. I remember having qualia-like questions at 5 or 6. Particularly, "do you see red the same way or do we just have the same name for that color?" An AI could definitely ask these kinds of questions without prompting.

Re:Why won't biologists say that animals might be conscious? by mikeash on Sunday December 18, 2016 @11:14PM (#13209472)
How certain are you that you were never exposed to those idea previously, possibly in passing or even without explicitly stating them?
Re:Why won't biologists say that animals might be conscious? by robbrown451 on Saturday December 17, 2016 @03:45PM (#13202460)
Are you aware of a human ever describing their own consciousness or qualia without having been exposed to the idea first?

I understand your "can't prove it" regarding animals, but if your only way of "proving it" doesn't work for most examples, I would continue to say the concept is one that is not defined in a meaningful way, at least not meaningful when it comes to any sort of scientific analysis or even being able to say whether an entity other than yourself has it.

Re:Why won't biologists say that animals might be conscious? by mikeash on Saturday December 17, 2016 @04:16PM (#13202678)
I know at least one human did without being exposed to it, and I know at least one other human is also conscious. For me, this is sufficient evidence to say that humans in general are likely conscious. It would be very weird for the two of us to be different in this way.

I agree that it remains fairly poorly defined, but I don't think it's correct to say that you can't even analyze it from the outside. There are many circumstances where you can't, but you can at least glean a little bit of information in some cases.

Re:Why won't biologists say that animals might be conscious? by robbrown451 on Saturday December 17, 2016 @06:53PM (#13203465)
How do you know one human did? It is quite possible the concept evolved over a very long time, so no single human came up with the idea.
Re:Why won't biologists say that animals might be conscious? by mikeash on Saturday December 17, 2016 @07:34PM (#13203633)
I don't think that matters much. The idea that it would evolve over time in a population where nobody experiences consciousness doesn't strike me as remotely probable.
Re:Why won't biologists say that animals might be conscious? by robbrown451 on Saturday December 17, 2016 @08:17PM (#13203792)
So, you've convinced yourselves that humans are conscious (whatever that means).

The point, though, was how do we tell if something else is. You haven't given us much in order to show one way or another if either an animal or a human-created thing is. So I'm saying the concept is so weakly defined as to be essentially meaningless.

Also, you say that because humans have somehow developed the ability to talk about something, it must exist. What exactly have they said? That there is this thing that they can't define objectively but they swear it exists because it seems like it does? And that proves that it exists? Do you not see how circular that is?

Re:Why won't biologists say that animals might be conscious? by mikeash on Saturday December 17, 2016 @08:38PM (#13203856)
It would be circular if it weren't so intimately connected with the very concept of "seems."

How would humans have arrived at the idea of qualia if they didn't experience it? What's your proposed alternate explanation for this?

Re:Why won't biologists say that animals might be conscious? by robbrown451 on Saturday December 17, 2016 @09:10PM (#13203930)
Alternate explanation for the fact that people describe having qualia?

I've seen qualia described as "qualities or feelings, like redness or pain, as considered independently of their effects on behavior and from whatever physical circumstances give rise to them."

I go into a good bit of detail about how such a thing is unsurprising in this thing I wrote (8 years ago). http://www.karmatics.com/docs/violet.html

The thing is, you have this intuitive feeling that something (say, redness) is real. Fine. But the external behavior you are describing as "proof"? I would consider that beyond weak. There is nothing at all surprising about an entity that can communicate, expressing that there is a certain something that it is having trouble communicating directly.

Re:Why won't biologists say that animals might be conscious? by mikeash on Sunday December 18, 2016 @12:01AM (#13204424)
If I"ve understood you correctly so far, your overall approach to the problem seems to be that if we can't define it in a reasonably rigorous way, then we don't really know what we're referring to, and so it's not real. For example:

> I can't help but have a lingering feeling that there must be more to the concept of "subjective experience" than "arbitrary details of the internal implementation of an algorithm that don't affect the results," but alas, I can't come up with words to describe whatever else there might be.

I sympathize, but disagree. It's quite clear to me that the sensation of perceiving things, whether it's redness or sweetness or pain, has something about it that is not just arbitrary details of how my brain works. There is a me which is qualitatively different from the rest of the universe in some way. No, I can't really describe it very well, but that doesn't make it any less real.

You do have me wondering, though, if maybe not everyone has this. Take aphantasia, for example. Some people can see things in their mind, and some can't. For a long time, neither group realized that the other even existed. Those who could see things just assumed everyone could, and those who couldn't assumed everyone couldn't. Maybe some subset of humanity consists of p-zombies, and they only know of these concepts because they've heard of them from others.

Re:Why won't biologists say that animals might be conscious? by robbrown451 on Monday December 19, 2016 @02:53AM (#13210119)
> If I"ve understood you correctly so far, your overall approach to the problem seems to be that if we can't define it in a reasonably rigorous way, then we don't really know what we're referring to, and so it's not real.

I don't think that's exactly what I'm saying. Maybe I am saying that if you can't define it in a reasonably rigorous way, that it doesn't make a lot of sense to claim that it absolutely must exist. There is a difference.

Of course this is real to you. But I am saying it is not real from the perspective of science. For instance, it isn't something that can have value that natural selection could have selected for.

It is, by nature, subjective. And that basically means "from a particular perspective." If you view it from a different perspective -- for instance, the external objective view that is appropriate in a scientific context -- it disappears.

Re:Why won't biologists say that animals might be conscious? by rubberstamp on Saturday December 17, 2016 @03:43PM (#13202443)
Even amongst same species things might be different. Take humans for example. Women and men have no clue how each other think about certain things that are very closely related to gender because they don't experience what other gender go through and experiences everyday. Some ant species farm coffee trees. Many rear aphids. It is very good enough evidence that they are conscious. Similarly animals and birds. They all know enough about their environment to identify their family/tribe, find food, etc. We may never understand ways of a cat unless we become one and live as a cat. Human kernal is incompatible with cat kernal and so for many inputs native to a cat we may not even know those exists. Like we didn't knew about animals communicating in frequency outside our freq etc until we developed tech to detect such sound. Its so amazing.