Re:Hans Rosling doesn’t consider himself an optimist or pess...
by ebbv on Saturday December 17, 2016 @09:33AM
(#13200835)
His famous TED talk against doing anything about climate change (a position which I think he later rescinded?) and instead focusing those funds on health and poverty reduction instead is littered with it, and based on a false assumption to begin with; that there is a pile of money that is already set aside and we're all in charge of directing it.
The reality is far more complicated. We aren't taking money away from fighting Malaria when we raise taxes on gas guzzling cars, to give just one example.
Re:Hans Rosling doesn’t consider himself an optimist or pess...
by jessriedel on Saturday December 17, 2016 @09:58AM
(#13200918)
You're disagreeing with his policy position. But where did he misrepresent data?
Re:Hans Rosling doesn’t consider himself an optimist or pess...
by ebbv on Saturday December 17, 2016 @10:23AM
(#13201003)
I just explained that. He misrepresents the data by presenting it as an either or (either we fight climate change OR we fight poverty) when it isn't. That misrepresentation distorts how you interpret all the data in his talk.
I'm not interested in nit picking back and forth. Go defend Rosling to someone else.
Re:Hans Rosling doesn’t consider himself an optimist or pess...
by jessriedel on Saturday December 17, 2016 @10:45AM
(#13201075)
I have no idea who Rosling is. That's just not what "misrepresent data" means.
Re:Hans Rosling doesn’t consider himself an optimist or pess...
by judahmeek on Saturday December 17, 2016 @10:56AM
(#13201111)
But that's not a data misrepresentation. It's a paradigm misrepresentation.
Re:Hans Rosling doesn’t consider himself an optimist or pess...
by sambe on Saturday December 17, 2016 @10:33AM
(#13201035)
In which TED talk did he advocate against doing anything about climate change?
Examples?