Re:Why won't biologists say that animals might be conscious?
by psyc on Saturday December 17, 2016 @01:49PM
(#13201833)
I'd happily forfeit all my Christmas presents this year if internet people would all stop noising up discussions of consciousness with protests that it's ill-defined. One meaning is the opposite of unconscious. Another perfectly fine meaning is having subjective experience. Just like every other word with shades of meaning, we can tell from context - e.g. if the one using the word is a philosopher, or an anesthesiologist. Neither necessarily implies self-awareness. That's a third thing. Poorly understood, yes. Ill-defined - I just don't see it.
Re:Why won't biologists say that animals might be conscious?
by harryjo on Saturday December 17, 2016 @02:34PM
(#13202055)
you just gave two vague definitions and also said it has shades of meaning -- that's what "ill-defined" is.
Re:Why won't biologists say that animals might be conscious?
by robbrown451 on Saturday December 17, 2016 @02:21PM
(#13201978)
For self awareness and subjective experience: can you tell me if a self driving car has either of those?
Another use (misuse?) of the word is to mean 'self-aware'. That one is harder to measure. But plenty of animals seem to meet that bar - if they recognize themselves in a mirror; if they can empathize with others etc.