News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why won't biologists say that animals might be conscious? by JoeAltmaier on Saturday December 17, 2016 @01:11PM (#13201672)
That old word - 'conscious'. We misuse it terribly. For instance we know when someone is 'unconscious', which should reasonably be the converse of being conscious. By that view, every animal that is aware and responding to its environment is conscious.

Another use (misuse?) of the word is to mean 'self-aware'. That one is harder to measure. But plenty of animals seem to meet that bar - if they recognize themselves in a mirror; if they can empathize with others etc.

Re:Why won't biologists say that animals might be conscious? by psyc on Saturday December 17, 2016 @01:49PM (#13201833)
I'd happily forfeit all my Christmas presents this year if internet people would all stop noising up discussions of consciousness with protests that it's ill-defined. One meaning is the opposite of unconscious. Another perfectly fine meaning is having subjective experience. Just like every other word with shades of meaning, we can tell from context - e.g. if the one using the word is a philosopher, or an anesthesiologist. Neither necessarily implies self-awareness. That's a third thing. Poorly understood, yes. Ill-defined - I just don't see it.
Re:Why won't biologists say that animals might be conscious? by harryjo on Saturday December 17, 2016 @02:34PM (#13202055)
you just gave two vague definitions and also said it has shades of meaning -- that's what "ill-defined" is.
Re:Why won't biologists say that animals might be conscious? by robbrown451 on Saturday December 17, 2016 @02:21PM (#13201978)
For self awareness and subjective experience: can you tell me if a self driving car has either of those?